Points on a square

Geometry Level 5

A B C D ABCD is a square. Point E E , located on the opposite side of line C D CD as compared to points A A and B B , satisfies D E A = A E C = 1 2 E A D \angle DEA = \angle AEC = \frac{1}{2} \angle EAD . What is the measure of E C D \angle ECD ?

Details and assumptions

Points X X and Y Y are on opposite sides of line M N MN if the line segment X Y XY intersects the line M N MN .


The answer is 105.

This section requires Javascript.
You are seeing this because something didn't load right. We suggest you, (a) try refreshing the page, (b) enabling javascript if it is disabled on your browser and, finally, (c) loading the non-javascript version of this page . We're sorry about the hassle.

6 solutions

James Lin
Jul 28, 2013

Note that we must clearly have A E AE intersect line segment C D CD , because otherwise D E A = A E C \angle DEA=\angle AEC is a clear contradiction. Let A E AE and C D CD intersect at F F . Denote the length of the side of the square as s s .

Then, let D E A = A E C = x \angle DEA=\angle AEC=x , so E A D = 2 x \angle EAD=2x , E D A = 180 3 x \angle EDA=180-3x and hence E D C = 90 3 x \angle EDC=90-3x . Now, E F D = 90 + 2 x \angle EFD=90+2x , E F C = 90 2 x \angle EFC=90-2x , and thus E C D = 90 + x \angle ECD=90+x . Also, since E D C > 0 \angle EDC>0 , we get that 0 < x < 30 0<x<30 .

By the law of sines on A E D \triangle AED , E D sin ( 2 x ) = s sin x \frac{ED}{\sin (2x)}=\frac{s}{\sin x} , and by the law of sines on C E D \triangle CED , E D sin ( 90 + x ) = s sin ( 2 x ) \frac{ED}{\sin (90+x)}=\frac{s}{\sin (2x)} . Hence, by rearranging these two equations, we get sin 2 ( 2 x ) = sin x sin ( 90 + x ) \sin ^2 (2x)=\sin x \sin (90+x) . Since 0 < x < 30 0<x<30 , we have sin ( 90 + x ) = cos x \sin (90+x)=\cos x , so sin 2 ( 2 x ) = sin x cos x \sin ^2 (2x)=\sin x \cos x , so by the sine double-angle formula, sin ( 2 x ) = 1 2 \sin (2x)=\frac 12 . The function f ( x ) = sin ( 2 x ) f(x)=\sin (2x) is strictly increasing as x x increases from 0 to 30, so hence there is at most one solution to sin ( 2 x ) = 1 2 \sin (2x)=\frac 12 in the range from 0 to 30. Clearly x = 15 x=15 is such a solution, so therefore E C D = 90 + 15 = 105 \angle ECD=90+15=\boxed{105} .

Moderator note:

Good explanation for why A E AE must intersect line segment D C DC . Note that the diagram that you draw will greatly affect the equations that you write (unless you use directed line segments and directed angles).

Mark Hennings
Jul 29, 2013

Let D E A = A E C = θ \angle DEA = \angle AEC = \theta and D A E = 2 θ \angle DAE = 2\theta . Then D C E = θ + 9 0 \angle DCE = \theta+90^\circ . Let the side of the square be a a . Applying the Sine Rule to Δ A D E \Delta ADE D E sin 2 θ = D A sin θ \frac{DE}{\sin2\theta} = \frac{DA}{\sin\theta} and hence D E = 2 a cos θ DE = 2a\cos\theta . Applying the Sine Rule to Δ C D E \Delta CDE , D E sin ( θ + 9 0 ) = D C sin 2 θ \frac{DE}{\sin(\theta+90^\circ)} = \frac{DC}{\sin2\theta} and hence D E = a 2 sin θ DE = \frac{a}{2\sin\theta} . Thus 2 sin 2 θ = 4 sin θ cos θ = 1 2\sin2\theta = 4\sin\theta\cos\theta = 1 , so sin 2 θ = 1 / 2 \sin2\theta = 1/2 , so θ = 1 5 \theta=15^\circ . Hence D C E = 10 5 \angle DCE = 105^\circ .

Moderator note:

I'd admit that I don't have a pure synthetic proof to this problem.

can any body give a pure geometry proof please!!

Sagnik Saha - 7 years, 10 months ago

can any body give a pure geometry proof please!!

Sagnik Saha - 7 years, 10 months ago

Replying to the Challenge Master's note, I believe there is a much simpler solution to this problem that does not involve trigonometry. It's not purely synthetic, but uses much less computation. By inscribing square A B C D ABCD in a circle, we can use the given angle relations to assign measures to the arcs of the circle.

Letting D E A = θ \angle DEA = \theta ^ \circ and the intersection of the circle and the segment A E AE be point F F , we have that minor arc D F DF has a measure of 4 θ 4 \theta . This means that minor arc A D AD has a measure of 6 θ 6 \theta because D E A = θ \angle DEA = \theta ^ \circ .

We know that arc A B C ABC has a measure of 180 ^ \(circ , and that the minor arc C D CD has a measure of 90 ^ \(circ . Together, the measures of arc A B C ABC , minor arc C D CD , and minor arc A D AD sum to 36 0 360 ^ \circ , because they encompass the whole circle. So, 18 0 + 9 0 + 6 θ = 36 0 180 ^ \circ + 90 ^ \circ + 6 \theta ^ \circ = 360 ^ \circ . Thus, θ = 1 5 \theta = 15 ^ \circ .

Some simple angle chasing reveals that E C D = 9 0 + θ \angle ECD = 90 ^ \circ + \theta ^ \circ . Replacing θ \theta , we have that E C D = 9 0 + 1 5 = 10 5 \angle ECD = 90 ^ \circ + 15 ^ \circ = 105 ^ \circ .

Vickie Wang - 7 years, 10 months ago

Reflect D D over E A EA also provides a synthetic proof.

Xuming Liang - 7 years, 3 months ago

Nice solution..That's exactly what I did too!

Ayush Garg - 6 years, 4 months ago
David Vaccaro
Jul 31, 2013

Let D E A = x DEA=x , and assume A D = 1 AD=1 . By the sine rule on EDA we get 1 sin x = E D sin 2 x \frac{1}{\sin{x}}=\frac{ED}{\sin{2x}} Chasing angles it is easy to find E C D = 90 + x ECD=90+x and then the sine rule on ECD gives 1 sin 2 x = E D sin ( 90 + x ) \frac{1}{\sin{2x}}=\frac{ED}{\sin{(90+x)}} . Equating the two expressions for ED, and using sin ( 90 + x ) = cos x \sin{(90+x)}=\cos{x} gives sin 2 x = 1 2 \sin{2x}=\frac{1}{2} and hence 2 x = 30 2x=30 and E C D = 105 ECD=105

Debjit Mandal
Aug 1, 2013

Let, D E A = A E C = 1 2 E A D = α \angle DEA=\angle AEC=\frac{1}{2} \angle EAD=\alpha and A B = B C = C D = D A = a AB=BC=CD=DA=a and D E = x DE=x

Of Δ A D E \Delta ADE ,
E A D + D E A + A D E = 18 0 \angle EAD+\angle DEA+\angle ADE=180^\circ
A D E = 18 0 2 α α \angle ADE=180^\circ-2\alpha-\alpha [ We know that, D E A = 1 2 E A D = α \angle DEA=\frac{1}{2} \angle EAD=\alpha ]
A D E = 18 0 3 α \angle ADE=180^\circ-3\alpha
C D E = 9 0 3 α \angle CDE=90^\circ-3\alpha



Of Δ D C E \Delta DCE ,
D C E + C E D + C D E = 18 0 \angle DCE+\angle CED+\angle CDE=180^\circ
D C E = 18 0 2 α 9 0 + 3 α \angle DCE=180^\circ-2\alpha-90^\circ+3\alpha [ We know that, C E D = A E C + D E A = α + α = 2 α \angle CED=\angle AEC+\angle DEA=\alpha+\alpha=2\alpha and C D E = 9 0 3 α \angle CDE=90^\circ-3\alpha ]
D C E = 9 0 + α \angle DCE=90^\circ+\alpha

Of Δ A D E \Delta ADE ,
A D s i n A E D = D E s i n D A E \frac{AD}{sin \angle AED}=\frac{DE}{sin \angle DAE}
a s i n α = x s i n 2 α \frac{a}{sin \alpha}=\frac{x}{sin 2\alpha}
a x = s i n α s i n 2 α \frac{a}{x}=\frac{sin \alpha}{sin 2\alpha} .............( 1 1 )

Of Δ D C E \Delta DCE ,
C D s i n C E D = D E s i n D C E \frac{CD}{sin \angle CED}=\frac{DE}{sin \angle DCE}
a s i n 2 α = x s i n ( 9 0 + α ) \frac{a}{sin 2\alpha}=\frac{x}{sin (90^\circ+\alpha)}
a x = s i n 2 α s i n ( 9 0 + α ) \frac{a}{x}=\frac{sin 2\alpha}{sin (90^\circ+\alpha)} ...............( 2 2 )

By equating ( 1 1 ) and ( 2 2 ), we shall get,
s i n α s i n 2 α = s i n 2 α s i n ( 9 0 + α ) \frac{sin \alpha}{sin 2\alpha}=\frac{sin 2\alpha}{sin (90^\circ+\alpha)}
s i n α 2. s i n α . c o s α = s i n 2 α c o s α \frac{sin \alpha}{2.sin \alpha.cos \alpha}=\frac{sin 2\alpha}{cos \alpha}
s i n 2 α = 1 2 sin 2\alpha=\frac{1}{2}
2 α = 3 0 2\alpha=30^\circ [ We know that, 0 0^\circ \leq α \alpha \leq 9 0 90^\circ ]
α = 1 5 \alpha=15^\circ

So,
D C E = 9 0 + α \angle DCE=90^\circ+\alpha
D C E = 9 0 + 1 5 \angle DCE=90^\circ+15^\circ
D C E = 10 5 \angle DCE=105^\circ [ ANSWER ]

Arthur Wang
Jul 29, 2013

Let D E A = x \angle DEA = x . Through angle chasing we see that E C D = 90 + x \angle ECD = 90 +x . Now, we use law of sines on Triangles DEC and DAE. From the first triangle we have that D C s i n 2 x = D E s i n ( 90 + x ) \frac{DC}{sin2x} = \frac{DE}{sin(90+x)} . The second triangle gives us D A s i n x = D E s i n 2 x \frac{DA}{sinx} = \frac{DE}{sin2x} . We know that DA = Dc since ABCD is a square so equating the two relations to each other gives us that s i n x s i n 2 x = s i n 2 x s i n ( 90 + x ) \frac{sinx}{sin2x} = \frac{sin2x}{sin(90+x)} . This becomes 1 s i n 2 x = 2 c o s x s i n ( 90 + x ) \frac{1}{sin2x} = \frac{2cosx}{sin(90+x)} , which further simplifies to sin2x = 1 2 \frac{1}{2} . This means that sinx = 15. Thus E C D = 105 \angle ECD = 105 .

Ayush Garg
Feb 6, 2015

Just apply Sine rule twice and we are done..isn't this problem over-rated?

Can you add your solution? Thanks!

There is an extremely short (3 lines?) solution using sine rule.

Calvin Lin Staff - 6 years, 4 months ago

Log in to reply

Yep... My solution is similar to that of Mark Hennings given above

Ayush Garg - 6 years, 4 months ago

0 pending reports

×

Problem Loading...

Note Loading...

Set Loading...