One of two coefficients of fit of relationship density to fall time.

The problem's question is What is the value of a a in the log-log fit of density in kilograms per cubic meter to the contact time of two identical balls of the same uniform density, each ball has a radius of 1 meter, total vacuum, both balls are in free fall with 0 relative velocity, they are the entire universe to be considered (no external gravitational field to be considered, no outside effects to be considered, radioactivity and radiation pressure are to be ignored, evaporation of the ball's material can be ignored, etc. This is a mathematical Newtonian gravity problem.

g = 6.674 × 1 0 11 m 3 / ( k g s 2 ) g=6.674\times10^{-11}m^3/(kg\,s^2) was used. But this does not affect the requested answer.

The equation to be fit is time in seconds = b × 1 0 a L o g 10 ( density in kg/m 3 ) \text{time in seconds}\,=\,b\times 10^{a\,Log_{10}(\text{density in kg/m}^3)} . Only a a , the easier of the two coefficients, is requested.


The answer is -0.5.

This section requires Javascript.
You are seeing this because something didn't load right. We suggest you, (a) try refreshing the page, (b) enabling javascript if it is disabled on your browser and, finally, (c) loading the non-javascript version of this page . We're sorry about the hassle.

1 solution

I worked the problem the hard way. Using the densities of pure elements ranging from lithium to osmium, I computed the fall times using numerical solution of the differential equation , { y ( t ) = na ( 2 y ( t ) ) 2 , y ( 0 ) = 0 , y ( 0 ) = 5. } ,\left\{y''(t)=\frac{\text{na}}{(2 y(t))^2},y'(0)=0,y(0)=5.\right\} . The value of na \text{na} is the acceleration due to gravity at the time of contact. Then I did the log-log fit and looked at the answer. Duh! Since gravity is an inverse square phenomenon, the value of a a has to be the reciprocal of 2 -2 , i.e., 1 2 -\frac12 . That is what the fit showed. The value of b b based on the units and the experimental setup is 1 425 242.3116 1\,425\,242.3116 seconds.

The list of elements used: Actinium, Aluminum, Americium, Antimony, Arsenic, Barium, Berkelium, Beryllium, Bismuth, Boron, Bromine, Cadmium, Calcium, Californium, Carbon, Cerium, Cesium, Chromium, Cobalt, Copper, Curium, Dysprosium, Erbium, Europium, Gadolinium, Gallium, Germanium, Gold, Hafnium, Holmium, Indium, Iodine, Iridium, Iron, Lanthanum, Lead, Lithium, Lutetium, Magnesium, Manganese, Mercury, Molybdenum, Neodymium, Neptunium, Nickel, Niobium, Osmium, Palladium, Phosphorus, Platinum, Plutonium, Polonium, Potassium, Praseodymium, Promethium, Protactinium, Radium, Rhenium, Rhodium, Rubidium, Ruthenium, Samarium, Scandium, Selenium, Silicon, Silver, Sodium, Strontium, Sulfur, Tantalum, Technetium, Tellurium, Terbium, Thallium, Thorium, Thulium, Tin, Titanium, Tungsten, Uranium, Vanadium, Ytterbium, Yttrium, Zinc and Zirconium. I only used element known to solids or liquids at standard temperature and pressure and which had known densities. I could have used arbitrary densities just as well.

g = 6.674 ˋ 11 Quantity [ Meters ] 3 Quantity [ Kilograms ] Quantity [ Seconds ] 2 g=\frac{6.674 \grave{ } * {}^{\wedge} -11 \text{Quantity}[\text{Meters}]^3}{\text{Quantity}[\text{Kilograms}] \text{Quantity}[\text{Seconds}]^2}

I actually solved the differential equation twice once by a single Riemann sum to get a guess of how long it takes for the balls to meet and using Mathematica's internal differential equation solver to get a more accurate answer. The reason for this is that the differential equation goes singular shortly after contact when the centers distance goes to 0.

table = Table [ density = ElementData [ element , Density ] ; mass = densityVolume [ Ball [ { 5 , 0 , 0 } , Quantity [ 1 , Meter ] ] ] ; a = d Evaluate [ g mass d 2 ] ; step = 300 s ; t = 0 s ; s = 5. m ; v = 0. m / s ; While [ s > Quantity [ 1. , Meter ] , acceleration = a ( 2 s ) ; s += acceleration step 2 2 + step v ; v +=accelerationstep ; t +=step ; ] ; guess = QuantityMagnitude [ t ] ; ClearAll [ y ] ; ClearAll [ t ] ; na = QuantityMagnitude [ a ( 1 ) ] ; y = ( y /. NDSolve [ { y ( t ) = na ( 2 y ( t ) ) 2 , y ( 0 ) = 0 , y ( 0 ) = 5. } , y , { t , 0 , 0.9991 guess } , Method ImplicitRungeKutta ] ) [ [ 1 ] ] ; ClearAll [ time ] ; time = time/. FindRoot [ y ( time ) = 1 , { time , 0.98 guess } ] ; { element , density , times , UnitConvert [ times , MixedUnit [ { Days , Hours , Minutes , Seconds } ] ] } , { element , elements } ] \text{table}=\text{Table}\left[ \\ \text{density}=\text{ElementData}[\text{element},\text{Density}]; \\ \text{mass}=\text{density} \text{Volume}[\text{Ball}[\{-5,0,0\},\text{Quantity}[1,\text{Meter}]]]; \\ a=d\to \text{Evaluate}\left[-\frac{g \text{mass}}{d^2}\right]; \\ \text{step}=300\text{s}; \\ t=0\text{s}; \\ s=5.\text{m}; \\ v=0.\text{m}/\text{s}; \\ \text{While}\left[s>\text{Quantity}[1.,\text{Meter}], \\ \text{acceleration}=a(2 s); \\ s\text{+=}\frac{\text{acceleration} \text{step}^2}{2}+\text{step} v; \\ v\text{+=}\text{acceleration} \text{step}; \\ t\text{+=}\text{step}; \\ \right]; \\ \text{guess}=\text{QuantityMagnitude}[t]; \\ \text{ClearAll}[y]; \\ \text{ClearAll}[t]; \\ \text{na}=\text{QuantityMagnitude}[a(1)]; \\ y=\left(y\text{/.}\, \text{NDSolve}\left[\left\{y''(t)=\frac{\text{na}}{(2 y(t))^2},y'(0)=0,y(0)=5.\right\},y,\{t,0,0.9991 \text{guess}\},\text{Method}\to \text{ImplicitRungeKutta}\right]\right)[[1]]; \\ \text{ClearAll}[\text{time}]; \\ \text{time}=\text{time}\text{/.}\, \text{FindRoot}[y(\text{time})=1,\{\text{time},0.98 \text{guess}\}]; \\ \{\text{element},\text{density},\text{time}\text{s},\text{UnitConvert}[\text{time}\text{s},\text{MixedUnit}[\{\text{Days},\text{Hours},\text{Minutes},\text{Seconds}\}]]\},\{\text{element},\text{elements}\} \\ \right]

The output is too large for easy cutting-and-pasting. Here is the log-log plot:

The fit is about 10 digits accurate.

Interesting follow-up question. Will you make another asking for the "b" coefficient?

Steven Chase - 2 years ago

I was not planning on it. That is why I gave the value of b b in my explanation.

0 pending reports

×

Problem Loading...

Note Loading...

Set Loading...