A bunch of bananas of total weight W is hung at one end of a string passing over a perfectly smooth pulley. At the other end, a monkey starts climbing up the rope at a constant acceleration and covers 16 ft in 2 seconds.
If the bananas always remain at rest, find the weight of the monkey.
Assume that g = 3 2 ft/s 2 .
This section requires Javascript.
You are seeing this because something didn't load right. We suggest you, (a) try
refreshing the page, (b) enabling javascript if it is disabled on your browser and,
finally, (c)
loading the
non-javascript version of this page
. We're sorry about the hassle.
Here the banana is stationary therefore T-mg=ma. i. e T=mg+ma. Since banana is stationary T=W this implies mg+ma=w
Why is the monkey assumed to be stationary. The problem statement said it had an upward acceleration. Is it because intitial velocity is assumed to be zero?
Log in to reply
You are right. The bananas are stationary. I have changed the solution.
Actually the weight of the monkey is by definition the force with which the monkey acts on the string. So the right answer is W. The same monkey will have zero weight being in a free fall: the weight depends on the situation. It's better to ask about the mass of the monkey then, if you want the problem not to be trivial.
Log in to reply
In this question, weight refers to how much strong is Earth's gravitational pull on it, which is equal to m g .
Why is it m(g + a) and not m(g - a)? The force of gravity accelerates the monkey in a downward direction, and the monkey is climbing (accelerating) in an upward direction.
Log in to reply
Here, we calculate the tension at both ends at the string. Monkey climbs the rope at a acceleration which implies that the rope is pulled down ( goes down) at a acceleration as well. Also, g acts on rope. So, tension at the end of rope on monkey's side is m ( g + a )
m(g+a)=Mg Shouldn't g be a negative quantity since it opposes the 🐒's motion?
Log in to reply
Here m ( g + a ) is the force that the monkey exerts on the rope as it climbs up. This can be seen if we draw the free body diagram of the monkey. The rope exerts force F upwards. The weight of the monkey is m g downwards. It accelerates with a upwards, so F − m g = m a , or F = m ( g + a ) .
I wish I knew these formulae that you demonstrated...
Log in to reply
You can refer to these wiki pages equations of motion and motion under constant acceleration to learn how we get the formulae.
Could a monkey possibly climb with a constant acceleration (as opposed to a constant speed) after it's gone from stationary to a comfortable climbing speed? If that's a long rope, this problem is going to end up with one seriously fast-climbing monkey.
Technically, the problem is missing the information that the monkey covers 16 ft in 2 sec from a stationary state. Changing from "climbs" to "starts climbing" should hopefully fix that.
Thanks, it has been added to the problem.
Log in to reply
Ok, i am apologizing for my brief answer: you see the problem? If bananas have an absolute weight, you see you can, imagine not only bananas but you can imagine concrete or stell, and it have an absolute weight, it can be calculated! weight is absolute i think, i mean a astronaut has the total weight like in space like on earth?
Log in to reply
What do you mean by absolute weight?
In this problem, weight implies the product of the mass of the bananas and the gravity g.
Not true, mass stays the same not weight
The bananas hhave a total weight, its absulute, is nt it?
That’s not a “technicality”, nor is the lack of info about what the bananas were doing before the monkey grabbed the rope. Another I’ll stated problem from ‘Brilliant’ (sic)
Yes, agreed, as 0 could be the constant acceleration of the monkey if it leapt onto the rope gaining its speed before climbing. Or the distance and time travelled could have been given from any point on the rope.
Surely the mass of the thread has some effect since it must be added to the mass of the Bananas? The Question does not indicate that the monkey actually stops after 2 seconds - if he carries on for ever the thread is infinitely long! If he stops he is mangled by the pulley and either jams the pulley or falls off.
Log in to reply
Or it reaches the bananas and changes the balance considerably to one side having the weights of monkey plus bananas and the other zero, at which point the monkey will descend at 24 ft/s/s. Also assuming the bananas are above the monkey otherwise it would be climbing down.
ROFLMAO at 24 ft/s/s
Imagine the monkey is running at x axis before getting on the rope, as he gets on the rope he suddenly changes his axis to y axis. Hence it can be deduced that he start from stationary.
Some more comments about the wording of the problem
Firstly, from the wording itself it is not clear whether the acceleration is to be taken with respect to the rope or the pulley. It comes to our rescue that the monkey climbs just fast enough so that the bananas remain at rest, and both concepts boil down to the same thing. Secondly, in physics we would say the bananas have mass W, whereas weight is the force mg of gravity g working on a mass m.
The monkey climbs with constant acceleration a. The distance climbed then is 2 1 a t 2 so that a = 2 × 1 6 / 2 2 = 8 f t / s 2 .
The tension force on the rope is ( a + g ) m = 4 0 m , where m is the mass of the monkey. This same tension force is holding the bananas up against gravity so 4 0 m = 3 2 W and m = 5 4 W .
Suppose the weight of the monkey is W ′ and acceleration of the monkey is f
So,
S = u t + 2 1 f t 2
1 6 = 0 × 2 + 2 1 f ( 2 ) 2 ⟹ f = 8 ft/s 2
If the tension is T , then the equation of motion of the monkey will be:
T − W ′ = g W ′ × f ⟹ T − W ′ = 3 2 W ′ × 8
⇒ T = W ′ + 4 W ′ = 4 5 W ′
So T = 4 5 W ′ . . . . . . . . . . ( 1 )
Since bananas always remain at rest,
T − W = 0 ⟹ T = W . . . . . . . . . . ( 2 )
From ( 1 ) and ( 2 ) , we get
4 5 W ′ = W ⟹ W ′ = 5 4 W
Log in to reply
S = u t + 2 1 f t 2
Log in to reply
This has come from SUVAT equations which are applicable when acceleration is constant. The equation used here is
S = u t + 2 1 a t 2 Here S is the displacement of the monkey, u is its initial speed, a is its acceleration and t is the time taken.
while I appreciate the idea of protecting the answer, it would be nice to know that the answer was in the discussion, and that by entering the discussion I would forfeit my right to answer the question. I feel cheated, and I did in fact arrive at the correct solution on my own.
Log in to reply
Wasn't it obvious?
Log in to reply
most sites that pose riddles and puzzles moderate posting the answer in the comments section if there is one. Normally the answer isn't even available, and is spoilered or removed any time someone tries to post it. I had intended to ask a question, which I realized right as I clicked the button, but at that point the site decided that I had looked at the answer. In short, no, it was not obvious. This is the first time I've seen "let's discuss this" to mean "what is the answer?"
I cant believe this site doesnt use the metric system.
Log in to reply
In this problem, the length units cancel off, so it doesn't really matter which system is used.
OK, so the monkey climbs 4.88 m in 2 seconds. His acceleration = 2* 4.88/4 = 2.44 m/sec/sec. The monkey's weight is W *9.81/(9.81+2.44) = W * 0.80
This problem is wrong stated, so is wrong solved. If the bananas are ALWAYS at rest then they were also at rest at the beginning, when the monkey was at rest. There fore at that moment bananas and monkey weighed the same,
Log in to reply
Zero speed does not imply zero acceleration. The monkey was initially at rest but has an acceleration upwards which implies the tension in the string (weight of the bananas) is greater than the weight of the monkey.
Log in to reply
If the weight of the bananas is greater than the weight of the monkey, then the monkey will not be "climbing" but will be pulled along by the falling bananas. Boreal Leon is correct.
what happens when the monkey who weighs less than the bananas reaches the top? presumably the bananas will pull the monkey or at least start descending so the monkey will fall off. JEFF
So I assumed that the monkey starts from rest, someone please inform me if there is a solution that does not assume this. I don't think there is but anyways, I digress.
We start by denoting a few things.
M m is the mass of the monkey.
F c is the force exerted on the string by the monkey's pulling.
a m is the acceleration of the monkey.
T is the tension in the string.
a b is the acceleration of the bananas.
First let's find a m :
s = u t + 2 1 a t 2
2 s = a m t 2
3 2 = 4 a m
a m = 8 f t s − 2
Do Newton's Second Law with respect to the bananas:
T − W = 0 since the bananas remain at rest.
T = W
Now do Newton's Second Law with respect to the monkey:
T − F c − M m g = M m a b where F c = M m a m
W − M m a m − M m g = 0 since a b = 0 and T = W
W = M m ( 3 2 + 8 )
M m = 4 0 W
Since W e i g h t m o n k e y = M m g
W e i g h t m o n k e y = 4 0 W ∗ 3 2 = 5 4 W
Since the bunch of bananas remain at rest, the weight of the climbing monkey has to be less. Therefore force at the monkey end will be its mass Mb (4/4)g plus the force due to its acceleration up Mm (1/4) g, which amounts 5/4 Mm g in total . At the banana side the force values Mb g.
Balancing both Mmg=4/5Mb g or in term of weights Wm= 4/5 Wb
I bet a 3 4 W solution option would trick some people :)
Oops... didn't see it's already been answered...sorry.
F(net)=0
So acc=0
M(G+A)=WG M=(G+A)/G M=4W/5
Let Mm = mass of monkey, Mb = mass of bananas..... a = 2*16/(2^2) = 8, g = 32
.......Forces are equal, so Fm = Mm * (g+a) = Fb = Mb * g
.......Mm * (g+a) = Mb * g, Then Mm = Mb * g / (g+a) = Mb * 32/40
.......Since weight is proportional to mass, then Wm = 4 Wb/5
None of these answers are correct. The question states that the weight of the bananas is W, but these solutions assume a MASS of W. Also, what the hell is a foot?
Problem Loading...
Note Loading...
Set Loading...
Relevant wiki: Newton's Third Law
Let the masses of the bananas and monkey be M and m respectively. Then the weights of the bananas and monkey are W = M g and w = m g respectively.
Let the acceleration the monkey climbing up the rope be a . Then using equation of motion ,
s 1 6 ⟹ a = u t + 2 1 a t 2 = ( 0 ) ( 2 ) + 2 1 a ( 2 2 ) = 8 ft/s 2
Since the bananas are stationary, by Newton's third law:
m ( g + a ) ( 3 2 + 8 ) m m m g ⟹ w = M g = 3 2 M = 5 4 M = 5 4 M g = 5 4 W