Jorge's subset products

Let S = { 1 , 2 , 3 , 4 , , 2013 } S=\{1,2,3,4,\ldots, 2013\} and let n n be the smallest positive integer such that the product of any n n distinct elements in S S is divisible by 2013 2013 . What are the last 3 3 digits of n n ?

This problem is posed by Jorge T.


The answer is 981.

This section requires Javascript.
You are seeing this because something didn't load right. We suggest you, (a) try refreshing the page, (b) enabling javascript if it is disabled on your browser and, finally, (c) loading the non-javascript version of this page . We're sorry about the hassle.

7 solutions

First, we can factor 2013 = 3 11 61 2013=3 * 11 * 61 . As the product of the subset must be divisible by 2013, it will need to contain at least one multiple of each factor. As 2013 = 61 11 3 = 61 33 2013=61 * 11 * 3=61 * 33 , we know that 61 has 33 multiples between 1 and 2013. Subtracting, we find that there are 2013 33 = 1980 2013-33=1980 numbers that aren't multiples of 61. This gives us a list of 1980 numbers which do not satisfy the conditions.

Using the pigeonhole principle, we know that any subset with 1981 will have at least one multiple of 61. We also know that this generic subset of 1981 elements must have factor(s) of 3 and 11 as both numbers have more factors than 61. Finally, as the problem asks for the last three digits, we get 981.

This was the only correct solution submitted.

Common mistakes: 1. Not explaining why 1981 is sufficient.
2. Not explaining why the factors of 3, 11 were not really involved in the calculation.
3. Not explaining why 1980 is not sufficient.

Calvin Lin Staff - 7 years ago
Zubayet Zico
May 20, 2014

2013 =3 11 61

So in each chosen set must have at least one triplet of the multiples of {3,11,61}.

As the number of multiples of 61 from 1 to 2013(2013/61 = 33) is less than either 3 or 11 ,we can just work with 61.From 1 to 2013 there are 2013 - 33 = 1981 numbers which are not a multiple of 61 . Thus any set of (1980 +1 = 1981) numbers from S would definitely have a triplet of multiples of 3,11 and 61.

Thus n=1981,last three digits of n=981.

Hendra Tandoyo
May 20, 2014

3,11,and 61 is the prime factor of 2013. the largest is 61. in 2013, there are 33 number divisible by 61 but we just need 1 so 2013 - 32 = 1981. we ask to write 981.

The prime factors of 2013 are 3, 11 and 61. So our set of n elements must contain some multiple of each of these numbers in order for the product of the elements to be divisible by 2013.

The set S contains (2013 / 3) = 671 multiples of 3, (2013 / 11) = 183 multiples of 11 and (2013 / 61) = 33 multiples of 61. Since 1980 elements of S are not multiples of 61, it then follows that in order to force any choice of n distinct elements to include all of these, n must be at least 1981.

Sridhar Venkatesh
May 20, 2014

2013 2013 = 3 × 11 × 61 3 \times 11 \times 61

There are - list

1342 integers in the set that are not divisible by 3 1830 integers in the set that are not divisible by 11 1980 integers in the set that are not divisible by 61

According to the Pigeon Hole Principle, there will be multiples of 3, 11, 61 if we pick at least 1981 integers from the given set. Thus, n = 1981.

Divisors of 2013 = 1 , 3 , 11 , 33 , 61 , 183 , 671 , 2013 2013 = 1, 3, 11, 33, 61, 183, 671, 2013

First we add the number of numbers between 1 1 and 2013 2013 which aren't divisible by 3, 11, 61

Multiples of 3 ⇒671

Multiples of 11 ⇒183

Multiples of 61 ⇒33

Multiples of 3 and 11 ⇒61

Multiples of 3 and 61 ⇒11

Multiples of 11 and 61 ⇒3

Multiples of 3, 11, and 61 ⇒1

671 + 183 + 33 61 11 3 + 1 = 813 671 + 183 + 33 - 61 - 11 - 3 + 1 = 813

2013 813 = 1200 2013 - 813 = 1200

A multiple of 2013 is a multiplication of 3s, 11s, and 61s. So add the result above with the number of the multiples of 3 and 11 only, then add 1 from the multiple of 61.

671 + 183 61 11 3 + 1 = 780 671 + 183 - 61 - 11 - 3 + 1 = 780

1200 + 780 + 1 = 1981 1200 + 780 + 1 = 1981

n = 1981 n = 1981

The last three digits of n n = 981

wrong logic.

Calvin Lin Staff - 7 years ago
Roger Jin
May 20, 2014

The prime factorization of 2013 is 3 11 61. Of these 3 factors, 61 has the least multiples from 0-2013. Therefore, by some pigeonholing, the value of n will be determined by the number of possible multiples of 61 in the set. 2013/61=33. Thus, n = 2013-32 = 1981. The last 3 digits of this n are 981.

No logic provided

Calvin Lin Staff - 7 years ago

0 pending reports

×

Problem Loading...

Note Loading...

Set Loading...