Inspired by Satyajit Mohanty

a a 5 = b b \large{a^{a^{5}}=b^{b}}

There exist n 1 n \geq 1 pair(s) of positive integers ( a i , b i ) (a_{i},b_{i}) with a i , b i > 1 a_{i},b_{i} > 1 such that the above equation is satisfied.

Find i = 1 n ( a i + b i ) \displaystyle \sum_{i=1}^{n} (a_{i}+b_{i}) .


Inspiration .


The answer is 260.

This section requires Javascript.
You are seeing this because something didn't load right. We suggest you, (a) try refreshing the page, (b) enabling javascript if it is disabled on your browser and, finally, (c) loading the non-javascript version of this page . We're sorry about the hassle.

2 solutions

Zk Lin
Feb 17, 2016

All variables introduced in this solution are positive integers.

It is obvious that b > a b>a .

Write a = k c , b = k d a=kc, b=kd where k = gcd ( a , b ) 1 k=\gcd(a,b) \geq 1 . Substituting into the equation yields:

( k c ) k 5 c 5 = ( k d ) k d {(kc)}^{k^{5}c^{5}}={(kd)}^{kd}

k k 5 c 5 k d = d k d c k 5 c 5 {k}^{k^{5}c^{5}-kd}=\frac{d^{kd}}{c^{k^{5}c^{5}}}

Since gcd ( c , d ) = 1 \gcd(c,d)=1 and the L.H.S. is an positive integer, this is only possible if c = 1 c=1 .

Therefore, we can write b = a d , d N + b=ad, d \in \mathbb{N^{+}} . Substituting this into the original equation, we have

a a 5 = d d a a d a a^{a^{5}}=d^{da}a^{da}

a a 5 d a = d d a a^{a^{5}-da}=d^{da}

a a 4 d = d d a^{a^{4}-d}=d^{d}

Note that if a > d a>d , then L.H.S. > R.H.S. as long as a > 2 1 3 a>2^{\frac{1}{3}} since a 4 > 2 a > 2 d a^{4}>2a>2d .

Therefore, a d a\leq d and we can write d = e a , e N + d=ea, e \in \mathbb{N^{+}} by the same argument above. Repeating the procedure above, we get

a a 3 2 e = e e a^{a^{3}-2e}=e^{e} .

Note that if a > e a>e , then L.H.S. > R.H.S. as long as a > 3 a>\sqrt{3} since a 3 > 3 a > 3 e a^{3}>3a>3e .

Therefore, a e a \leq e and we can write e = f a , f N + e=fa, f \in \mathbb{N^{+}} . Repeating the procedure above, we get

a a 2 3 f = f f a^{a^{2}-3f}=f^{f}

Note that if a > f a > f , then L.H.S. > R.H.S. as long as a > 4 a>4 since a 2 > 4 a > 4 f a^{2}>4a>4f .

We will manually check the cases for a = 2 , 3 , 4 a=2,3,4 before proceeding to assume that a f a \leq f

If a = 2 a=2 , note that 2 4 3 f = f f 2^{4-3f}=f^{f} . Since a > f a>f , this forces f = 1 f=1 , but 2 4 3 1 1 2^{4-3} \neq 1^{1} .

If a = 3 a=3 , note that 3 9 3 f = f f 3^{9-3f}=f^{f} . Since a > f a>f , this forces f = 1 f=1 or 2 2 , but the equation does not hold in either cases.

If a = 4 a=4 , note that 4 16 3 f = f f 4^{16-3f}=f^{f} . Since a > f a>f , this forces f = 1 , 2 f=1,2 or 3 3 , but equation does not hold in all 3 3 cases.

Therefore, with a f a \leq f , we can write f = g a , g N + f=ga, g \in \mathbb{N^{+}} . Repeating the procedure above, we get

a a 4 g = g g a^{a-4g}=g^{g} .

If we assume a g a \leq g and write g = h a , h N + g=ha, h \in \mathbb{N^{+}} , we get

a 1 5 h = h h a^{1-5h}=h^{h} which is impossible since we require 1 5 h > 0 1-5h>0 if h h is to be a positive integer. Therefore, we can conclude that a > g a>g .

Now, write a = j g a=jg with j > 1 , j N + j>1, j \in \mathbb{N^{+}} . We get

( j g ) j g 4 g = g g (jg)^{jg-4g}=g^{g}

( j g ) j 4 = g (jg)^{j-4}=g

j j 4 = g 5 j j^{j-4}=g^{5-j}

The only possible value j j can take is 4 4 . (You may prove this as an exercise.)

Solving the equation, we find that g = 1 g=1 . Therefore, a = 4 a=4

Write 4 4 5 = 4 1024 = 4 ( 4 ) ( 256 ) = 25 6 256 4^{4^{5}}=4^{1024}=4^{(4)(256)}=256^{256} and we are done.

The answer is therefore 4 + 256 = 260 4+256=\boxed{260}

Moderator note:

Good solution showing how to iteratively simplify this problem.

Mietantei Conan
Feb 18, 2016

Let b = a x × k b=a^x×k where x x is such that a a does not divide k k . After plugging this the equation becomes k k = a a 5 x x k^k=a^{a^{5-x}-x} . Since a a does not divide k k there must exist a prime divisor p p of a a and k k such that v p ( a ) > v p ( k ) v_{p}(a)>v_{p}(k) . The power of p p must be same in R H S RHS and L H S LHS thus giving k = ( a 5 x x ) × v p ( a ) v p ( k ) > a 5 x x k=\frac {(a^{5-x}-x)×v_{p}(a)}{v_{p}(k)}>a^{5-x}-x --- ( i ) (i) . As b < a 5 b<a^5 we have 0 x 4 0 \leq x \leq 4 . Now we have to just check all cases from x = 0 x=0 to x = 4 x=4 . Cases x = 0 , 1 , 2 x=0,1,2 are easy to prove so I will show only x = 3 , 4 x=3,4 .
Case x = 3 x=3 . From b < a 5 b<a^5 and ( i ) (i) we get a 2 2 k < a 2 a^2-2 \leq k <a^2 . k k cannot be a 2 1 a^2-1 as it g c d ( a + 1 , a ) = 1 gcd(a+1,a)=1 . So k k is a 2 2 a^2-2 but this is not correct either as L H S LHS becomes greater than R H S RHS . No solutions in this case.

Case x = 4 x=4 From b < a 5 b<a^5 and ( i ) (i) we get a 3 k < a a-3 \leq k <a . Again we have to check k = ( a 3 ) , ( a 2 ) , ( a 1 ) k=(a-3),(a-2),(a-1) which is not very dufficult. After checking all cases in this case we get only one solution a = 4 , k = 1 a=4,k=1 i.e. a = 4 , b = 256 a=4,b=256 .

0 pending reports

×

Problem Loading...

Note Loading...

Set Loading...