Inspired by Calvin Lin 2 : An open challenge to all of Brilliant

Geometry Level 5

Suppose in the previous problem B C BC may not be 10 10 i.e. there is no information about it. We only have the condition that was mentioned: A E × F A = 3 × G E × G F AE \times FA = 3 \times GE \times GF .

Then:

1) Is it possible to have: A fool-proof compasses & straightedge (which is a "scale" without graduations, i.e. basically a straight rod that cannot measure) only, construction of the Δ A B C \Delta ABC simply given length A B AB and the circumcircle of the Δ A B C \Delta ABC . (of course A B < 2 × R AB < 2\times R ) In other words, on a sheet of paper, I draw a circle out and beside it somewhere a line segment (of lesser length than the circle's diameter) and ask you to construct a triangle A B C ABC with the above property ( A E × F A = 3 × G E × G F AE \times FA = 3 \times GE \times GF ) within the circle (the circle should pass through A , B , C ) A,B,C) with the length of A B AB equal to the segment's length. Can you always do it?

2) Should the triangle be necessarily equilateral?

I am more interested in the solution! Do tell me the how or the how not and the why or the why not?!

Yes, No No, No No, Yes Yes, Yes

This section requires Javascript.
You are seeing this because something didn't load right. We suggest you, (a) try refreshing the page, (b) enabling javascript if it is disabled on your browser and, finally, (c) loading the non-javascript version of this page . We're sorry about the hassle.

1 solution

Mark Hennings
Sep 18, 2016

Start with the circumcircle Γ \Gamma and the chord A B AB .

  • Find the perpendicular bisector of A B AB . This meets A B AB at F F , and Γ \Gamma at points P , Q P,Q . Bisect the diameter P Q PQ to find the centre O O of the circumcircle.
  • Extend the line A B AB and find the point X X such that F B = B X FB = BX . Draw the circle Γ 1 \Gamma_1 which has centre X X and radius B X 3 BX\sqrt{3} . This is easy to do. For example, a circle of radius B X BX and centre B B and a circle of radius B X BX and centre F F meet at two points, both of which are a distance B X 3 BX\sqrt{3} from X X . Why do this? The circle Γ 1 \Gamma_1 is the locus of the points P P such that A P = B P 3 AP = BP\sqrt{3} , and hence the midpoint D D of B C BC must lie on Γ 1 \Gamma_1 .
  • Since O O lies on the perpendicular bisector of B C BC , the angle O D B = 9 0 \angle ODB = 90^\circ . If we construct the midpoint Y Y of O B OB and draw the circle Γ 2 \Gamma_2 with centre Y Y that passes through O O and B B , then the point D D must lie on Γ 2 \Gamma_2 as well.
  • Having identified the point D D , extend the line B D BD to meet the circumcircle Γ \Gamma at C C , and we are done.

Note that since Γ 1 \Gamma_1 and Γ 2 \Gamma_2 meet at two points, there are two possible triangles that can be constructed for any particular circle Γ \Gamma and chord A B AB . The diagram shows both triangles A B C ABC and A B C ABC' .

This construction holds for any chord A B AB (if A B AB is a diameter the triangles A B C ABC and A B C ABC' are congruent), and hence A B C ABC does not have to be equilateral.

0 pending reports

×

Problem Loading...

Note Loading...

Set Loading...