Minimum Area Enclosed

Calculus Level 3

Suppose you have 1000 meters of fencing material. You set out to build a closed circular fence and a closed square fence, as shown above. The circular fence is partitioned into 4 quadrants by two perpendicular diameter sections.

If all of the fencing material must be used, what is the minimum possible combined area enclosed by the two fences (in square meters, to the nearest square meter)?


The answer is 20137.

This section requires Javascript.
You are seeing this because something didn't load right. We suggest you, (a) try refreshing the page, (b) enabling javascript if it is disabled on your browser and, finally, (c) loading the non-javascript version of this page . We're sorry about the hassle.

2 solutions

Zee Ell
Oct 26, 2016

Relevant wiki: Optimization

Let r r be the radius of the circle and a a be the side length of the square.

Recall the perimeter of a circle and a square can be expressed as 2 π r 2\pi r and 4 a 4a , respectively.

Then we can set up the following equation regarding the fence used:

( 2 π r + 4 r ) + 4 a = 1000 (2\pi r + 4r) + 4a = 1000

Changing the subject to a a gives a = 250 ( 1 + π 2 ) r a = 250 - \left( 1 + \dfrac \pi2 \right) r .

The combined area:

A = r 2 π + a 2 = r 2 π + ( 250 ( 1 + 0.5 π ) r ) 2 A = r^2π + a^2 = r^2π + (250 - (1+0.5π)r)^2

An easy way to find the minimal area is by differentiating (using the chain rule):

d A d R = 2 r π 2 ( 250 ( 1 + 0.5 π ) r ) ( 1 + 0.5 π ) \frac {dA}{dR} = 2r \pi - 2(250 - (1+0.5π)r)(1+0.5π)

2 r π 2 ( 250 ( 1 + 0.5 π ) r ) ( 1 + 0.5 π π ) = 0 2r \pi - 2(250 - (1+0.5 \pi )r)(1+0.5 \piπ) = 0

r = 500 ( 1 + 0.5 π ) 2 π + 2 ( 1 + 0.5 π ) 2 65.91389 m r = \dfrac {500(1+0.5 \pi)}{ 2 \pi+2(1+0.5 \pi)^2} \approx 65.91389 \text{ m}

Substituting this value back into our formulae regarding a and A, we get:

a 80.54881 m a \approx 80.54881 \text{ m}

and

A min = 20137.20331 m 2 = 20137 m 2 (0 d. p.) A_\text{min} = 20137.20331 \text{ m}^2 = \boxed {20137 \text{ m}^2 \text { (0 d. p.) } } .

By the second derivative test , we can show that d 2 A d R 2 r 65.91389 > 0 \left . \frac {d^2 A}{dR^2} \right |_{r \approx 65.91389}> 0 , so the extremal point that we have found is indeed the minimum value.

For completeness, I've added in the "second derivative test" line in your solution.

Pi Han Goh - 4 years, 7 months ago

x = length of wire bent into a circle

1000 - x = length of wire bent into a square

x = π d + 2 d x = πd + 2d

d = d= x π + 2 \frac{x}{π+2}

A = A= π 4 \frac{π}{4} ( ( x π + 12 ) 2 \frac{x}{π+12})^2 + ( +( 1000 x 4 \frac{1000-x}{4} ) 2 )^2

A = A= 0.029709 x 2 0.029709x^2 + + ( 1000 x ) 2 16 \frac{(1000-x)^2}{16}

d A d x \frac{dA}{dx} = 0.059418 x =0.059418x 1000 x 8 -\frac{1000-x}{8} = 0 =0

x = 677.8047471 x=677.8047471

d = 131.8277804 d=131.8277804

A = 13649.09199 + 6488.111312 = 20137.2033 A=13649.09199+6488.111312=20137.2033

0 pending reports

×

Problem Loading...

Note Loading...

Set Loading...