Irreducible Fractions

The denominators of two irreducible fractions are 600 and 700. Find the minimum value of the denominator of their sum when it is written as an irreducible fraction.


The answer is 168.

This section requires Javascript.
You are seeing this because something didn't load right. We suggest you, (a) try refreshing the page, (b) enabling javascript if it is disabled on your browser and, finally, (c) loading the non-javascript version of this page . We're sorry about the hassle.

2 solutions

Zk Lin
Feb 19, 2016

Write A 600 + B 700 = 7 A + 6 B 4200 \frac{A}{600}+\frac{B}{700}=\frac{7A+6B}{4200} .

The prime decomposition of 4200 4200 (the denominator) is 2 3 . 3. 5 2 . 7 2^{3}.3.5^{2}.7 , we are attempting to make the numerator share as many similar factors as possible to cancel them out in order to minimize the denominator.

Note that it is impossible for 7 A + 6 B 7A+6B to be even since this implies A A must be even. However, we know that this is impossible since A A is coprime to 600 600 . Therefore, 2 3 2^{3} will remain in the denominator.

Also, it is impossible for 7 A + 6 B 7A+6B to be divisible by 3 3 since this implies A A is divisible by 3 3 . However, we know that this is impossible since A A is coprime to 600 600 . Therefore, 3 3 will remain in the denominator.

By the same reasoning, it is impossible for 7 A + 6 B 7A+6B to be divisible by 7 7 since this implies B B is divisible by 7 7 . However, we know that this is impossible since B B is coprime to 700 700 . Therefore, 7 7 will remain in the denominator.

However, it is easy to cancel out 25 25 in the denominator. Just let A = 1 , B = 3 A=1, B=3 and we get 25 4200 = 1 168 \frac{25}{4200}=\frac{1}{168} .

Therefore, the minimum value of the denominator is 168 \boxed{168} .

Moderator note:

Good clear solution.

Instead of "irreducible with", you mean "coprime to".

Excellent proof. FYI, the correct terminology is "coprime to", not "irreducible with". Individual numbers are irreducible/prime or not; being coprime describes whether two numbers have a common factor or not.

Mark Hennings - 5 years, 3 months ago

Log in to reply

Thanks. I have edited my solution accordingly.

ZK LIn - 5 years, 3 months ago

How can you know A=1, B=3 will cancel out 25 in the denominator?

Hải Trung Lê - 5 years, 3 months ago

Log in to reply

In general, any A = 25 k + 1 , B = 25 l + 3 A=25k+1, B=25l+3 will do. What I did was trying to solve 6 A + 7 B = 25 6A+7B=25 . It happens to work.

ZK LIn - 5 years, 3 months ago

Log in to reply

Oh, thank you. Anyway, great solution.

Hải Trung Lê - 5 years, 3 months ago

Exactly Same Way.

Kushagra Sahni - 5 years, 3 months ago
Zee Ell
Feb 19, 2016

We can write this problem in the form of:

a 600 \frac {a} {600} + b 700 = +\frac {b} {700}= c d \frac {c} {d} , where a, b, c, d are positive integers and gcd(a,600) = gcd(b,700) = gcd(c,d) = 1. We need to find the minimum value of d.

It is easy to see, that

a 600 \frac{a}{600} + b 700 = + \frac {b}{700}= 7 a + 6 b 4200 \frac{7a+6b}{4200}

We can get the minimum value of d by simplifying the fraction on the RHS (which therefore has to be a factor of 4200).

4200= 2 3 × 3 × 5 2 × 7 2^3×3×5^2×7

Now, we will show, that we can simplify by 5 2 = 25 5^2=25 , but not any further:

As 17×7+1×6=125 :

17 600 \frac{17}{600} + 1 700 = + \frac{1}{700}= 125 4200 = \frac {125}{4200}= 25 × 5 25 × 168 = \frac{25×5}{25×168}= 5 168 \frac{5}{168}

However, we cannot simplify by any other prime factor of 4200 (2, 3 or 7) than 5, because:

If we could simplify by 2, then there would be an m=2k (positive integer), that

7a + 6b = 2k

If we rearrange this, we get

7a = 2(k-3b)

This can only happen, if a is divisible by 2, which is impossible as gcd(a,600)=1 (the fraction is irreducible according to the question) and 2 is a factor of 600.

Similarly, we cannot simplify by 3 either, as then there would be an m=3k, 7a = 3(k-2b), a cannot be divisible by 3 (as then gcd(a,600) would be at least 3, which contradicts the condition of the question .

And we can't simplify by 7, as then there would be an n=7p, that

7a + 6b = 7p

6b = 7(a-p)

and b cannot be divisible by 7 since gcd(b,700)=1.

For the reasons above, the solution is 168 \boxed{168} .

Thanks for the solution

Aatreya Hui - 5 years, 3 months ago

Thank you for your excellent solution. May i ask you what your studying currently? I've never come across irreducible fractions before.

Sukh Singh - 5 years, 3 months ago

0 pending reports

×

Problem Loading...

Note Loading...

Set Loading...