Knight, Knave and Jokers
You are visiting a mythical island with 3 types of islanders:
- Knights who always tell the truth,
- Knaves who always lie, and
- Jokers who can tell the truth or lie interchangeably.
You come across 2 islanders, A and B, whose types you don't know. They had a conversation with you as follows:
- A: "I am either a Knight or a Knave, B is either a Knave or a Joker, and either one of us is either a Knight or a Joker."
- B: "I am not a Knave or a Joker, A is not a Knight or a Knave, and either one of us is either a Knight or a Joker."
After listening to their statements, can you tell whether either A or B can be a Knave?
This section requires Javascript.
You are seeing this because something didn't load right. We suggest you, (a) try
refreshing the page, (b) enabling javascript if it is disabled on your browser and,
finally, (c)
loading the
non-javascript version of this page
. We're sorry about the hassle.
1 solution
First, analyze A's statement. The first thing A says is "I am either a knight or a knave." Now, make three assumptions and evaluate them:
A is a knight: This does not contradict A's statement, so this is a valid assumption.
A is a joker: This does not contradict A's statement, so this is a valid assumption.
A is a knave: This leads to a contradiction because a knave cannot claim that they are a knave. Therefore, A is not a knave.
We can also deduce that B cannot be a knave because of the third part of their statement: "One of us is either a Knight or a Joker." If B was a knave, then this statement would be false. However, using our previous deduction, that statement must be true. Therefore, B is not a knave.