Michael keeps it real

Algebra Level 4

For a uniformly random real number k k in the interval [ 10 , 0 ] , [-10, 0], the probability that sin 4 θ sin 2 θ k = 0 \sin^4 \theta - \sin^2 \theta - k = 0 has at least one real solution θ \theta can be expressed as a b \dfrac{a}{b} for positive coprime integers a a and b . b. What is the value of a + b a+b ?

This problem is posed by Michael T .


The answer is 41.

This section requires Javascript.
You are seeing this because something didn't load right. We suggest you, (a) try refreshing the page, (b) enabling javascript if it is disabled on your browser and, finally, (c) loading the non-javascript version of this page . We're sorry about the hassle.

15 solutions

Daniel Liu
Dec 8, 2013

Let sin 2 x = y \sin^2{x}=y . Note that since 0 sin 2 x 1 0\le\sin^2{x}\le 1 . we have 0 y 1 0\le y\le1 .

Substituting into the equation sin 4 x sin 2 x k = 0 \sin^4{x}-\sin^2{x}-k=0 gives y 2 y k = 0 y^2-y-k=0 .

Using the quadratic formula gives y = 1 ± 1 + 4 k 2 y=\dfrac{1\pm\sqrt{1+4k}}{2} . Using the fact that 0 y 1 0\le y\le1 , we see that 0 1 ± 1 + 4 k 2 1 0\le\dfrac{1\pm\sqrt{1+4k}}{2}\le 1 .

We can break the problem into two cases now: y = 1 + 1 + 4 k 2 y=\dfrac{1+\sqrt{1+4k}}{2} and y = 1 1 + 4 k 2 y=\dfrac{1-\sqrt{1+4k}}{2} .

First case: y = 1 + 1 + 4 k 2 y=\dfrac{1+\sqrt{1+4k}}{2}

We have that 0 1 + 1 + 4 k 2 1 0\le\dfrac{1+\sqrt{1+4k}}{2}\le 1 . Multiplying both sides by 2 2 and then subtracting 1 1 gives 1 1 + 4 k 1 -1\le \sqrt{1+4k}\le 1 . Since 1 + 4 k 0 \sqrt{1+4k}\ge 0 , we have that 0 1 + 4 k 1 0\le \sqrt{1+4k}\le 1 .

Solving for k k gives 1 4 k 0 -\frac{1}{4}\le k\le 0 .

Second case: y = 1 1 + 4 k 2 y=\dfrac{1-\sqrt{1+4k}}{2}

We have that 0 1 1 + 4 k 2 1 0\le\dfrac{1-\sqrt{1+4k}}{2}\le 1 . Multiplying both sides by 2 2 and then subtracting 1 1 gives 1 1 + 4 k 1 -1\le -\sqrt{1+4k}\le 1 . Multiplying by 1 -1 and keeping in mind to switch the direction of the inequalities gives 1 1 + 4 k 1 -1\le \sqrt{1+4k}\le 1 , and we see that we are back at our first case.

We have that in the range 10 k 0 -10\le k\le 0 , that 1 4 k 0 -\frac{1}{4}\le k\le 0 works. This is 1 4 10 = 1 40 \dfrac{\frac{1}{4}}{10}=\dfrac{1}{40} of the entire range. Therefore the probability of choosing a k k in this range is 1 40 \dfrac{1}{40} and our desired answer is 1 + 40 = 41 1+40=\boxed{41} .

Andrew Sellek
Dec 9, 2013

Let sin 2 θ = X \sin^2\theta=X We can rewrite the equation as X 2 X k = 0 X^2-X-k=0 Since this is a quadratic, we can apply a discriminant test. The sine function only gives real values, so therefore X will be real. This means that we need the quadratic to have at least one real root, so b 2 4 a c 0 b^2-4ac\ge0 ( 1 ) 2 4 1 k 0 (-1)^2-4*1*-k\ge0 1 + 4 k 0 1+4k\ge0 4 k 1 4k\ge-1 k ( 1 4 ) k\ge\left(\frac{-1}{4}\right) This gives us a desired range for k of 0 ( 1 4 ) = ( 1 4 ) 0-\left(\frac{-1}{4}\right)=\left(\frac{1}{4}\right) This is out of a total possible range of 0 ( 10 ) = 10 0-(-10)=10 The probability that k lies inside this range is therefore ( 1 4 ) ÷ 10 = ( 1 40 ) \left(\frac{1}{4}\right)\div10=\left(\frac{1}{40}\right) This is in the required form so therefore the answer is 1 + 10 = 41 1+10=41 41 \boxed{41}

Moderator note:

This solution is incomplete, because it didn't check that 0 X 1 0 \leq X \leq 1 which would then yield a solution for θ \theta .

Almost exactly how I did it. Nice solution mate.

A Former Brilliant Member - 7 years, 6 months ago

almost same approach i followed :D

Prashant Upadhyay - 7 years, 6 months ago

Good. Thanks for providing bright solutions.

Bharat Karmarkar - 7 years, 6 months ago

thanks for good solution

Viswakanth Kandala - 7 years, 6 months ago
Ivan Sekovanić
Dec 9, 2013

Let us transform the original equation a bit:

sin 4 θ sin 2 θ k = 0 sin 2 θ ( sin 2 θ 1 ) = k sin 2 θ ( 1 sin 2 θ ) = k \sin^{4}\theta-\sin^{2}\theta-k=0 \Rightarrow \sin^{2}\theta(\sin^{2}\theta-1)=k \Rightarrow -\sin^{2}\theta(1-\sin^{2}\theta)=k \Rightarrow

sin 2 θ cos 2 θ = k sin 2 θ cos 2 θ = k 4 sin 2 θ cos 2 θ = 4 k \Rightarrow -\sin^{2}\theta \cos^{2}\theta=k \Rightarrow \sin^{2}\theta \cos^{2}\theta=-k \Rightarrow 4\sin^{2}\theta \cos^{2}\theta=-4k \Rightarrow

s i n 2 ( 2 θ ) = 4 k \Rightarrow sin^{2}(2\theta)=-4k

Taking into account that sin α [ 1 , 1 ] \sin\alpha \in [-1,1] , we may note that sin 2 α [ 0 , 1 ] \sin^{2}\alpha \in [0,1] . For α = 2 θ \alpha = 2\theta , we can see that sin 2 ( 2 θ ) [ 0 , 1 ] \sin^{2}(2\theta) \in [0,1] .

Therefore, the allowed values for k k can be found in the interval between its minimal allowed value and its maximal allowed value.

The minimum is acquired for sin 2 ( 2 θ ) = 0 \sin^{2}(2\theta)=0 , thus 4 k m i n = 0 k m i n = 0 -4k_{min}=0 \Rightarrow k_{min}=0 .

The maximum is acquired for sin 2 ( 2 θ ) = 1 \sin^{2}(2\theta)=1 , thus 4 k m a x = 1 k m a x = 1 4 -4k_{max}=1 \Rightarrow k_{max}=-\frac{1}{4} .

At this point it is evident that the allowed values for k k are the values in the interval [ 1 4 , 0 ] [-\frac{1}{4},0] .

Considering the original domain of k k , which is [ 10 , 0 ] [-10,0] , we may note that [ 1 4 , 0 ] [-\frac{1}{4},0] is exactly 1 40 \frac{1}{40} of it. Therefore, the desired probability is P = 1 40 P=\frac{1}{40} .

With that in mind, if a b = 1 40 \frac{a}{b}=\frac{1}{40} then a + b = 41 a+b=\boxed{41} .

PS: This is by FAR the best problem title I have seen so far. Well done!

What do you want to see in a problem title? What makes this the best so far?

Calvin Lin Staff - 7 years, 6 months ago

Log in to reply

In essence, I love mini-puns in problems, like in this one. They make me chuckle every time :)

Ivan Sekovanić - 7 years, 6 months ago

i did the same

Akbarali Surani - 7 years, 6 months ago
Patrick Chen
Dec 9, 2013

As a quadratic in sin 2 θ \sin^2\theta , for theta to be real the discriminant Δ = b 2 4 a c = 1 + 4 k \Delta = b^2-4ac=1+4k must be positive. 1 + 4 k > 0 k > 1 4 1+4k>0 \implies k>-\frac{1}{4} . Thus, k k is in the interval [ 1 4 , 0 ] [-\frac{1}{4},0] .

Finally, because of the range of y = sin 2 x y = \sin^2x is [ 0 , 1 ] [0,1] , not all values of k k in the previous interval [ 1 4 , 0 ] [-\frac{1}{4},0] may be valid. By the quadratic formula, sin 2 θ = b + Δ 2 a = 1 + Δ 2 \sin^2\theta = \frac{-b+\sqrt{\Delta}}{2a} = \frac{1+\sqrt{\Delta}}{2} . As Δ = 1 + 4 k \Delta=1+4k is between 0 and 1, sin 2 θ \sin^2\theta ranges from [ 1 2 , 1 ] [ 0 , 1 ] [\frac{1}{2},1]\subset [0,1] , so there is now no doubt that the previous interval of [ 1 4 , 0 ] [-\frac{1}{4},0] is valid for all values of k k .

Thus, the probability is 0 ( 1 4 ) 0 ( 10 ) = 1 40 \frac{0-(-\frac{1}{4})}{0-(-10)}=\frac{1}{40} and so a + b = 41 a+b=\boxed{41} .

Ben Williams
Dec 9, 2013

(1) Uniform Probability distribution in interval [c,d] has p.d.f

f ( x ) = 1 c d f(x)=\frac{1}{c-d} So in this case, f ( x ) = 1 10 f(x)= \frac{1}{10}

(2) s i n 4 θ s i n 2 θ k sin^{4}\theta-sin^{2}\theta-k is a quadratic in s i n 2 θ sin^{2}\theta

From the quadratic formula:

(3) s i n 2 θ = 1 ± 1 + 4 k 2 sin^{2}\theta=\frac{1±\sqrt{1+4k}}{2}

For real solutions, 1 + 4 k > 0 4 k > 1 4 1+4k>0 \implies 4k>-\frac{1}{4} So k in interval 1 4 < k < 0 -\frac{1}{4}<k<0

Using p.d.f,

(4) P r ( 1 4 < k < 0 ) = 1 4 0 1 10 d x = 1 40 Pr(\frac{-1}{4}<k<0)=\int^{0}_{\frac{-1}{4}} \frac{1}{10} dx = \frac{1}{40}

(5) So a = 1 , b = 40 , a + b = 41 a=1, b=40, a+b=41

Can you review your solution and spot an unstated assumption? Look at Patrick Chen's solution.

Calvin Lin Staff - 7 years, 6 months ago
Ishbir Singh
Dec 8, 2013

I started solving it by substituting sin 2 θ \sin^2 \theta with x x . Thus this makes the equation: x 2 x k = 0 x^2 - x - k = 0 Using the quadratic formula, x = 1 ± 1 + 4 k 2 x = \frac{1 \pm \sqrt{1+4k}}{2}

Thus, the maximum possible value of k k is 0 and the minimum possible value of 1 4 \frac{-1}{4} . The distribution of 1 4 \frac{-1}{4} to 0 is 1 4 0 10 0 \frac{\frac{-1}{4}-0}{-10-0} which gives the fraction as 1 40 \frac{1}{40}

Thus a + b = 41 a+b = 41

Can you review your solution and spot an unstated assumption? Look at Patrick Chen's solution.

Calvin Lin Staff - 7 years, 6 months ago

Log in to reply

The assumption is that x x can have only real values and thus 1 + 4 k > 0 1+4k > 0

Ishbir Singh - 7 years, 6 months ago
Parth Chopra
Dec 8, 2013

Let x = sin 2 θ x = \sin^{2} \theta

Now, we can rewrite the above equation as a simple quadratic:

x 2 x k = 0 x^{2} - x - k = 0

Let's calculate the probability for which there are NO real solutions to this equation. In order for this to be true, the discriminant, ( b 2 4 a c ) (b^{2} - 4ac) has to be less than 0.

Substituting the given coefficients, we get:

4 k + 1 < 0 4k + 1 < 0

k < 1 4 k < \frac{-1}{4}

Since k k can only be chosen from the interval [ 10 , 0 ] [-10, 0] , it means that the probability of choosing a k k such that the equation has no solution is:

10 1 4 10 = 39 40 \frac{-10 - \frac{-1}{4}}{-10} = \frac{39}{40}

Hence, the probability that the equation has at least one real solution θ \theta is:

1 39 40 = 1 40 1 - \frac{39}{40} = \frac{1}{40} , where a = 1 a = 1 and b = 40 b = 40 .

Therefore, the value of a + b = 41 a + b = \boxed{41} .

Can you review your solution and spot an unstated assumption? Look at Patrick Chen's solution.

Calvin Lin Staff - 7 years, 6 months ago
Zachary Chase
Dec 8, 2013

Letting u = s i n 2 θ u = sin^2\theta and using quadratic formula, we have:

u = 1 ± 1 + 4 k 2 u = \frac{1\pm{\sqrt{1+4k}}}{2}

Thus:

sin θ = 1 ± 1 + 4 k 2 \sin{\theta} = \sqrt{\frac{1\pm{\sqrt{1+4k}}}{2} } . Solving for θ \theta :

θ = sin 1 ( 1 ± 1 + 4 k 2 ) \theta = \sin^{-1}({\sqrt{\frac{1\pm{\sqrt{1+4k}}}{2} } })

For θ \theta to be real, 1 ± 1 + 4 k 2 \sqrt{\frac{1\pm{\sqrt{1+4k}}}{2} } must be between 1 -1 and 1 1 inclusive.

Because 1 ± 1 + 4 k 2 \sqrt{\frac{1\pm{\sqrt{1+4k}}}{2} } is always positive, we only check for k k that makes that value less than 1 1 .

Squaring the radical:

1 ± 1 + 4 k 2 1 \frac{1\pm{\sqrt{1+4k}}}{2} \le 1

Simplifying:

± 1 + 4 k 1 \pm{\sqrt{1+4k}} \le 1 , or just k 0 k \le 0

Also notice from the original equation where we isolated θ \theta , for θ \theta to be real, 4 k + 1 \sqrt{4k+1} must be non-negative. So, k 1 4 k \ge \frac{-1}{4} . The range [ 1 4 , 0 ] [\frac{-1}{4}, 0] is 1 4 10 \frac{\frac{1}{4}}{10} or 1 40 \frac{1}{40} of the total range. So, the probability is 1 40 \frac{1}{40} . The desired result is thus 40 + 1 = 40+1 = 41 41 .

Akash K.
Dec 14, 2013

We have,

s i n 4 θ s i n 2 θ k = 0 sin^4\theta - sin^2\theta - k = 0

\Rightarrow s i n 2 θ ( s i n 2 θ 1 ) k = 0 sin^2\theta(sin^2\theta -1)-k=0

\Rightarrow s i n 2 θ c o s 2 θ + k = 0 sin^2\theta cos^2\theta + k = 0

\Rightarrow s i n 2 2 θ = 4 k sin^2 2\theta = -4k . .

Since the value of s i n 2 2 θ sin^2 2\theta lies between 0 0 and 1 1 so the possible values of k k lies between 0 0 and 0.25 -0.25 . .

So, the probability is,

0.25 / 10 = 1 / 40 0.25/10 = 1/40

And the answer is 40 + 1 = 41 40 + 1 = \boxed{41}

Ananay Agarwal
Dec 11, 2013

The first thing to notice is that we are required to calculate the probability of finding a solution θ \theta to the equation. This gives us our first clue: there are going to be a range of values of k k in the given interval that satisfy the given conditions. If there were only one or two select numbers, the probability would be infinite.

The next, rather obvious thing to notice that the equation is a quadratic in sin 2 θ \sin^2\theta . We can express it so, and write its solution out in the quadratic formula:

sin 2 θ = 1 ± 1 + 4 k 2 \sin^2\theta = \frac{1\pm \sqrt{1 + 4k}}{2}

Now, lets look for constraints on k k . The first constraint is given to us: as k k is in the interval [ 10 , 0 ] , 10 k 0 [-10, 0], -10\leq k \leq 0 . But lets narrow it down a bit more.

As we are looking for real solutions, the discriminant, 1 + 4 k 0 k 1 4 1+4k \geq 0 \implies k \geq -\frac{1}{4} .

Also, sin 2 θ 1 1 ± 1 + 4 k 2 1 k 0 \sin^2\theta\leq 1 \implies \frac{1\pm \sqrt{1 + 4k}}{2} \leq 1 \implies k \geq 0 . So, we conclude that k k has to be in the interval, [ 1 4 , 0 ] [\frac{-1}{4}, 0] whose "size" is exactly one-fortieth of the interval given. The probability that a number will be chosen from this interval therefore is 1 40 \frac{1}{40} where 1 1 and 40 40 are co-prime. So, we get the required answer 1 + 40 = 41 1 + 40 = \boxed{41} .

Using the discriminant, let x = sin(theta), k must be greater than or equal to -1/4 in order to have at least one real solution.

Given the interval [-10, 0], k can only be in the interval [-1/4, 0].

Finding the probability, we find the distances for these intervals. The interval given has distance of 10 and the k has distance of 1/4.

P(at least one real solution) = (1/4)/10 = 1/40. Then a + b = 1 + 40 = 41. The probability

Can you review your solution and spot an unstated assumption? Look at Patrick Chen's solution.

Calvin Lin Staff - 7 years, 6 months ago
Platonas Platonas
Dec 14, 2013

Let sin^2(theta)=y. We want to find the probability that there is a real solution of y^2-y-k=0. That means that 1+4k>=0. So, k>=1/4. Since k is chosen uniformly in the interval [-10, 0] we get probability 1/40.

TYPO:
k>=-1/4

Pouya Hamadanian - 7 years, 6 months ago
Sabarinath M S
Dec 13, 2013

the expression is (sin² Θ)² -(sin² Θ) -k =0

---> put x=sin² Θ ,& we get ==> x² - x -k =0 ,

here since x=sin² Θ --->x must lie in range [0,1] as sinΘ lies in range [-1,1]

quadratic roots for x=(1± √1+4k)/2 & discriminant,d=1+4k

OR

let the roots be represented as

♦x1 =(1+ I√d I)/2 ♦x2 =(1- I√d I)/2

===>x=x1 or x2 discriminant, d = 1+4k ≥ 0 ----for real soln.(s)

==> k ≥ -1/4

===>the range of k ε [-0.25,0] for real soln.(s)

at k= -0.25 or -1/4 --->discriminant,d =0

as k increases to its provided maximum k=0 ----->discriminant,d= 1

so as -1/4 ≤ k ≤0 -----> 0≤ d≤ 1 ------> 0≤ I√d I ≤ 1

x1 =(1+ I√d I)/2 --------> 1/2 ≤ x1 ≤ 1 (due to reason given above ↑)

x2 =(1- I√d I)/2 --------> 0 ≤ x2 ≤ 1/2 (since 0≤ I√d I ≤ 1)

hence ,x= x1 or x2 ===> 0≤x≤1 throughout the range k ε [-0.25,0]

so our initial condition (x ε [0,1] ) is satisfied

so probability of having real roots = distance in number line for [-0.25,0] to that of [-10,0]

==> a/b= I(0)- (-0.25)I / I (0) - (-10)I = 1/40

==>a+b =41

Shyamal Shukla
Dec 11, 2013

sin x ^ 4 - sin x ^ 2 will always be a -ve number [-1, 0] .. hence loose bound for k is [-1, 0] however, the minima of y^2 - y (if sin x ^ 2 is called y) occurs at y = 0.5 .. hence the max diff can only be [-0.25, 0] which is the range of k .. hence prob = 0.25/10 or 1/40 => a+b = 41

Aryan C.
Dec 9, 2013

This has real solution only and only if k>=-0.25 and probability is given by (upper limit of - lower limit)/(max value - lowest value) i.e. (0-(-1/4))/(0-(-10)) solve this and you will get the right answer.

Can you explain your thinking step by step? How did you arrive at the conclusion that "This has real solution if and only if k >=-0.25"?

Calvin Lin Staff - 7 years, 6 months ago

0 pending reports

×

Problem Loading...

Note Loading...

Set Loading...