Koch Snowflake - Part 2

Calculus Level 3

The Koch snowflake has several surprising properties, as illustrated in the previous question . Furthermore, in the above gif, we see that the Koch snowflake is self-similar, as zooming in on the perimeter reveals the exact same shape.

Which of the following statements is false of the Koch Snowflake, with initial side length s s ?

We can tessellate the plane with copies of the Koch snowflake in 2 different sizes. It can be subdivided into seven smaller snowflakes of the same size. Its perimeter is nowhere differentiable. It has an area of 2 3 5 s 2 \frac{2 \sqrt{3} }{5} s^2 .

This section requires Javascript.
You are seeing this because something didn't load right. We suggest you, (a) try refreshing the page, (b) enabling javascript if it is disabled on your browser and, finally, (c) loading the non-javascript version of this page . We're sorry about the hassle.

1 solution

Calvin Lin Staff
Feb 26, 2014

This question is hard if you do not know where to start.

The statement about subdivision into 7 smaller snowflakes of the same size is wrong.
Proof by contradiction, assume it is correct. By considering the areas, the smaller snowflakes must each have side length 1 7 s \frac{ 1} { \sqrt{7} } s . This clearly cannot fit into the snowflake.

What is true though, is that it can be subdivided into 7 smaller snowflakes. 6 of size 1 3 \frac{1}{3} in each of the 'corners' and 1 of size 1 3 \frac{1}{ \sqrt{3} } in the center.


Here is a tessellation of the snowflake in the plane. It surprised me when I first saw it.

image image


Let's tackle an easy one, namely the area. Starting with an equilateral triangle of side length s s , it has area X = 3 4 s 2 X = \frac{ \sqrt{3} } { 4} s^2 .
In the first step, there are 3 line segments.
In the second step, there are 12 line segments.
At the nth step, there are 3 × 4 n 1 3 \times 4^{n-1} line segments.

In the first step, the area of the small triangles added is X 9 \frac {X}{9} .
In the second step, the area of the small triangles added is X 9 2 \frac{X}{9^2} .
In the nth step, the area of the small triangles added is X 9 n \frac{X}{9^n} .

Hence, the total area is X + 3 9 X + 3 × 4 9 2 X + + 3 × 4 n 1 9 n X X + \frac{3}{9} X + \frac{ 3 \times 4 } {9^2} X + \ldots + \frac{ 3 \times 4^{n-1} } { 9^n} X .
Ignoring the first two terms, we get a geometric progression with common ratio 4 9 \frac{4}{9} , and hence the sum is 3 × 4 9 2 X × 1 1 4 9 = 4 15 X \frac{ 3 \times 4 } { 9^2 } X \times \frac{ 1} { 1 - \frac{ 4}{9}} = \frac{ 4}{15} X . Hence, the total area is 8 5 X = 2 3 5 s 2 \frac{ 8}{5} X = \frac{ 2 \sqrt{3} } { 5} s^2 .
Thus, the statement on area is correct!


I leave the fact about a non-differentiable perimeter to you. It will require some work.

It is possible to tessellate the plane by copies of Koch snowflakes in two different sizes. However, such a tessellation is not possible using only snowflakes of the same size as each other. Since each Koch snowflake in the tessellation can be subdivided into seven smaller snowflakes of two different sizes, it is also possible to find tessellations that use more than two sizes at once.

Priyank Kumar - 7 years, 3 months ago

0 pending reports

×

Problem Loading...

Note Loading...

Set Loading...