Physicist in the kitchen - run for your lives!

You prefer soft-boiled to hard-boiled eggs, but you hate waiting next to your eggs to check if they're cooked. Therefore, you want to determine how often do you need to check the eggs so that they're not overcooked.

What time does it take in minutes for a soft-boiled egg to become a hard-boiled one?

Note: A soft boiled egg is when only the egg white is solid, whereas a hard boiled egg is when both the egg white and yolk are solid.

Details and assumptions

  • The egg can be modeled as a sphere of radius 2 cm 2~\mbox{cm} and density 1000 kg/m 3 1000~\mbox{kg/m}^3 .
  • Egg white solidifies at 5 0 C 50^\circ\mbox{C} while yolk solidifies at 6 5 C 65^\circ\mbox{C}
  • The heat capacity of an egg is c = 4200 J kg K c = 4200 \frac{\mbox{J}}{\mbox{kg}\cdot\mbox{K}}
  • The power transferred from the heater to the egg is P = 20 W P = 20~\mbox{W}


The answer is 1.759.

This section requires Javascript.
You are seeing this because something didn't load right. We suggest you, (a) try refreshing the page, (b) enabling javascript if it is disabled on your browser and, finally, (c) loading the non-javascript version of this page . We're sorry about the hassle.

10 solutions

Discussions for this problem are now closed

Jubayer Nirjhor
Jul 26, 2013

First, we work out the volume of the egg in m 3 m^3 using,

V = 4 3 π r 3 = 4 3 π ( 2 c m ) 3 = 4 3 π × ( 0.02 m ) 3 V=\frac{4}{3} \pi r^3 = \frac{4}{3} \pi (2 cm)^3 = \frac{4}{3} \pi \times (0.02 m)^3

= 4 3 π × 0.000008 m = 0.000032 π 3 m = \frac{4}{3} \pi \times 0.000008m = \frac {0.000032 \pi}{3}m

= 3.2 × 1 0 5 × π 3 m = \frac {3.2 \times 10^{-5} \times \pi}{3}m

Now, we work out the mass in k g kg using,

m = ρ V = 1000 k g / m 3 × 3.2 × 1 0 5 × π 3 m m= \rho V=1000kg/m^3 \times \frac {3.2 \times 10^{-5} \times \pi}{3}m

= 1 0 3 × 3.2 × 1 0 5 × π 3 k g = \frac {10^3 \times 3.2 \times 10^{-5} \times \pi}{3}kg

= 3.2 × 1 0 2 × π 3 k g = \frac {3.2 \times 10^{-2} \times \pi}{3}kg

Next, let's work out the amount of heat energy needed to raise the temperature from 50⁰C to 65⁰C using,

E = m c Δ T = 3.2 × 1 0 2 × π 3 k g × 4200 J k g K × ( 65 C 50 C ) E=mc \Delta T = \frac {3.2 \times 10^{-2} \times \pi}{3}kg \times 4200 \frac {J}{kg⋅K} \times (65⁰C-50⁰C)

= 3.2 × 1 0 2 × π 3 k g × 4200 J k g K × 15 K = \frac {3.2 \times 10^{-2} \times \pi}{3}kg \times 4200 \frac {J}{kg⋅K} \times 15⁰K

= 42 × 1 0 2 × 3.2 × 1 0 2 × π × 15 3 J = \frac {42 \times 10^2 \times 3.2 \times 10^{-2} \times \pi \times 15}{3}J

= 672 π J = 672 \pi J

Finally, we work out the time in seconds to supply this amount of energy, using,

P = E t t = E P = 672 π J 20 W P= \frac {E}{t} \Longrightarrow t= \frac {E}{P} = \frac {672 \pi J}{20 W}

= 672 π J 20 J s 1 = 672 π 20 s = 33.6 π s = 33.6 π 60 m i n = \frac {672 \pi J}{20 J s^{-1}} = \frac {672 \pi}{20} s = 33.6 \pi s = \frac {33.6 \pi}{60} min

= 0.56 × π = 0.56 \times \pi min = 1.759 m i n =1.759 min (approx.)

Hence, the required answer is 1.759 \fbox {1.759} .

Ahaan Rungta
Jul 24, 2013

We note that the time is just t = E P t = \dfrac {E}{P} where P P is the given power and E E is the heat energy, given by m c Δ T mc \cdot \Delta T , where c c is the given specific heat and Δ T = 15 C \Delta T = 15 \, \text{C}^\circ . Thus: t = m c Δ T P . t = \dfrac {mc \cdot \Delta T}{P}. But note that we need to find m m using the volume density and the volume as follows: m = ρ V = 4 3 π r 3 ρ , m = \rho V = \dfrac {4}{3} \pi r^3 \rho, since the egg is a sphere. Thus: t = 4 3 π r 3 ρ c Δ T P . t = \dfrac {4}{3} \cdot \dfrac {\pi r^3 \rho c \cdot \Delta T}{P}. We have the necessary number to substitute into this. So we proceed.

r = 0.02 m \implies r = 0.02 \, \text{m}

ρ = 1000 kg / m 3 \implies \rho = 1000 \, \text{kg}/\text{m}^3

Δ T = 15 C \implies \Delta T = 15 \, \text{C}^\circ

P = 20 W \implies P = \text {20 W}

Plugging in, we get t = 105.56 s t = 105.56 \, \text{s} . Converting to minutes, we get 1.76 minutes \boxed {1.76 \, \text{minutes}} .

Eric Edwards
Jul 26, 2013

We need to calculate the mass of the egg, M = ρ 4 3 π r 3 M=\rho\frac{4}{3}\pi r^3 and then the amount of energy required to raise the temperature by 15 degrees is E = 15 M c E = 15Mc . Since we want the time, we divide by the power and convert from seconds to minutes: t = 15 M c ( 20 ) ( 60 ) = 15 ρ 4 3 π r 3 c ( 20 ) ( 60 ) = 15 ( 1000 ) ( 4 3 π ( . 02 ) 3 ( 4200 ) 1200 = 1.759 t = \frac{15Mc}{(20)(60)} = \frac{15\rho\frac{4}{3}\pi r^3c}{(20)(60)} = \frac{15(1000)( \frac{4}{3}\pi (.02)^3 (4200)}{1200} = 1.759 .

Andrias Meisyal
Jul 24, 2013

We know that, the power, P P is how many energy store in a seconds, E t \frac{E}{t} . So, to get the times in minutes , t t , You have to find the energy, energy in here mean the calor/heat enery which E = m c Δ T E = mc\Delta T , m m mass you can get using ρ = m V \rho = \frac{m}{V} . Volume in here can be modeled as sphere of radius 2 c m 2 cm . Then,

V = 4 3 π r 3 V = \frac{4}{3}\pi r^{3} , you will get the mass. Next, find the energy, E E , and Δ T \Delta T is the temperature change in C ^{\circ} C . Finally, you will the get time in seconds, using the relation of (\E) and P P . Converse it in to minutes .

Leonardo Jackson
Jul 23, 2013

There are lots of assumptions made in this question. In reality, there is a temperature gradient between the outer part of the egg and the (yolk) in the middle, which means that the inner part of the egg is always cooler than the outer part.

This gradient diminishes with time, which makes it a time dependent problem, solvable using a differential equation.

However, (intended) simplifications make the problem solvable.

By considering 1. a constant input of heat to the egg, and 2. the egg temperature is uniform, then we only have a single temperature to contend with, which varies linearly with time.

mass of egg: m m = ρ ( 4 / 3 ) π r 3 \rho(4/3)\pi r^{3} =1 g / c m 3 g/cm^{3} * ( 4 / 3 ) π ( 2 3 ) (4/3)\pi (2^{3}) = 32 π / 3 g 32\pi/3 g = 32 π / 3000 k g 32\pi/3000 kg

Heat capacity C C = m ( k g ) 4200 J k g / ° K m (kg) *4200 J-kg/°K (given) = 224 π / 5 J / ° K 224 \pi/ 5 J/°K

Power supplied, P P = 20 W 20W

Temp difference, Δ T \Delta T = ( 65 50 ) (65-50) = 15 ° K 15 °K

Time required = Δ T C / P ° K J / ° K s / J \Delta T * C/P °K * J/°K * s/J = 15 ( 224 π / 5 ) / 20 s 15*(224\pi/5)/20 s = 105.6 s 105.6 s about 1 minute 45 seconds or 1.75 m i n u t e s 1.75 minutes

Tim Vermeulen
Jul 22, 2013

{ Δ T = 65 50 = 15 K m e g g = V e g g ρ e g g = 4 3 π ( 0.02 ) 3 1000 0.0335 kg c = 4200 J k g K \begin{cases} \begin{aligned} \Delta T &= 65 - 50 = 15\text{K}\\ m_{egg} &= V_{egg} \cdot \rho_{egg} = \frac{4}{3} \pi (0.02)^3 \cdot 1000 \approx 0.0335\text{kg}\\ c &= 4200 \frac{J}{kg \cdot K} \end{aligned} \end{cases}

Filling it in:

Q = c m Δ T = 4200 0.0335 15 = 2110.5 J Q = c \cdot m \cdot \Delta T = 4200 \cdot 0.0335 \cdot 15 = 2110.5\text{J}

Finally, 2110.5 J 20 W 105.5 s 1.76 minutes . \frac{2110.5 \text{J}}{20 \text{W}} \approx 105.5\text{s} \approx \boxed{1.76}\text{ minutes}.

John Chaddock
Jul 22, 2013

The enthalpy change of the egg is described by:

E = m c Δ θ E=mc\Delta\theta

Differentiating with respect to t, and remembering that d E d t = P \frac{dE}{dt}=P :

P = d ( m c θ ) d t P=\frac{d(mc\theta)}{dt}

Because mass and secific heat capacity remain constant as t changes, they can be brought outside of the differential, meaning that:

P = m c d θ d t P=mc\frac{d\theta}{dt}

Rearranging to find d θ d\theta :

P m c d t = d θ \frac{P}{mc}dt=d\theta

Integrating both sides:

P m c d t = d θ \int\frac{P}{mc}dt=\int{d\theta}

The lower bound for the left side is when t = 0 t=0 , and the upper bound is when t = t 1 t=t_1 , where t 1 t_1 is the value to be determined. The lower bound for the right side is when θ = 50 \theta=50 , and the upper bound is when θ = 65 \theta=65 . This means that the resulting integral is:

0 t 1 P m c d t = 50 65 d θ \int_{0}^{t_1}\frac{P}{mc}dt=\int_{50}^{65}{d\theta}

Integrating both sides:

[ P m c t ] 0 t 1 = [ θ ] 50 65 [\frac{P}{mc}t]_{0}^{t_1}=[\theta]_{50}^{65} (1)

We'll leave this equation to one side for now. Mass can be described by density multiplied by volume, so:

m = ρ V m={\rho}V

ρ \rho is given, however:

V = 4 3 π r 3 V=\frac{4}{3}{\pi}r^3

This means that:

m = 4 3 π ρ r 3 m=\frac{4}{3}{\pi}{\rho}r^3

Plugging that into equation (1) means that equation (1) is:

[ P 4 3 π c ρ r 3 t ] 0 t 1 = [ θ ] 50 65 [\frac{P}{\frac{4}{3}{\pi}c{\rho}r^3}t]_{0}^{t_1}=[\theta]_{50}^{65}

P 4 3 π c ρ r 3 \frac{P}{\frac{4}{3}{\pi}c{\rho}r^3} is constant as t varies, so by plugging in P = 20 P=20 , c = 4200 c=4200 , ρ = 1000 {\rho}=1000 and r = 0.02 r=0.02 :

P 4 3 π c ρ r 3 = 25 56 π \frac{P}{\frac{4}{3}{\pi}c{\rho}r^3}=\frac{25}{56\pi}

Meaning that equation (1) is:

[ 25 56 π t ] 0 t 1 = [ θ ] 50 65 [\frac{25}{56\pi}t]_{0}^{t_1}=[\theta]_{50}^{65}

Evaluating bounds:

25 56 π t 1 = 65 50 = 15 \frac{25}{56\pi}t_1=65-50=15

This means that:

t 1 = 15 × 56 π 25 t_1=\frac{15\times56\pi}{25} in seconds, or:

t 1 = 15 × 56 π 25 × 60 t_1=\frac{15\times56\pi}{25\times60} in minutes. Therefore:

t 1 = 14 25 π t_1=\frac{14}{25}\pi minutes, or, to 3 significant figures: t 1 = 1.76 t_1=1.76 minutes.

Oh, by the way, θ \theta is temperature

John Chaddock - 7 years, 10 months ago
Avraam Aneleitos
Jul 22, 2013

Let Q Q be the heat needed for the egg to turn from soft to hard-boiled, m m the egg's mass, d d the egg's density, V V the egg's volume, r r the egg's radius, Δ T ΔT the temperature difference between the two states of the egg and Δ t Δt the desired time interval.We know that Q = m c Δ T Q=mcΔT with Q = P Δ t Q=PΔt and m = d V = d 4 3 π r 3 m=dV=d\frac{4}{3}πr^{3} .Substituting these into the first equation and solving for Δ t Δt we get that Δ t = 4 π d c Δ T r 3 3 P = 105.56 s e c = 1.759 m i n Δt=\frac{4πdcΔTr^{3}}{3P}=105.56 sec=1.759 min

Armin Namavari
Jul 22, 2013

This problem can be solved by simple dimensional analysis: 1 s 20 J × 1 m i n 60 s × 4200 J k g × K × 15 K × 1000 k g m 3 × 4 3 π ( 0.02 m ) 3 = 1.759 m i n \dfrac{1 s}{20 J} \times \dfrac{1 min}{60 s} \times \dfrac{4200 J}{kg \times K} \times 15K \times \dfrac{1000 kg}{m^3} \times \dfrac{4}{3}\pi (0.02m)^3 = 1.759 min Notes: 1 Watt = 1 J/s, the increments between the celsius and kelvin scales are equal 65 ºC - 50 ºC = 15 K.

Mursalin Habib
Jul 21, 2013

We have the radius of the egg, r = 0.02 r=0.02 meters. Since the egg can be modeled as a sphere, we can find the volume of the egg using the formula V = 4 3 π × r 3 V=\frac{4}{3}\pi\times r^3 .

We also have the density of the egg, ρ = 1000 \rho=1000 k g / m 3 kg/m^3 .

Multiplying the volume & the density of the egg gives us the mass, m = ρ V m=\rho V .

As a soft boiled egg becomes hard-boiled, the temperature changes from 5 0 C 50^\circ C to 6 5 C 65^\circ C . In other words, the change of temperature that takes place is equal to Δ θ = ( 65 50 ) \Delta\theta=(65-50) or 15 15 kelvins.

So the amount of heat needed for a soft-boiled egg to become hard boiled is equal to

m c Δ θ = Q mc\Delta\theta=Q .

Dividing Q Q by P P gives us the time t t .

In other words, t = Q P t=\frac{Q}{P} .

Wait! notice that t t is now in seconds and we want t t to be in minutes . So we need to divide our answer by 60 60 to get our desired result.

t m i n u t e s = Q P × 60 = ρ V c Δ θ P × 60 t_{minutes}=\frac{Q}{P\times60}=\frac{\rho V c \Delta\theta}{P\times 60} .

Now simply plug in all the values (use a calculator for this) and get t = 1.759 t=1.759 minutes.

PS: A quick aside. I was wondering: is c c really the heat capacity of the egg? Looking at its unit tells me that it's the specific heat capacity of the composition of the egg and we were always taught at school to make this distinction.

0 pending reports

×

Problem Loading...

Note Loading...

Set Loading...