Let be a positive integer.
Denote by the number of ways can be written in the form of where for every we have (except the last term) and for some positive integer
Denote by the number of ways can be written in the form of where for every is a positive integer and (except the last term).
Which of the following statemens is true?
This section requires Javascript.
You are seeing this because something didn't load right. We suggest you, (a) try
refreshing the page, (b) enabling javascript if it is disabled on your browser and,
finally, (c)
loading the
non-javascript version of this page
. We're sorry about the hassle.
We are going to prove the answer by showing that a bijection exists between the possible arrangements in a ( n ) and b ( n ) . For this, let us encode every construction in a ( n ) in the following way:
Firstly, convert every x i to its binary form and write them into i rows (the i th row containing x i ) such that their first digits are below each other. Since all x i 's are in the form of 2 k i − 1 for positive integers k i , their binary form consists only of 1's. Moreover, from the condition x i ≤ x i + 1 it is evident that the i + 1 th row must contain at least as much digits as the i th. Finally, let us assign a unique value to every digit which represents the amount it contributes to the value of its corresponding x i ; this can be achieved by defining the value of a certain digit to be 2 l if the number of digits in the same row which are on the right hand side of the digit appears to be l . A clear consequence of this assigment is the fact that x i is equal to the sum of the values of digits in the i th row.
Now we seek to show that if we add together the digit's values in every column instead of row, we obtain a proper construction in b ( n ) . Indeed, denoting the sum of the values in the i th row from the right by y i it is apparent that the condition y i + 1 ≥ 2 y i is met, since every digit corresponding to y i has a neighbouring digit from the left with twice as much value that is contained in y i + 1 . Moreover, as the sums n = x 1 + x 2 + … and y 1 + y 2 + … both can be calculated by summing up the values of every digit in the construction, it follows that n = y 1 + y 2 + … . Henceforth, we have found an injection from a ( n ) to b ( n ) .
It suffices to show that this injection is a one-to-one mapping. We'll prove it by correlating every n = y 1 + y 2 + … arrangement to a unique n = x 1 + x 2 + … arrangement such that the latter is corresponding to the former according to our injective reasoning. We proceed by the following:
Place y 1 number of 1's in a column. If i number of columns have already been constructed, we add the ( i + 1 ) st by writing 1's on the left side of every digit in the i th column, and y i + 1 − 2 y i number of 1's over them in addition (note that this can always be accomplished in view of y i + 1 ≥ 2 y i ). After completing the construction, let all of the digits be given the same defined value as formerly. Finally, observe that the sum of values of 1's in the i th column from the right equals to y i for every i , and if the values are summed up in every row we end up with a proper n = x 1 + x 2 + … arrangement which corresponds to the b ( n ) construction we started with. That's exactly what we wanted to show.
Hence, our proof is complete.