Is Pell Relevant Here?

Given two natural numbers a a and b b satisfying the equation: . 2015 a 2 + a = 2016 b 2 + b 2015a^2+a=2016b^2+b . Will a b \sqrt{|a-b|} always be an integer?

Yes! Insufficient information No.

This section requires Javascript.
You are seeing this because something didn't load right. We suggest you, (a) try refreshing the page, (b) enabling javascript if it is disabled on your browser and, finally, (c) loading the non-javascript version of this page . We're sorry about the hassle.

1 solution

Đạt Tạ Quang
Apr 11, 2016

From the equality: 2015 a 2 + a = 2016 b 2 + b 2015a^2+a=2016b^2+b ( 1 ) (1)

We can easily find a b a \ge b .

If a = b a=b then a = b = 0 a=b=0 hence a b = 0 \sqrt{|a-b|}=0 is an integer.

If a > b a>b , we can write ( 1 ) (1) as:

b 2 = 2015 ( a 2 b 2 ) + ( a b ) b^2=2015(a^2-b^2)+(a-b)

\Rightarrow b 2 = ( a b ) [ 2015 ( a + b ) + 1 ] b^2=(a-b)[2015(a+b)+1] \Leftrightarrow b 2 = ( a b ) ( 2015 a + 2015 b + 1 ) b^2=(a-b)(2015a+2015b+1) ( 2 ) (2)

Let ( a , b ) = d (a,b)=d then a = m d a=md , b = n d b=nd , where ( m , n ) = 1 (m,n)=1 . Since a > b a>b then m > n m>n , and put m n = p > 0 m-n=p>0 .

Let ( p , n ) = x (p,n)=x then p p is divisible by x x , n n is divisible by x x , and also m m is divisible by x x . That follows x = 1 ( p , n ) = 1 x=1 \Rightarrow (p,n)=1 , and a b = p d a-b=pd .

Putting b = n d b=nd , a b = p d a-b=pd in ( 2 ) (2) , we will get

n 2 d = p ( 2015 d p + 4030 d n + 1 ) n^2d=p(2015dp+4030dn+1) ( 3 ) (3)

From ( 3 ) (3) we get n 2 d n^2d is divisible by p p and with ( p , n ) = 1 (p,n)=1 , it follows d d is divisible by p.

Also from ( 3 ) (3) we will get n 2 d = 2015 d p 2 + 4030 d n p + p n^2d=2015dp^2+4030dnp+p and then p = n 2 d 2015 d p 2 4030 d n p p=n^2d-2015dp^2-4030dnp

Hence p = d ( n 2 2015 p 2 4030 n p ) p=d(n^2-2015p^2-4030np) , i.e. p p is divisible by d d p = d \Rightarrow p=d and then a b = p d = d 2 a-b=pd=d^2 and a b = d \sqrt{|a-b|}=d is an integer.

Great explanation. But a, b cannot be zero as zero isn't a natural number.

Rajaraman Padmanabhan - 5 years, 1 month ago

Log in to reply

Thanks. I've replaced the ambiguous term "natural number" with "integer".

Calvin Lin Staff - 5 years, 1 month ago

0 pending reports

×

Problem Loading...

Note Loading...

Set Loading...