Let's Bend light

Akshay loves stargazing. So much so in his free time he browses through different images of stars and galaxy taken by telescopes, on the Internet. One day he came across this weird photo. Soon he found out that the blue ring in the picture is actually a galaxy and was formed due to the distortion in the path of light coming from the blue galaxy. This effect is known as gravitational lensing and it happens because a gravitational field of a massive object can bend a ray of light. Let's think of this happening due to a change in the effective refractive index of the medium given by n r = 1 + 2 G M r c 2 , n_r =1+\frac{ 2GM }{ r{ c }^{ 2 } }, where r r is the distance of the point of consideration from the center of the mass of the massive body. Considering a spherical body, find the deviation of the ray from the original path as it grazes the object.

Your answer will be of the form k G M R c 2 \frac{ kGM }{ R{ c }^{ 2 } } , where r r is the radius of object. Input your answer as k k .

Details and Assumptions:

  • While calculating you can ignore a product of two differentials.
  • The above-mentioned effect actually happens due to distortion in space.


The answer is 4.

This section requires Javascript.
You are seeing this because something didn't load right. We suggest you, (a) try refreshing the page, (b) enabling javascript if it is disabled on your browser and, finally, (c) loading the non-javascript version of this page . We're sorry about the hassle.

1 solution

Rishi Sharma
Jan 12, 2017

Let us consider two arcs concentric with the centre of the planet at a distance r r and r + d r r+dr . Let the light be incident at angle θ \theta at the surface at r r and leave r + d r r+dr at an angle θ + d θ \theta+d\theta

As h < < R h << R and the light ray initially was tangent to the surface, the marked angle can be assumed to θ \theta . Then from the Snell's law,

n ( r ) sin ( θ ) = n ( r + d r ) sin ( θ + d θ ) n(r) \sin (\theta)=n(r+dr) \sin (\theta+d\theta)

Now n ( r + d r ) n ( r ) ( r + d r ) ( r ) = d n d r \frac{ n(r+dr)-n(r) }{ (r+dr)-(r) }=\frac{ dn }{ dr } . Which gives n ( r + d r ) = n ( r ) + d n d r d r n(r+dr)=n(r)+\frac{ dn }{ dr }dr . Replacing in the above equation and using sin ( A + B ) = sin A cos B + cos B sin A \sin (A+B)= \sin A \cos B+\cos B \sin A . We get,

n ( r ) s i n ( θ ) = ( n ( r ) + d n d r d r ) ( sin θ cos d θ + cos θ sin d θ ) n(r)sin(\theta)=\left( n(r)+\frac{ dn }{ dr }dr \right)\left( \sin \theta \cos d\theta + \cos \theta \sin d\theta \right)

On simplification we get,

d n d r tan θ = n ( r ) d θ d r -\frac{ dn }{ dr } \tan\theta=n(r)\frac{ d\theta }{ dr } .

Now d n d r = 2 G M r 2 c 2 \frac{ dn }{ dr }=-\frac{ 2GM }{ { r }^{ 2 }{ c }^{ 2 } } . Also, ( 1 + 2 G M r c 2 ) d θ d r d θ d r \left( 1+\frac{ 2GM }{ r{ c }^{ 2 } } \right) \frac{ d\theta }{ dr } \approx \frac{ d\theta }{ dr } As the object is massive. Replacing all of this in the original equation we get

d θ = 2 G M c 2 ( tan θ r 2 d r ) d\theta=\frac{ 2GM }{ { c }^{ 2 } }\left( \frac{ \tan\theta }{ { r }^{ 2 } }dr \right) .

Now from the diagram we can see that r 2 = ( h + R ) 2 + x 2 { r }^{ 2 }={ (h+R) }^{ 2 }+{ x }^{ 2 } . And tan θ = R + h x \tan\theta=\frac{ R+h }{ x } . As the light ray just grazes the planet, h < < R R + h R h<< R \rightarrow R+h \approx R . So r 2 = R 2 + x 2 d r = x d x x 2 + R 2 { r }^{ 2 }={ R }^{ 2 }+{ x }^{ 2 } \rightarrow dr=\frac{ xdx }{ \sqrt{ { x }^{ 2 }+{ R }^{ 2 } } } and tan θ = R x \tan\theta=\frac{ R }{ x } . Replacing all of this in the original equation and integrating within proper limits we get

0 θ 0 d θ = 2 G M R c 2 d x ( x 2 + R 2 ) 3 2 \int _{ 0 }^{ { \theta }_{ 0 } }{ d\theta } =\frac{ 2GMR }{ { c }^{ 2 } }\int _{ -\infty }^{ \infty }{ \frac{ dx }{ { ( { x }^{ 2 }+{ R }^{ 2 } ) }^{ \frac{ 3 }{ 2 } } } }

θ 0 = 4 G M R c 2 { \theta }_{ 0 }=\boxed{ \frac{ 4GM }{ R{ c }^{ 2 } } }

Nice solution! Great picture as well. :P

Sharky Kesa - 4 years, 4 months ago

@Rishi Sharma You should have credited ncert exemplar.

Kartik Sharma - 4 years, 4 months ago

Log in to reply

Na this is quite a standard problem.Even this was a q in inpho.

Spandan Senapati - 4 years, 3 months ago

0 pending reports

×

Problem Loading...

Note Loading...

Set Loading...