Minimum Volume Enclosed

Calculus Level 4

Suppose you have 10 square meters of "surface material", and you want to make a hollow sphere surface and a hollow cube surface.

If all of the material must be used (sphere surface area + cube surface area = 10 square meters), what is the minimum possible combined volume enclosed by the two shapes (in cubic meters, to three decimal places)?


The answer is 1.743.

This section requires Javascript.
You are seeing this because something didn't load right. We suggest you, (a) try refreshing the page, (b) enabling javascript if it is disabled on your browser and, finally, (c) loading the non-javascript version of this page . We're sorry about the hassle.

2 solutions

Chew-Seong Cheong
Oct 30, 2016

Let the surface area of the sphere be x x then that of the cube is 10 x 10-x . Then x = 4 π r 2 x = 4\pi r^2 , where r r is the radius of the sphere. r = x 4 π \implies r = \sqrt{\dfrac x{4\pi}} . The volume of the sphere V s = 4 3 π r 3 = 4 π 3 ( x 4 π ) 3 2 = x 3 2 3 4 π V_s = \dfrac 43 \pi r^3 = \dfrac {4\pi}3 \left(\dfrac x{4\pi}\right)^\frac 32 = \dfrac {x^\frac 32}{3\sqrt{4\pi}} .

The surface area of the cube ( 10 x ) = 6 a 2 (10-x) = 6a^2 , where a a is the side length of the cube. a = 10 x 6 \implies a = \sqrt{\dfrac {10-x}6} . Then the volume of the cube V c = a 3 = ( 10 x 6 ) 3 2 V_c = a^3 = \left(\dfrac {10-x}6\right)^\frac 32 .

The combined volume is therefore,

V = V s + V c = x 3 2 3 4 π + ( 10 x 6 ) 3 2 d V d x = x 1 2 2 4 π 1 4 ( 10 x 6 ) 1 2 Putting d V d x = 0 x 1 2 2 4 π = 1 4 ( 10 x 6 ) 1 2 x 16 π = 10 x 16 6 6 x = 10 π π x x = 10 π 6 + π \begin{aligned} V & = V_s+V_c \\ & = \frac {x^\frac 32}{3\sqrt{4\pi}} + \left(\frac {10-x}6\right)^\frac 32 \\ \frac {dV}{dx} & = \frac {x^\frac 12}{2\sqrt{4\pi}} - \frac 14\left(\frac {10-x}6\right)^\frac 12 & \small {\color{#3D99F6}\text{Putting }\frac {dV}{dx} = 0} \\ \frac {x^\frac 12}{2\sqrt{4\pi}} & = \frac 14\left(\frac {10-x}6\right)^\frac 12 \\ \frac {x}{16\pi} & = \frac {10-x}{16\cdot 6} \\ 6x & =10 \pi - \pi x \\ \implies x & = \frac {10\pi}{6+\pi} \end{aligned}

Note that d 2 V d x 2 = 1 4 4 π x + 1 48 6 10 x > 0 \dfrac {d^2V}{dx^2} = \dfrac 1{4\sqrt{4\pi x}} + \dfrac 1{48} \sqrt{\dfrac 6{10-x}} > 0 . This means that V V is minimum when x = 10 π 6 + π x = \dfrac {10\pi}{6+\pi} and:

V m i n = ( 10 π 6 + π ) 3 2 3 4 π + ( 10 π 6 + π 6 ) 3 2 1.743 \begin{aligned} V_{min} & = \frac {\left(\frac {10\pi}{6+\pi}\right)^\frac 32}{3\sqrt{4\pi}} + \left(\frac {10-\frac \pi{6+\pi}}6\right)^\frac 32 \approx \boxed{1.743} \end{aligned}

Did the same way without using x. But your use of is much better.

Niranjan Khanderia - 4 years, 6 months ago

Lagrangian method of multipliers is the shortest method for this optimisation problem realising: 10=4πx^2+6y^2=g(x,y)

4/3πx^3+y^3=f(x,y)=V

Now div{f(x,y)}=¥div{g(x,y)}

Where ¥ is the constant to be determined which comes up to ¥=(10/(96+16π))^(3/2)

And hence the ans is V=¥*((32π/3)+64))

which is

[(10/(96+16π))^(3/2)]*((32π/3)+64))=the given ans

Your use of Lagrangian method is very appropriate. 1+)

Niranjan Khanderia - 4 years, 6 months ago

0 pending reports

×

Problem Loading...

Note Loading...

Set Loading...