Japanese Mathematical Olympiad 2005 (Revised)

Geometry Level 4

We are given a 17 × 17 17 \times 17 array of coins with heads up. In each step, one can choose five consecutive coins in a row, column or diagonal and reverse them. Is it possible to obtain a position with all coins having tails up in a finite number of such steps?

Note: "Reverse" indicates switching from head to tail or back again, not a random flip as in probability.

Yes No

This section requires Javascript.
You are seeing this because something didn't load right. We suggest you, (a) try refreshing the page, (b) enabling javascript if it is disabled on your browser and, finally, (c) loading the non-javascript version of this page . We're sorry about the hassle.

2 solutions

Peter Csorba
Feb 22, 2021

Consider 115 red coins: In each step (horizontal, vertical, diagonal) exactly 2 of them will be flipped! Because of the parity it is not possible to have all (red) coins showing tails.

Mark Hennings
Feb 21, 2021

Consider the 17 × 17 17\times17 array of coins, and look at the special set of coins I have coloured orange. There are 7 7 such coins in each column, except for the 4 4 columns marked with a green dot, which have 6 6 such coins, and hence there are 7 × 13 + 6 × 4 = 115 7\times13 + 6\times4=115 orange coins altogether - an odd number. As the ten red rectangles show, any 5 × 1 5\times1 rectangle covers precisely two orange coins. Thus any legal move reverses the state of two orange coins, and hence the parity (evenness/oddness) of the number of orange coins that are showing Heads remains constant. Since there are an odd number of orange coins, there will always be an odd number of orange coins that show heads at any future time. If all the coins showed tails, then in particular all the orange coins would show tails, and hence there would be an even number of orange coins showing heads. This is impossible. Thus it is not possible to have all coins showing tails.

0 pending reports

×

Problem Loading...

Note Loading...

Set Loading...