More clocks and angles

Algebra Level 4

At a given time, the hour and minute hands of a clock form an angle of exactly 1 8 18^\circ . What is the minimum amount of time it takes that this will be the case again, in seconds rounded to the nearest integer?


The answer is 393.

This section requires Javascript.
You are seeing this because something didn't load right. We suggest you, (a) try refreshing the page, (b) enabling javascript if it is disabled on your browser and, finally, (c) loading the non-javascript version of this page . We're sorry about the hassle.

2 solutions

Arjen Vreugdenhil
May 30, 2017

In one hour, the hour hand moves 1 / 12 1/12 of a revolution ahead, and the minute hand moves one revolution. Thus the position angle of the minute hand relative to the hour hand increases 11 / 12 11/12 revolution per hour. Thus, the angle between the hands increases at a rate of Δ θ Δ t = 33 0 hr . \frac{\Delta \theta}{\Delta t} = \frac{330^\circ}{\text{hr}}.

There are two possible scenarios:

  • if the minute hand was initially behind on the hour hand, θ = 1 8 , θ = + 1 8 , Δ θ = 3 6 ; \theta = -18^\circ, \theta' = +18^\circ, \Delta \theta = 36^\circ;

  • if the minute hand was initially ahead of the hour hand, θ = 1 8 , θ = 360 1 8 = 34 2 , Δ θ = 32 4 . \theta = 18^\circ, \theta' = 360 -18^\circ = 342^\circ, \Delta \theta = 324^\circ.

Clearly, the first scenario results in a smaller change in angle and therefore a shorter time interval. We have Δ t = Δ θ 33 0 / hr = 3 6 33 0 / hr × 60 × 60 s hr 393 s . \Delta t = \frac{\Delta \theta}{330^\circ/\text{hr}} = \frac{36^\circ}{330^\circ/\text{hr}} \times \frac{60\times 60\ \text{s}}{\text{hr}} \approx \boxed{393}\ \text{s}.

Alternative, more intuitive approach:

The minute hand moves over 1 8 18^\circ in 1/20th of an hour, i.e. 3 minutes. Another 3 minutes and it is 1 8 18^\circ ahead. Thus the answer would be 6 minutes if the hour hand stood still.

But the hour hand moves; in 6 minutes, or 1/10th of an hour, it moves 1/120th of.a revolution, or 3 3^\circ . To make up for this, the minute hand must also travel 3 3^\circ more, which takes 1/2 minute .

But in this extra half-minute, or 1/120th of an hour, the hour hand moves 1/1440th of a revolution. It takes the minute hand 1/24th minute, or 2 1/2 second to travel this distance.

Of course, in these 2 1/2 seconds the hour hand also moves a little, but barely. Therefore the answer will be slightly bigger than what we have so far, but the discrepancy is less than one second.

Conclusion: total time is 6 1/2 minute and slightly more than 2 1/2 seconds, or slightly over 392 1/2 seconds.

Arjen Vreugdenhil - 4 years ago

I tried converting it from an angular problem to a linear problem with a circle of radius 1, and I did get the answer, but I thought that it wouldn't be the answer.

Guy Alves - 4 years ago

Minimum amount of time would be taken if the minute hand is behind the hour hand. The two hands first will meet and then separate by 1 8 o 18^o .
That is twice the time taken for meeting.
In one minute, minute hand rotates 6 o 6^o and hour hand 6 / 12 = 1 / 2 o 6/12=1/2^o both cw.
So in one minute, the distance between two hands is changed by 6 1 / 2 = 11 / 5 o 6 - 1/2 = 11/5^o .
We want a change of 2 * 18= 3 6 o 36^o .
So minimum amount of time=36/(11/5) minutes=36/(11/5) *60 sec \approx 393 sec.



0 pending reports

×

Problem Loading...

Note Loading...

Set Loading...