Perimeter-Area Inequality

Algebra Level 2

For all rectangles with perimeter P P and area A A , what is the minimum value of P 2 A ? \frac{P^2}{A}?


The answer is 16.

This section requires Javascript.
You are seeing this because something didn't load right. We suggest you, (a) try refreshing the page, (b) enabling javascript if it is disabled on your browser and, finally, (c) loading the non-javascript version of this page . We're sorry about the hassle.

18 solutions

Daniel Liu
May 16, 2014

Let the side lengths of the rectangle be x x and y y .

We have that A = x y A=xy and P = 2 x + 2 y P=2x+2y .

By AM-GM, x + y 2 x y \dfrac{x+y}{2}\ge \sqrt{xy} , or P 4 A \dfrac{P}{4}\ge \sqrt{A} .

Squaring both sides gives P 2 16 A \dfrac{P^2}{16}\ge A , and rearranging gives P 2 A 16 \dfrac{P^2}{A}\ge \boxed{16}

Another solution:

Again, let A = x y A=xy and P = 2 x + 2 y P=2x+2y . We have that P 2 = 4 x 2 + 8 x y + 4 y 2 P^2=4x^2+8xy+4y^2 . We can subtract 16 x y = 16 A 16xy=16A to get P 2 16 A = 4 x 2 8 x y + 4 y 2 = ( 2 x 2 y ) 2 0 P^2-16A=4x^2-8xy+4y^2=(2x-2y)^2\ge 0 .

This means P 2 16 A 0 P^2-16A\ge 0 , or P 2 16 A P^2\ge 16A or P 2 A 16 \dfrac{P^2}{A}\ge \boxed{16} .

Daniel Liu - 7 years ago

can't we do this through local minima ??

Rishabh Jain - 7 years ago

Log in to reply

yes we can mr. jain as i solved it above.

mohd SAGEER - 7 years ago

we can do.........but lengthy process

Vikas Sharma - 7 years ago

well, I just took the height and width to be 1 unit and so i had the answer

Nishant Prabhu - 7 years ago

superbbbbb..........

Vikas Sharma - 7 years ago

Cool, great problem!

Ali Akbar - 7 years ago

just take The first derivative for the equation (P2/A) with respect to the width(x) or height(y) then obtain the condition for mini. value (x=y ) and apply it in the equation so you have the answer

Mahmoud Said - 7 years ago

Why soooo complicated

Danushan Dayaparan - 7 years ago

Both solutions are creative and flawless. I especially like the (2x-2y)^2 bit

Amit Srivastava - 7 years ago

Nice solutions!

Lisa Liu - 3 months, 2 weeks ago

JUst assume the sides to be 1

Danushan Dayaparan - 7 years ago
Shabarish Ch
May 17, 2014

I used a simple logic for this. I don't know whether this logic is fully correct or not.

The minimum value of P 2 A \frac{P^2}{A} will be achieved when A A is largest and P P is smallest. For all rectangles, square has the largest area for the least perimeter. Let side of square be x x units.

So, P 2 A = ( 4 x ) 2 x 2 = 16 x 2 x 2 = 16 \frac{P^2}{A} = \frac{(4x)^2}{x^2} = \frac{16x^2}{x^2} = 16

Your are perfect ......p is constant but area varying as on the selection of length and width so for max length=width

satish patel - 7 years ago

nice................

Vikas Sharma - 7 years ago

I also thought it this way :)

Ahnaf Sakib - 7 years ago

same here !!

Birendra Korni - 7 years ago

Not correct

Shrey Patel - 7 years ago

Log in to reply

Why? Please?

Andrea Palma - 1 year, 5 months ago
Jubayer Nirjhor
May 16, 2014

Let the side lengths be x x and y y . So we have: P 2 A = 4 ( x 2 + 2 x y + y 2 ) x y = 4 ( x y + y x + 2 ) \dfrac{P^2}{A}=\dfrac{4(x^2+2xy+y^2)}{xy}=4\left(\dfrac x y + \dfrac y x + 2\right) Since ( x , y ) R + × R + (x,y)\in\mathbb{R_+}\times\mathbb{R_+} , by AM-GM inequality x y + y x 2 \dfrac x y +\dfrac y x\geq 2 Hence: P 2 A = 4 ( x y + y x + 2 ) 4 ( 2 + 2 ) = 16 \dfrac{P^2}{A}=4\left(\dfrac x y + \dfrac y x + 2\right)\geq 4(2+2)=\fbox{16}

Reinforcing the idea of your answer... let´s take a look...

( x y ) 2 0 x 2 + y 2 2 x y 0 x 2 + y 2 2 x y x y + y x 2 \ (x-y)^2 \geqslant 0 \Leftrightarrow x^2+y^2-2xy \geqslant 0 \Leftrightarrow x^2+y^2 \geqslant 2xy \Leftrightarrow \frac{x}{y} +\frac{y}{x} \geqslant 2

x , y R + \large \forall x,y \in \mathbb{R_+}

The rest it´s fine!!!

Cleres Cupertino - 5 years, 11 months ago
Unnikrishnan V
May 17, 2014

The area of a variable rectangle (with fixed perimeter) is minimum when it's a square. If the perimeter is P, then each side of the square is P/4. So its area is: A = P 2 16 A = \frac{{P}^{2}}{16} Therefore, P 2 A = 16 \frac{{P}^{2}}{A} = 16

Nikkhil Kalia
May 17, 2014

A very simple solution. We all know that a square is also a rectangle and using its formula will improve accuracy and increase efficiency. Taking one side of the square as a simply 1 unit, P^2/A= 4side/side.side = (4side)^2/1.1 16Side/1side

=16.

Tisya Rawat
Jan 7, 2021

My solution is pretty short and easy to understand. (it looks a little lengthier because I have explained each and every step)

Emmanuel Torres
Feb 9, 2017

This is for all rectangles, so make a square with a side of 1. Perimeter squared = 16. Area = 1.

Pratik Singhal
Jan 23, 2015

By AM-GM inequality x/y + y/x>2 hence, P^2/A>=16

Ceesay Muhammed
Nov 13, 2014

Let the sides be x and y. Then A=xy, and P=2(x+y). P^2=4(x+y)(x+y)>= 4(2(sqroot(xy))(2(sqroot(xy)) = 16xy (by AM GM). If we divide both sides of the inequality by A, we get P^2/A>=16xy/xy=16.

Supathat Sukaiem
Jun 9, 2014

I have no any idea about mathematic equations to solve.

I just have a conceptual idea about rectangle. One of the most basic rectangle is 'square'. It has the minimum area (i'm not sure but it is one that i have in my mind) when compared with others of the same shortest length.

So, it is a reason why 16 is an answer.

Square is also a rectangle. Use the smallest number which is 1 as the mesurement of one side. Then solve for P2/A. P=1x4 = 4. 4^2 = 16. A=1x1. 16/1 = 16.

Lucas Valadao
Jun 6, 2014

O menor retângulo possível é um quadrado, portanto, o perímetro é 4 lado (l) e a área é lado lado(l²). (4l)²/l²=16

Sankar Rams
Jun 6, 2014

minimum value is possible when length=breadth it becomes a square so perimeter is 4s where is side of the square and P^2 =16s^2 and area is s^2 so on dividing p^2 by A we get 16

Mohd Sageer
Jun 3, 2014

as we know, p = 2(x+y)..................................eq2 a = x*y.......................................eq 1 putting x = a/y, p = 2(a/y+y) p^ = 4(a/y+y)^ diff w.r .t.x we get 2pdp/dy = 8(a/y+y)(-a/y^+1)....................................................eq 3 for max or minima putting dp/dy = 0 a/y+y = 0 (not possible) -a/y^+1 = 0 y^ = a putting y in eq 1 x^ = a putting x , y in eq 2 we get p^/a = 16 diff eq 3 w.r.tx , 2pd^p/dp^+2(dp/dy)^ = +ve so the func. will be minima. ]

Vedant Dave
May 30, 2014

The rectangle has minimum area when it is a square.
Area of the sq=a^2.
Perimeter=4a.
On dividing, we get 16.


Saumya Shandilya
May 29, 2014

P*P/A=4(X+Y)^2/XY Use condition for maxima and minima for minimum value first order derivative wrt x=0 second order derivative wrt x>0

Hemel Sarkar
May 22, 2014

Let the side lengths of the rectangle be a and b. We have that A=ab and P=2(a+b). from this problem we can get {2(a+b)}^2/ab. now the lowest value of a is 1 and b is 1.1 because it is a rectangle.so {2(a+b)}^2/ab=16.something.From this we can say that the lowest value of P^2/A=16.

Jia Quan Ng
May 18, 2014

Smallest perimeter=1+1+1+1=4 4 4=16 Area of the same square=1 1=1 So16/1=16

the smallest perimeter is not necessarily 4

wrong approch....

Vikas Sharma - 7 years ago

0 pending reports

×

Problem Loading...

Note Loading...

Set Loading...