Neither series nor parallel circuit

Five resistors are connected as shown below.

Note that the resistors are neither connected in series nor in parallel. However, it turns out that the set of resistors is equivalent to a single resistor R A B R_{AB} . Determine the resistance in Ohms R A B R_{AB} .


The answer is 2.

This section requires Javascript.
You are seeing this because something didn't load right. We suggest you, (a) try refreshing the page, (b) enabling javascript if it is disabled on your browser and, finally, (c) loading the non-javascript version of this page . We're sorry about the hassle.

8 solutions

Discussions for this problem are now closed

Pranjit Handique
May 20, 2014

The three 3 ohms resistors forms a delta which can be converted to three 1 ohms resistors in a star (since (3 3)/(3+3+3)=1. Delta to star conversion formula R1=(R12 R13)/(R12+R13+R23)), one of these three 1 ohm resistor in the star connects to point A and the other two connected to one each of the 1 ohms resistors connected to point B. The resultant is a circuit with a 1 ohm resistor in series with two parallel 2 ohms resistors (series circuit formula R=R1+R2+….). which is again equal to a circuit with a 1 ohm resistor in series with another 1 ohm resistor ( parallel circuit formula (1/R)=(1/R1)+(1/R2)+…..) ). The equivalent resistance is therefore 2 ohms.(series circuit formula R=R1+R2+….).

Adithyan Rk
Sep 10, 2013

Notice that, this arrangement forms a balanced Wheatstone bridge. So you can easily remove the connecting resistance and this arrangement simplifies to a series and parallel connection.

For more information on Wheatstone bridge, watch this video:

Principle of Wheatstone bridge

yep. this circuit is way more simple than what it appears at first.

Kunal Rmth - 7 years, 9 months ago

here we should consider the wheatstone bridge in which the current flowing through the CD bridging resistor to be zero, as the bridge is balanced.i.e p/q=r/s here p=r=3 ohms and q=s=1 ohm. p and q are in series and so are q and s. the combination of p and q is in parallel with that of s and r.i.e equivalent resistance of the combination will be (p+q)(r+s)/p+q+r+s= 2 ohms

We have the following equations:

v a v c = 3 i v_a-v_c=3i

v a v d = 3 ( I i ) v_a-v_d=3(I-i)

v c v d = 3 j v_c-v_d=3j

v c v b = i j v_c-v_b=i-j

v d v b = I i + j v_d-v_b=I-i+j

Solving, we have j = I 2 i j=I-2i and i = 1 2 I i={1 \over 2}I . Finally, we have v a v b = 2 I v a v b I = 2 v_a-v_b=2I \implies {v_a-v_b \over I} = 2 .

using delta to wye convertion, Ry = Rdelta/3, for balanced resistances. then converting the left side with 3 ohms, Ry = 1 ohm.

after that, two-1 ohm are in series and in parallel to the same two-1 ohm resistors, which is in series with the 1 ohm resistance on the left side. Rab = 1 + ((2*2)/(2+2)) = 2 ohms

Matt McNabb
Sep 15, 2013

Since this circuit is symmetrical about the x-axis, , there can be no current along the path C D CD .

So it is just the same as two resistors of 4 Ω 4 \Omega in parallel, i.e. 2 Ω \boxed{2 \Omega} total.

However, if the circuit were not symmetrical then we could solve it via the Y-delta transform :

my picture my picture

This transform changes a triangle of resistors, into resistors going from each vertex to a point. The formula is given in the above link; in this case it works out that D P = D C 3 = 1 DP = {DC \over 3} = 1 . So we end up with A P = 1 Ω AP = 1 \Omega , P C = P D = 1 Ω PC = PD = 1 \Omega , and C B = D B = 1 Ω CB = DB = 1 \Omega which are unchanged from the original.

The section from P P to B B is two parallel resistances of 2 Ω 2 \Omega , so the total resistance from P P to B B is 1 Ω 1 \Omega . Combining this in series with A P AP gives the total of 2 Ω 2 \Omega .

hmmm... quite interesting. but a simple way could be that the potential drop across C and D is equal as they both cross a 3 ohm resistor. therefore the current will not flow through wire CD. this can be one of the approaches

Utkarsh Mehra - 7 years, 9 months ago
Guillermo Angeris
Sep 11, 2013

The best way to do one of these is to 'connect' a 1V source to the outputs, solve the circuit using mesh analysis, and use Ohm's law on the remaining loop. From mesh analysis, we receive (naming the loops clockwise, starting from the left triangle):

9 I 1 3 I 2 3 I 3 = 0 3 I 1 + 5 I 2 I 3 = 0 3 I 1 I 2 + 4 I 3 = 1 \begin{aligned} 9I_1-3I_2-3I_3&=0\\ -3I_1+5I_2-I_3&=0\\ -3I_1-I_2+4I_3&=1 \end{aligned} Solving gives us, simply that ( I 1 , I 2 , I 3 ) = ( 1 4 , 1 4 , 1 2 ) (I_1,I_2,I_3)=(\frac{1}{4},\frac{1}{4},\frac{1}{2}) , and, using Ohm's law, we have that: V I = R = 1 . 5 = 2 Ohms \frac{V}{I}=R=\frac{1}{.5}=2\text{ Ohms}

Tilak Patel
Sep 11, 2013

Try to observe,

This is a balanced Wheatstone bridge,

Hence, no current will flow from resistor CD of 3 ohm

total resistence in ACB = 4 ohm

total reisitence in ADB = 4 ohm

ADB and ACB are in parallel connection

Hence, total resistence = 4 × 4 4 + 4 \frac{4\times4}{4+4} ohms = 2ohms

0 pending reports

×

Problem Loading...

Note Loading...

Set Loading...