Necker Cube

A constant current I I flows around the edges of a cube in two different ways as shown in the figure below. The magnetic induction vectors at the center of the cube in Fig. I and Fig. II are B I \vec{B}_{\text{I}} and B II \vec{B}_{\text{II}} , respectively. Find the angle in degrees between these vectors.


The answer is 54.74.

This section requires Javascript.
You are seeing this because something didn't load right. We suggest you, (a) try refreshing the page, (b) enabling javascript if it is disabled on your browser and, finally, (c) loading the non-javascript version of this page . We're sorry about the hassle.

4 solutions

For (I), the four currents contribute magnetic field vectors with directions: i + j , i + k , i j , i k i+j,i+k,i-j,i-k which sum up to i i .

For (II), the 6 currents contribute magnetic field vectors with directions: i + j , j k , i k , i + j , j k , i k i+j,j-k,i-k,i+j,j-k,i-k which sum up to 4 ( i + j k ) 4(i+j-k) . So we have c o s θ = ( i + j k ) . ( i ) 3 1 cos\theta = {(i+j-k) . (i) \over \sqrt{3}\sqrt{1}} . So θ = a c o s ( 1 3 ) = 54.7 3 o \theta = acos({1 \over \sqrt{3}}) = 54.73^o .

Very nice solution indeed.. I found the same solution very hard way! I only want you to elaborate more about i + j i+j etc. What are the directions of your unit vectors and how do you get direction of magnetic field?

Snehal Shekatkar - 7 years, 7 months ago
Lokesh Sharma
Oct 7, 2013

B I \vec {B_{I}} = x ^ \hat {x}

B I I \vec {B_{II}} = x ^ + y ^ + z ^ \hat {x} + \hat {y} + \hat{z}

θ = c o s 1 B I . B I I B I B I I \theta = cos^{-1} \frac{\vec {B_{I}}.\vec {B_{II}}}{|B_{I}| |B_{II}}| = c o s 1 1 3 cos^{-1}\frac{1}{\sqrt3} = 54.7 4 54.74^ \circ

Advitiya Brijesh
Oct 7, 2013

In figure I, the net magnetic field due to current is along +ve x a x i s x-axis so let B I = B 0 i ^ B_{I}=B_{0} \hat{i}

As, The magnitude of current is same in second case as well so B I I = B 0 i ^ + B 0 j ^ + B 0 k ^ B_{II}=B_{0} \hat{i} + B_{0} \hat{-j} + B_{0} \hat{k} Now using scalar product of vectors will fetch us θ = c o s 1 1 3 \theta = cos^{-1} \frac{1}{\sqrt{3}} so, θ 54.74 \theta \approx 54.74

I think you have merely provided a sketch of a solution, not a full solution itself. You skipped the heart of this question (which is to determine the sum of the vectors).

These solutions are like of the form: We set up everything in Cartesian co-ordinates first, let the x x axis be \cdots , and just when it feels like this is gonna be a great solution, it has a pathetic ending by simple arguments fetch us \text{simple arguments fetch us } \cdots . :)

Sreejato Bhattacharya - 7 years, 8 months ago
Angel Leon
Oct 12, 2013

I decomposed in pairs of vectors and used the right hand rule to determine the direction of the resulting magnetic field fields. I assumed that the resulting magnitude of each resulting vector would be 1 on the resulting axis. So, if I did, y cross - z => 1 unit on x, and so on.

On (I), I ended up with B1 = (2,0,0) On (II), I ended up with B2 = (1,-1,1)

Then I did, Cos(x) = (B1 dot B2)/|B1||B2| Cos(x) = 2/ (2 * (3)^1/2)

Cos(x) = (3^1/2)/3

Then solved for x, using acos((3^1/2)/3) = 54.74

0 pending reports

×

Problem Loading...

Note Loading...

Set Loading...