Non Specification Billiard Ball

Logic Level 2

Colin has a set of 12 billiard balls. The balls look identical, however due to a manufacturing error one of the balls is either slightly lighter or slightly heavier than the others. To investigate, Colin only has a set of balance scales. What is the minimum number of times Colin would have to use the scales in order to determine which ball is non-specification, and also whether it is heavier or lighter than the others?

3 4 5 6

This section requires Javascript.
You are seeing this because something didn't load right. We suggest you, (a) try refreshing the page, (b) enabling javascript if it is disabled on your browser and, finally, (c) loading the non-javascript version of this page . We're sorry about the hassle.

2 solutions

Colin Mabey
Jun 30, 2017

Coding

G= Known Good

U = Unknown (Could be heavy or light)

H= Possibly Heavy - (but can not be light)

L = Possibly Light - (but can not be heavy)

Initially we have 12 U -- 12 unknown balls.

Balance 1 is 4 Balls versus 4 Balls UUUU Vrs UUUU

Case 1 - scales balance - we have 8 good balls and 4 unknown - 8G4U

Case 2 - Scales do not balance In this case we know the 4 balls not used are good, the side of the scales that went down may contain a heavy ball or the side that went up may contain a light ball. The fact balls may be Heavy or Light but not the opposite is important. Hence 4G4H4L

Now we look at case 1 untill conclusion We have 8G4U

Balance 2 GGG Vrs UUU Scale balances we now have 11 good ball, and one which is unknown - 11G1U

    Balance 3 is a simple to find out if 1 unknown ball is heavy or light.

     Scale does not Balance   - UUU goes up  - one of the three unknown must be light

     We now have  9G3L

    Balance 3 is   L vrs L    side that goes up is light ball, or if balance ball not used is light

     Scale does not Balance -  UUU goes down - one of the 3  unknown must be heavy     

     We now have  9G3H

    Balance 3 is   H vrs H    side that goes down  is a heavy  ball, or if balance ball not used is heavy

Now we look at case 2 untill conclusion We have 4G4H4L

Balance 2

HHHLL Vrs HGGGG

      Scale balances  - all the balls weighed are good so we are left with 2 possible light balls.  - 10G2L

       Balance 3 is  L vrs L   to show which ball is light

      HHHLL goes up /HGGGG goes down   either the two L s are light or the H from the other side is heavy

     Balance 3 is  L vrs L  to show which is light - or if balances the H not weighed  is a heavy ball.

      HHHLL goes down/HGGG goes up   -  one of the three H's must be heavy.

                           Balance 3  is H vrs H  to show which ball is heavy  - or if it balances the H not wieghed is heavy.

3 Balances is all that is required.

by using divide and conquer technique

0 pending reports

×

Problem Loading...

Note Loading...

Set Loading...