Limiting behavior of the area of an infinity-gon

Calculus Level 3

Suppose a regular n n -gon is constructed from N N sides of constant length 2 π 2\sqrt{\pi} .

As the number of sides N N of this n n -gon is increased towards infinity, which function of N N gives the limiting behavior of of the n n -gon's area, A ( N ) A(N) ?

N N tan ( N ) \tan(N) 1 N \frac 1 N N 3 N^3 N 2 N^2

This section requires Javascript.
You are seeing this because something didn't load right. We suggest you, (a) try refreshing the page, (b) enabling javascript if it is disabled on your browser and, finally, (c) loading the non-javascript version of this page . We're sorry about the hassle.

1 solution

Brian Kardon
Jan 7, 2016

The area of the n-gon can be found by dividing it into N isosceles triangles constructed from two consecutive n-gon vertices plus the central point of the n-gon, as shown here for a 12-gon:

Each of our N isosceles triangles has an area that can be found by dividing in half, forming two identical right triangles, as shown in the diagram. The angle marked θ \theta on the diagram is π / N \pi/N .

The area of one of the right triangles is L 2 8 tan ( π / N ) \frac{L^2}{8\tan(\pi/N)} . The area of one of the isosceles triangles is twice that, so the area of the whole n-gon is

A ( N ) = N L 2 4 tan ( π / N ) A(N) = \frac{N L^2}{4 \tan(\pi/N)}

A ( N ) = N L 2 4 cot ( π / N ) A(N) = \frac{N L^2}{4} \cot(\pi/N)

Our goal is to find the limiting behavior lim N A ( N ) \lim_{N \to \infty} A(N) . The Taylor series expansion of cot ( x ) \cot(x) is

cot ( x ) = 1 x 1 3 x + O ( x 3 ) \cot(x) = \frac 1 x - \frac 1 3 x + O(x^3)

Therefore

A ( N ) = N L 2 4 ( N π π 3 N + O ( N 3 ) ) A(N) = \frac{N L^2}{4} (\frac{N}{\pi} - \frac{\pi}{3 N} + O(N^{-3}))

A ( N ) = N 2 L 2 4 π L 2 π 12 + O ( N 2 ) ) A(N) = \frac{N^2 L^2}{4 \pi} - \frac{L^2 \pi}{12} + O(N^{-2}))

And in the limit N N \to \infty ,

A ( N ) N 2 L 2 4 π A(N) \sim \frac{N^2 L^2}{4 \pi}

If we evaluate this with L = 2 π L = 2 \sqrt{\pi} , we find that

A ( N ) N 2 A(N) \sim N^2

I like your solution because your method was very precise. Just one comment: I would guess that you used the Maclaurin expansions for cos x \cos{x} and sin x \sin{x} , and used polynomial long division, but this does not give the Maclaurin series expansion (nor a Taylor series expansion) for cot x \cot{x} . It gives a Laurent expansion (centered at the origin) http://mathworld.wolfram.com/Cotangent.html. Just thought that would help your terminology a bit. Cheers - James

James Wilson - 3 years, 6 months ago

0 pending reports

×

Problem Loading...

Note Loading...

Set Loading...