Measuring the Earth with camels and sticks

One of the first intellectual achievements of the human race was Eratosthenes' measurement of the Earth's circumference around 240 BC. Not only did he measure the circumference using only sticks and observations, but he also assumed that the Earth was round and not flat.

Eratosthenes used the following method: he observed that the Sun creates a 16 m 16~\mbox{m} shadow off the Lighthouse of Alexandria at the same time when it is straight above Syene (no shadow). He hired a caravan of camels that went back and fourth couple of times between Alexandria and Syene to establish the distance between them. The measured distance was around 928 km 928~ \mbox{km} . What was the circumference of the Earth in km that Eratosthenes calculated?

Details and assumptions

  • It is thought that the Lighthouse of Alexandria was around 130 m 130~\mbox{m} tall.
  • Eratosthenes assumed the Earth was perfectly spherical.
  • Since the Sun is very far away, Eratosthenes assumed that its rays are parallel.


The answer is 47726.

This section requires Javascript.
You are seeing this because something didn't load right. We suggest you, (a) try refreshing the page, (b) enabling javascript if it is disabled on your browser and, finally, (c) loading the non-javascript version of this page . We're sorry about the hassle.

4 solutions

Mursalin Habib
Nov 18, 2013

[Before I begin, I strongly recommend that you read [Calculating the Size of the Earth](https://brilliant.org/assessment/techniques-trainer/calculating-the-size-of-the-earth/) in the techniques trainer section. The image below is taken from there (with slight modifications)]

Alt text Alt text

I'll use this image as a reference. We're calling P Q PQ the lighthouse of Alexandria which is 130 130 meters tall. Q S QS is the distance between Syene and Alexandria [ 928 928 kilometers]. And Q R QR is the shadow of the lighthouse.

Let's determine A \angle A .

Since Q R QR is really small compared to the circumference of the earth, we can consider Q R QR to be a straight line.

So in the right triangle P Q R PQR , A = tan 1 16 130 = 0.1225 \angle A=\tan^{-1} \frac{16}{130}=0.1225 radians approximately.

A \angle A is equal to B \angle B because they're alternate angles.

And the circumference of the earth is 2 π 0.1225 × Q S = 2 π 0.1225 × 928 = 47726 \frac{2\pi}{0.1225}\times QS= \frac{2\pi}{0.1225}\times 928=\boxed{47726} kilometers approximately.

this is awesome

Rey Francis Famulagan - 7 years, 6 months ago

Nice.Would you tell me how can I input links in solutions or comments ?

arif rayhan - 7 years, 6 months ago

Log in to reply

You can include links by:

[Words to display](your link)

For example: if I were to add a link to Brilliant. I'd write

[Brilliant]( https://brilliant.org)

And it would look like: Brilliant .

If you're talking about images, try using this:

![Alt text](url of the image)

So if I wanted to link your profile pic, I'd write:

![Alt](https://ds055uzetaobb.cloudfront.net/avatars-2/resized/190/f9203ea3630c0614269c5b5ec14014eb.4c317cee61-SxkI5ouqbB.jpg)

And voila!

Alt Alt

Mursalin Habib - 7 years, 6 months ago

My dear Mursalin, how are you getting 2 π 0.1225 × 928 = 47726 \frac{2\pi}{0.1225}\times928=47726 ? I don't think it is wise to round things off before plugging them in for final result.

Nishant Sharma - 7 years, 6 months ago

Log in to reply

You're right. I actually got 2 π × 928 tan 1 16 130 = 47613.47067 \frac{2\pi \times 928}{\tan^{-1}\frac{16}{130}}=47613.47067 on my calculator. And that's what I submitted (as far as I can remember). Then the answer submission field went green and said "47726 is correct! You earned 125 points".

I wrote the solution 7 hours later and then I didn't go through all of the calculations again. I just wrote down what was on the submission field.

Well, it's a 0.23 0.23 % discrepancy. So it's accurate enough, I guess.

Mursalin Habib - 7 years, 6 months ago

but i think all are doing wrong..No one is converting that 16 m into Kilometer. so how can 47726 is correct.....first make the units same...then the answer will be different ..around 826434 km.

Sourabh Sharma - 7 years, 6 months ago

Log in to reply

Nope! You don't have to convert Q R QR & P Q PQ in kilometers. You can, but that will give you the same answer.

Why? Well, tan A \tan \angle A is always constant and equal to The length of Q R The length of P Q \frac{\text{The length of} \ QR}{\text{The length of} \ PQ} . Note that the ratio of these lengths don't depend on their units as long as they are expressed in the same units.

By the way, the actual circumference of the earth is 40 , 075 40,075 km [from a google search]. So Eratosthenes did really good for his time. But your answer, 826434 826434 km, is way off! That is more than 20 20 times earth's actual circumference! If you're willing to show how you got that answer, I'll be glad to see it. But it is more than likely that you made an error in the process and you're not noticing that.

Mursalin Habib - 7 years, 6 months ago

How do i include image of a diagram made by me in the solution ???

Upendra Singh - 7 years, 6 months ago

Log in to reply

First upload your image to a image-sharing site like imgur.com.

Then then get its direct url and follow the steps mentioned in the comment I made in reply to Arif.

Mursalin Habib - 7 years, 6 months ago

Let θ l i g h t h o u s e θ_{lighthouse} be the angle created by the lighthouse and its shadow. So, computing for θ l i g h t h o u s e θ_{lighthouse} :

  • tan θ l i g h t h o u s e θ_{lighthouse} = 16 130 \frac{16}{130}
  • arc tan ( 16 130 \frac{16}{130} )= θ l i g h t h o u s e θ_{lighthouse}
  • θ l i g h t h o u s e θ_{lighthouse} = 7.016501745

Taking for account that the rays are parallel, we can say that the angle formed by the lighthouse-shadow is the alternate interior angle of the earth formed from the distance between Alexandria and Syene. Thus, θ e a r t h θ_{earth} - which is the central angle formed by the distance from Alexandria and Syene is equal to the angle formed in the lighthouse-shadow.

θ l i g h t h o u s e θ_{lighthouse} = θ e a r t h θ_{earth}

So computing for earth's circumference : (In my solution, I used means and extreme) - Let x be the circumference of the earth

θ e a r t h θ_{earth} : d A l e x a n d r i a > S y e n e d_{Alexandria->Syene } , 360 : x

x = d A l e x a n d r i a > S y e n e × 360 d_{Alexandria->Syene } \times 360 / θ e a r t h θ_{earth}

Substituing the values :

x = 928 k m × 360 928 km \times 360 / 7.016501745

x = 47726 k m \boxed{47726 km}

Same steps... i am getting final answer as 47613.47 km using calculator

Piyushkumar Palan - 7 years, 6 months ago

Log in to reply

yeah. it is still correct

Rey Francis Famulagan - 7 years, 6 months ago

but i think all are doing wrong..No one is converting that 16 m into Kilometer. so how can 47726 is correct.....first make the units same...then the answer will be different ..around 826434 km.

Sourabh Sharma - 7 years, 6 months ago

Log in to reply

you don't need to convert that 16m into kilometers, since you just need to find out the angle formed by the shadows and the height of the light house (which are BOTH in meters).

Rey Francis Famulagan - 7 years, 6 months ago
Gopal Adhikari
Nov 18, 2013

The angle made by the sun rays at the lighthouse is θ = arctan ( 130 / 16 ) \theta = \arctan(130/16) . The angle made by the sun rays above Syene is 9 0 90^\circ . Since we can assume the Earth is spherical, therefore it's cross-sections are circles. Syene and the lighthouse lie on the edge of a circle, the distance between them, L L , is 928 m 928m and the angle between them is ϕ = 9 0 θ = ( 90 82.98 ) = 7.0 2 \phi = 90^\circ - \theta = (90 - 82.98)^\circ = 7.02^\circ

Now we can get the radius of circle like this:

Convert ϕ \phi to radians: ϕ r = 0.122 \phi_{r} = 0.122

r = L ϕ r = 928 0.122 = 7606 k m r = \frac{L}{\phi_{r}} = \frac{928}{0.122} = 7606 km

\therefore Circumference = 2 π r = 2 × 3.14 × 7606 k m = 47765 k m 2\pi r= 2 \times 3.14 \times 7606km = 47765km

Edit: This is not very accurate but hey! we are in ancient Greece!

but i think all are doing wrong..No one is converting that 16 m into Kilometer. so how can 47726 is correct.....first make the units same...then the answer will be different ..around 826434 km.

Sourabh Sharma - 7 years, 6 months ago

Log in to reply

It's not needed because when you find the arctan of 130m/16m, that's equivalent to doing 130km/16km. The units get canceled.

Gopal Adhikari - 7 years, 6 months ago
Felipe Sousa
Nov 17, 2013

In Alexandria the Sun makes a angle of θ = t a n 1 ( 16 130 ) = 0.12246 \theta=tan^-1(\frac{16}{130})=0.12246 with the normal with the surface.

Because we consider earth as a sphere we can represent the angle θ \theta as the angle between two points on a circunference with a distance of 928 k m 928 km between them.

Now we just make a proportion θ 2 π = 928 C \frac{\theta}{2\pi}=\frac{928}{C} where C C is the circumference of the Earth. Solving we have C = 47726 C=47726 .

0 pending reports

×

Problem Loading...

Note Loading...

Set Loading...