One to Two,Isosceles to Isosceles

Geometry Level 3

One possible way to draw \(ABC\) and split it into two isosceles triangles is shown here. One possible way to draw A B C ABC and split it into two isosceles triangles is shown here.

An isosceles triangle A B C ABC ( ( with B = C ) \angle B=\angle C) is cut into two smaller isosceles triangles (which don't have to be identical).

How many different possible angles A \angle A are there?

1 2 3 4 5

This section requires Javascript.
You are seeing this because something didn't load right. We suggest you, (a) try refreshing the page, (b) enabling javascript if it is disabled on your browser and, finally, (c) loading the non-javascript version of this page . We're sorry about the hassle.

2 solutions

David Vreken
Aug 11, 2018

The 4 4 different A \angle A possibilities are A = 108 ° \angle A = 108° , A = 90 ° \angle A = 90° , A = 25 5 7 ° \angle A = 25 \frac{5}{7}° , and A = 36 ° \angle A = 36° , as illustrated below:


In order to make 2 2 triangles out of 1 1 triangle from one cut, the cut must go through a vertex and its opposite side. Since A B C \triangle ABC is an isosceles with B = C \angle B = \angle C , so we only need to consider cuts that go through either A \angle A or B \angle B . In all cases, A B = B C AB = BC and B = C \angle B = \angle C by isosceles triangle properties.


Case A A : Let the cut intersect A \angle A and point D D along B C BC . If the cut results in 2 2 isosceles triangles, then there are 9 9 cases to consider:

A 1 ) A1) A B = A D AB = AD and A D = A C AD = AC . Let x = C x = \angle C . Then A D C = x \angle ADC = x since A D = A C AD = AC , A D B = 180 ° x \angle ADB = 180° - x since A D C \angle ADC and A D B \angle ADB are linear, A B D = 180 ° x \angle ABD = 180° - x since A B = A D AB = AD , so x = 180 ° x x = 180° - x since B = C \angle B = \angle C , which means x = 90 ° x = 90° , which means A C D \triangle ACD has two right angles, which is not possible.

A 2 ) A2) A B = A D AB = AD and A D = C D AD = CD . Let x = C x = \angle C . Then C A D = x \angle CAD = x since A D = D C AD = DC , A D C = 180 ° 2 x \angle ADC = 180° - 2x by triangle sum of A C D \triangle ACD , A D B = 2 x \angle ADB = 2x since A D C \angle ADC and A D B \angle ADB are linear, B = 2 x \angle B = 2x since A B = A D AB = AD , so x = 2 x x = 2x since B = C \angle B = \angle C , which means x = 0 ° x = 0° , which is not a possible angle for a triangle.

A 3 ) A3) A B = A D AB = AD and A C = C D AC = CD . Let x = C x = \angle C . Then A D C = 90 ° x 2 \angle ADC = 90° - \frac{x}{2} by isosceles triangle sum of A C D \triangle ACD , A D B = 90 ° + x 2 \angle ADB = 90° + \frac{x}{2} since A D C \angle ADC and A D B \angle ADB are linear, B = 90 ° + x 2 \angle B = 90° + \frac{x}{2} since A B = A D AB = AD , so x = 90 ° + x 2 x = 90° + \frac{x}{2} since B = C \angle B = \angle C , which means x = 180 ° x = 180° , which is not a possible angle for a triangle.

A 4 ) A4) A B = B D AB = BD and A D = A C AD = AC . By symmetry this is the same as Case A 3 A3 , which was not possible.

A 5 ) A5) A B = B D AB = BD and A D = C D AD = CD . Let x = C x = \angle C . Then C A D = x \angle CAD = x since A D = D C AD = DC , A D C = 180 ° 2 x \angle ADC = 180° - 2x by triangle sum of A C D \triangle ACD , A D B = 2 x \angle ADB = 2x since A D C \angle ADC and A D B \angle ADB are linear, B A D = 2 x \angle BAD = 2x since A B = B D AB = BD , B = 180 ° 4 x \angle B = 180° - 4x by triangle sum of A C D \triangle ACD , so x = 180 ° 4 x x = 180° - 4x since B = C \angle B = \angle C , which means x = 36 ° x = 36° , C A D = x = 36 ° \angle CAD = x = 36° , B A D = 2 x = 2 36 ° = 72 ° \angle BAD = 2x = 2 \cdot 36° = 72° , and A = B A D + C A D = 72 ° + 36 ° = 108 ° \angle A = \angle BAD + \angle CAD = 72°+ 36° = \boxed{108°} .

A 6 ) A6) A B = B D AB = BD and A C = C D AC = CD . Let x = C x = \angle C . Then A D C = 90 ° x 2 \angle ADC = 90° - \frac{x}{2} by isosceles triangle sum of A C D \triangle ACD , A D B = 90 ° + x 2 \angle ADB = 90° + \frac{x}{2} since A D C \angle ADC and A D B \angle ADB are linear, B A D = 90 ° + x 2 \angle BAD = 90° + \frac{x}{2} since A B = A D AB = AD , B = x \angle B = -x by triangle sum of A B D \triangle ABD , so x = x x = -x since B = C \angle B = \angle C , which means x = 0 ° x = 0° , which is not a possible angle for a triangle.

A 7 ) A7) A D = B D AD = BD and A D = A C AD = AC . By symmetry this is the same as Case A 2 A2 , which was not possible.

A 8 ) A8) A D = B D AD = BD and A D = C D AD = CD . Let x = C x = \angle C . Then C A D = x \angle CAD = x since A D = D C AD = DC , A D C = 180 ° 2 x \angle ADC = 180° - 2x by triangle sum of A C D \triangle ACD , A D B = 2 x \angle ADB = 2x since A D C \angle ADC and A D B \angle ADB are linear, B = B A D = 90 ° x \angle B = \angle BAD = 90° - x by isosceles triangle sum of A B D \triangle ABD , so x = 90 ° x x = 90° - x since B = C \angle B = \angle C , which means x = 45 ° x = 45° , C A D = x = 45 ° \angle CAD = x = 45° , B A D = 90 ° x = 90 ° 45 ° = 45 ° \angle BAD = 90° - x = 90° - 45° = 45° , and A = B A D + C A D = 45 ° + 45 ° = 90 ° \angle A = \angle BAD + \angle CAD = 45°+ 45° = \boxed{90°} .

A 9 ) A9) A D = B D AD = BD and A C = C D AC = CD . By symmetry this is the same as Case A 5 A5 , which would give A = 108 ° \angle A = 108° again.


Case B B : Let the cut intersect B \angle B and point D D along A C AC . If the cut results in 2 2 isosceles triangles, then there are 9 9 cases to consider:

B 1 ) B1) A B = B D AB = BD and B C = B D BC = BD . Let x = C x = \angle C . Then B D C = x \angle BDC = x since B C = B D BC = BD , A D B = 180 ° x \angle ADB = 180° - x since B D C \angle BDC and A D B \angle ADB are linear, A = 180 ° x \angle A = 180° - x since A B = B D AB = BD , C B D = 180 ° 2 x \angle CBD = 180° - 2x by triangle sum of B C D \triangle BCD , A B D = 2 x 180 ° \angle ABD = 2x - 180° by triangle sum of A B D \triangle ABD , B = 0 ° \angle B = 0° as the sum of C B D \angle CBD and B C D \angle BCD , which is not a possible angle for a triangle.

B 2 ) B2) A B = B D AB = BD and B D = C D BD = CD . Let x = C x = \angle C . Then C B D = x \angle CBD = x since B D = C D BD = CD , B D C = 180 ° 2 x \angle BDC = 180° - 2x by triangle sum of B C D \triangle BCD , A D B = 2 x \angle ADB = 2x since B D C \angle BDC and A D B \angle ADB are linear, A = 2 x \angle A = 2x since A B = B D AB = BD , A B D = 180 ° 4 x \angle ABD = 180° - 4x by triangle sum of A B D \triangle ABD , B = 180 ° 3 x \angle B = 180° - 3x as the sum of C B D \angle CBD and B C D \angle BCD , so x = 180 ° 3 x x = 180° - 3x since B = C \angle B = \angle C , which means x = 45 ° x = 45° , A D B = 2 x = 2 45 ° = 90 ° \angle ADB = 2x = 2 \cdot 45° = 90° , and A = 2 x = 2 45 ° = 90 ° \angle A = 2x = 2 \cdot 45° = 90° , which means A B D \triangle ABD has two right angles, which is not possible.

B 3 ) B3) A B = B D AB = BD and B C = C D BC = CD . Let x = C x = \angle C . Then C B D = C D B = 90 ° x 2 \angle CBD = \angle CDB = 90° - \frac{x}{2} by isosceles triangle sum of B C D \triangle BCD , A D B = 90 ° + x 2 \angle ADB = 90° + \frac{x}{2} since B D C \angle BDC and A D B \angle ADB are linear, A = 90 ° + x 2 \angle A = 90° + \frac{x}{2} since A B = B D AB = BD , A B D = x \angle ABD = -x by triangle sum of A B D \triangle ABD , B = 90 ° 3 x 2 \angle B = 90° - \frac{3x}{2} as the sum of C B D \angle CBD and B C D \angle BCD , so x = 90 ° 3 x 2 x = 90° - \frac{3x}{2} since B = C \angle B = \angle C , which means x = 72 ° x = 72° and A B D = x = 72 ° \angle ABD = -x = -72° , which is not a possible angle for a triangle.

B 4 ) B4) A D = B D AD = BD and B C = B D BC = BD . Let x = C x = \angle C . Then B D C = x \angle BDC = x since B C = B D BC = BD , A D B = 180 ° x \angle ADB = 180° - x since B D C \angle BDC and A D B \angle ADB are linear, C B D = 180 ° 2 x \angle CBD = 180° - 2x by triangle sum of B C D \triangle BCD , A = A B D = x 2 \angle A = \angle ABD = \frac{x}{2} by isosceles triangle sum of A B D \triangle ABD , B = 180 ° 3 x 2 \angle B = 180° - \frac{3x}{2} as the sum of C B D \angle CBD and B C D \angle BCD , so x = 180 ° 3 x 2 x = 180° - \frac{3x}{2} since B = C \angle B = \angle C , which means x = 72 ° x = 72° and A = x 2 = 72 ° 2 = 36 ° \angle A = \frac{x}{2} = \frac{72°}{2} = \boxed{36°} .

B 5 ) B5) A D = B D AD = BD and B D = C D BD = CD . Let x = C x = \angle C . Then C B D = x \angle CBD = x since B D = C D BD = CD , B D C = 180 ° 2 x \angle BDC = 180° - 2x by triangle sum of B C D \triangle BCD , A D B = 2 x \angle ADB = 2x since B D C \angle BDC and A D B \angle ADB are linear, A = A B D = 90 ° x \angle A = \angle ABD = 90° - x by isosceles triangle sum of A B D \triangle ABD , B = 90 ° \angle B = 90° as the sum of C B D \angle CBD and B C D \angle BCD , so x = 90 ° x = 90° since B = C \angle B = \angle C , which means B = C = 90 ° \angle B = \angle C = 90° , which means A B C \triangle ABC has two right angles, which is not possible.

B 6 ) B6) A D = B D AD = BD and B C = C D BC = CD . Let x = C x = \angle C . Then C B D = C D B = 90 ° x 2 \angle CBD = \angle CDB = 90° - \frac{x}{2} by isosceles triangle sum of B C D \triangle BCD , A D B = 90 ° + x 2 \angle ADB = 90° + \frac{x}{2} since B D C \angle BDC and A D B \angle ADB are linear, A = A B D = 45 ° x 4 \angle A = \angle ABD = 45° - \frac{x}{4} by isosceles triangle sum of A B D \triangle ABD , B = 135 ° 3 x 4 \angle B = 135° - \frac{3x}{4} as the sum of C B D \angle CBD and B C D \angle BCD , so x = 135 ° 3 x 4 x = 135° - \frac{3x}{4} since B = C \angle B = \angle C , which means x = 77 1 7 ° x = 77\frac{1}{7}° and A = 45 ° x 4 = 45 ° 77 1 7 ° 4 = 25 5 7 ° \angle A = 45° - \frac{x}{4} = 45° - \frac{77\frac{1}{7}°}{4} = \boxed{25\frac{5}{7}°} .

B 7 ) B7) A B = A D AB = AD and B C = B D BC = BD . Then A C = A B = A D AC = AB = AD , and C D = A C A D = 0 CD = AC - AD = 0 , which is not a possible length for a triangle.

B 8 ) B8) A B = A D AB = AD and B D = C D BD = CD . Then A C = A B = A D AC = AB = AD , and C D = A C A D = 0 CD = AC - AD = 0 , which is not a possible length for a triangle.

B 9 ) B9) A B = A D AB = AD and B C = C D BC = CD . Then A C = A B = A D AC = AB = AD , and C D = A C A D = 0 CD = AC - AD = 0 , which is not a possible length for a triangle.


Therefore, the only different A \angle A possibilities are 108 ° 108° , 90 ° 90° , 25 5 7 ° 25 \frac{5}{7}° , and 36 ° 36° .

Ergh. I read the question as asking , for some A, how many other angles in the diagram had the same value

Matt McNabb - 2 years, 9 months ago

Log in to reply

Same. It would be 3, right?

Isaac Pace - 2 years, 9 months ago

Log in to reply

Same here as well. And yes, it would be 3.

Motty Stone - 2 years, 9 months ago

Yea, I got three. This one is way over my head.

Matt Mascitti - 2 years, 9 months ago

the authors!! PLEASE change the text! the way it is now, especially those unnoticeable small letters under the drawing, is quite misleading and bloody irritating! my advise is to put the phrase "one possible way to..." RIGHT BEFORE the question, so it was much more distinctive!

Nik Gibson - 2 years, 9 months ago

WHAT A SMALL SOLUTION.

Zhanbolat Kussainov - 2 years, 9 months ago

Log in to reply

Lol..😂😄😅. I've never seen such a small solution!

Prem Chebrolu - 2 years, 9 months ago

There has to be a simpler solution. I obviously missed something in my approach and only found two but wasn't expecting this. I'm still none the wiser, apart from realising that I missed the right-angle triangle solution.

Malcolm Rich - 2 years, 9 months ago

Thanks for telling me that this question is indeed not so easy to me...

Kelvin Hong - 2 years, 9 months ago

Help

Take and c to be x Then angle b=x Angle BDC =x This makes angle ABD=3x-180 Angle a =180-2x As both are equal x=72

Anmol Arichwal - 2 years, 9 months ago

Now this is what I call a SOLUTION!

EKENE FRANKLIN - 2 years, 9 months ago

I'll pretend i get it 🙄

João David - 2 years, 8 months ago

How do you have patience to write such a long answer??

Prem Chebrolu - 2 years, 8 months ago
Arjen Vreugdenhil
Aug 21, 2018

Label the angles as follows:

The angles satisfy the equations { a + b = q c + d = p a + b + c + d = p + q = 18 0 \begin{cases} a + b = q \\ c + d = p \\ a + b + c + d = p + q = 180^\circ \end{cases}

Now consider the different cases, based on which angles are equal in the three triangles. In each triangle there are potentially three angles that could be the vertex angle, making for 27 cases in principle; but several of them can be ruled out, because

  • a a or d d cannot be the vertex angle in both the large and a small triangle;

    • if b + c b+c is the vertex angle in the large triangle, neither b b nor c c can be the vertex angle in the smaller triangles;

    • if d d is the vertex angle in the large triangle, p p cannot be the vertex angle in a small triangle; the same holds for a a and q q ;

    • the symmetry between ( a , b , p ) (a,b,p) and ( c , d , q ) (c,d,q) allows us to rule out some more cases.

That leaves the following cases

case large triangle small triangle 1 small triangle 2 ( 1 ) a = d a = b c = d ( 2 ) a = d a = b c = q ( 3 ) a = d b = p c = q ( 4 ) a = b + c a = p c = d ( 5 ) a = b + c a = p d = q ( 6 ) a = b + c b = p c = d ( 7 ) a = b + c b = p d = q \begin{array}{cccc} \text{case} & \text{large triangle} & \text{small triangle 1} & \text{small triangle 2} \\ \hline (1) & a = d & a = b & c = d \\ (2) & a = d & a = b & c = q \\ (3) & a = d & b = p & c = q \\ (4) & a = b+c & a = p & c = d \\ (5) & a = b+c & a = p & d = q \\ (6) & a = b+c & b = p & c = d \\ (7) & a = b+c & b = p & d = q \\ \hline \end{array}

For each case, we substitute the given values into the three equations listed at the beginning. We obtain:

  • Case (1): a = b = c = d a = b = c = d , 4 a = 18 0 4a = 180^\circ , a = 4 5 a = 45^\circ , vertex angle b + c = 9 0 b + c = \boxed{90^\circ} .

  • Case (2): a = b = d a = b = d , 3 a + c = 18 0 3a + c = 180^\circ , (2a = c), 5 a = 18 0 5a = 180^\circ , a = 3 6 a = 36^\circ , vertex angle b + c = 3 a = 10 8 b + c = 3a = \boxed{108^\circ} .

  • Case (3): a = d a = d , a + b = c a + b = c , c + a = b c + a = b , which gives a = 0 a = 0 , which is impossible.

  • Case (4): b = c = d b = c = d , a = 2 c a = 2c , 5 c = 18 0 5c = 180^\circ , c = 3 6 c = 36^\circ , vertex angle d = c = 3 6 d = c = \boxed{36^\circ} .

  • Case (5): b = d = a + b b = d = a+b , so that a = 0 a = 0 , which is impossible.

  • Case (6): a = 3 c a = 3c , b = p = 2 c b = p = 2c , q = 5 c q = 5c , 7 c = 18 0 7c = 180^\circ , vertex angle d = c = 25 5 7 d = c = \boxed{25\tfrac57^\circ} .

  • Case (7): a = p + c = 2 c + d = 2 c + a + b a = p+c = 2c+d = 2c+a+b , so that 2 c + b = 0 2c + b = 0 , which is impossible.

Thus we see that there are four \boxed{\text{four}} possible vertex angles for the large triangle.

A picture/diagram would be helpful to understand it better.

Santosh Kulkarni - 2 years, 9 months ago

Log in to reply

You're right. Picture has been added.

Arjen Vreugdenhil - 2 years, 9 months ago

0 pending reports

×

Problem Loading...

Note Loading...

Set Loading...