Moles and Gophers

Logic Level 1

Three spies, suspected as double agents, speak as follows when questioned:

Albert: "Bertie is a mole."
Bertie: "Cedric is a mole."
Cedric: "Bertie is lying."

Assuming that moles lie, other agents tell the truth, and there is just one mole among the three, determine who the mole is.

Albert Bertie Cedric None of them are moles

This section requires Javascript.
You are seeing this because something didn't load right. We suggest you, (a) try refreshing the page, (b) enabling javascript if it is disabled on your browser and, finally, (c) loading the non-javascript version of this page . We're sorry about the hassle.

5 solutions

Raghu Raman Ravi
Apr 28, 2017

The first 2 statements cannot be simultaneously correct, as there is only 1 mole. So one of the first 2 must be mole. Therefore the third person is not a mole and is hence telling the truth. The answer follows.

Thanks for the solution! It’s helped me a lot with this problem.

Diana Bradish - 1 year, 2 months ago
Tapas Mazumdar
May 1, 2017

We make the following three cases:

Case 1: Albert is the mole.

Since Albert is the mole, therefore he is the only person lying and therefore his statement - "Bertie is a mole" is false. But then Bertie is telling the truth when she made the statement - "Cedric is a mole". This is a contradiction and thus Albert is not a mole.

Case 2: Bertie is the mole.

So, Bertie must be the one lying about her statement that - "Cedric is a mole". Now, Cedric and Albert must both be speaking out the truth which perfectly fits our proposition - "Bertie is a mole" and "Bertie is lying". Thus Bertie is the mole.

Case 3: Cedric is the mole.

To check, Cedric must be lying about his statement - "Bertie is lying" so Bertie and Albert are both speaking out the truth. The statement made by Bertie perfectly agrees with our proposition but the statement made by Albert - "Bertie is a mole" doesn't fit as there is only one mole here. Again by reductio ad absurdum, we can say that Cedric is not a mole.

A perfect and clear solution that explains in detail! Well written!

William Huang - 3 years, 11 months ago
Matt A
May 29, 2017

Albert and Bertie's statements are contradictory, one of them may be a mole. Bertie and Cedric's statements are contradictory, one of them may be a mole. Albert and Cedric's statements are not contradictory, they are not the mole. Bertie is the mole.

Both Albert and Cedric are essentially saying that Bertie is the Mole. As there is only one Mole, they cannot both be lying; hence, Bertie is the mole.

Odinrawo201 Rom
May 2, 2017

Because two of the statements are about Bertie, them being"Bertie is the mole"and "Bertie is lying" and Bertie's statement is "Cedric is lying", if either Cedric or Albert are the mole, then two of the statements are lies. Thus, is rite must be the mole

0 pending reports

×

Problem Loading...

Note Loading...

Set Loading...