Mind your Ps and Qs

Algebra Level 3

Under what conditions are the roots of

z 3 + p z 2 + q z + r = 0 z^3+p z^2 + q z + r = 0

guaranteed to form an equilateral triangle in the Argand plane? p , q p,q and r r may be complex.

p 2 = 3 q p^2=3q q = 3 p 2 q=3p^2 p q = 0 pq=0 r 2 = 3 p 2 + 3 q r^2=3p^2+3q

This section requires Javascript.
You are seeing this because something didn't load right. We suggest you, (a) try refreshing the page, (b) enabling javascript if it is disabled on your browser and, finally, (c) loading the non-javascript version of this page . We're sorry about the hassle.

1 solution

Peter Macgregor
Feb 13, 2017

Just to make the algebra easier let

p = 3 P p= 3P and q = 3 Q q=3Q so that the equation becomes

z 3 + 3 P z 2 + 3 Q z + r = 0 z^3+3Pz^2 +3Qz +r=0

Now make the substitution z = x P ( 1 ) z=x-P \dots(1) to get

( x 3 3 x 2 P + 3 x P 2 P 3 ) + 3 P ( x 2 2 P x + P 2 ) + 3 Q ( x P ) + r = 0 (x^3-3x^2 P+3x P^2-P^3)+3P(x^2-2Px+P^2)+3Q(x-P)+r=0

Now collect like terms, combining all the constant terms into a single complex number, k.

x 3 + ( 3 P + 3 P ) x 2 + ( 3 P 2 6 P 2 + 3 Q ) x + k = 0 x^3 + (-3P+3P)x^2+(3P^2-6P^2+3Q)x+k=0

Now if we set Q = P 2 ( 2 ) Q=P^2 \dots(2)

the equation becomes

x 3 = k x^3=-k

This equation has three roots placed symmetrically on a circle in the complex plane and so forming an equilateral triangle centred on the origin..

The transformation (1) shows that the z-solutions to the original problem are found by translating these x-solutions by the complex number -P. This simply slides the roots along the plane, maintaining them as an equilateral triangle!

To complete the problem we just need to translate the condition (2) back into the language of p and q, giving p 2 = 3 q \boxed{p^2=3q}

Nice problem and solution. When I went to edit the choices for you I could see which the correct option was, and since I hadn't yet finished working on the problem I had to reveal your solution without entering any answer option of my own. This ended up being for the best as I was leaning towards p q = 0 pq = 0 anyway. I had the three roots placed symmetrically on a circle but I didn't take into account the translation. Now that I've edited the options as you had indicated I deleted your note as well. I hope that's o.k.. In future you should be able to edit answer options by pressing the 3 dots at the lower right corner of the question box and choosing "Edit choices" from the menu.

Brian Charlesworth - 4 years, 3 months ago

Log in to reply

Brian, thank you for editing the choices for me. I'm glad you liked the problem.

b.t.w. I still don't see 'edit choices' in the pop up menu when I click the three dots.

Peter Macgregor - 4 years, 3 months ago

Log in to reply

Ah, o.k., that's interesting. I guess the "edit choices" option must only be available to moderators. I had thought it would be available to the writer of the question as well, but apparently not.

Brian Charlesworth - 4 years, 3 months ago

0 pending reports

×

Problem Loading...

Note Loading...

Set Loading...