Do Some Physics Before Shooting!

Jim, the scientist, is planning to do a dangerous stunt in which he puts his life at stake. He asks his assistant to shoot him while he stands behind a stack of identical books.

Before he does the stunt, he test fires a bullet on a single book and confirms that the bullet fired at speed 457.2 m / s \SI[per-mode=symbol]{457.2}{\meter\per\second} penetrates the 3.5 cm \SI[per-mode=symbol]{3.5}{\centi\meter} thick book and comes out from the other side at speed 400 m / s \SI[per-mode=symbol]{400}{\meter\per\second} .

What is the minimum number of books Jim needs to stack up so that he can pull off this stunt safely?


Details and Assumptions:

  • Air resistance is neglected.
  • The deceleration of the bullet within the books is constant.


The answer is 5.

This section requires Javascript.
You are seeing this because something didn't load right. We suggest you, (a) try refreshing the page, (b) enabling javascript if it is disabled on your browser and, finally, (c) loading the non-javascript version of this page . We're sorry about the hassle.

2 solutions

Let's do this short. If the thickness of one book is s s , then thickness of n n books is n s ns .

Now we would implement proportionality concept. We know s = v 2 u 2 2 a s=\frac{v^2-u^2}{2a} As the deceleration, a is constant, we can write s v 2 u 2 s\propto v^2-u^2 s 2 s 1 = v 2 2 u 2 2 v 1 2 u 1 2 \rightarrow \frac{s_2}{s_1}=\frac{{v_2}^2-{u_2}^2}{{v_1}^2-{u_1}^2} For the 1st (couple's) case, s 1 = s , u 1 = 457.2 m / s , v 1 = 400 m / s s_1=s, u_1=457.2m/s, v_1=400m/s And for the 2nd (and safe) case, s 2 = n s , u 2 = 457.2 m / s , v 2 = 0 m / s (as the bullet must stop) s_2=ns, u_2=457.2m/s, v_2=0m/s \text{(as the bullet must stop)}

Finally, n s s = 0 457. 2 2 40 0 2 457. 2 2 \frac{ns}{s}=\frac{0-457.2^2}{400^2-457.2^2} n = 4.26 = 5 ( a n s ) \rightarrow n=\lceil 4.26 \rceil = 5 (ans) As we can't take 4.26 books, we need at least five books to stop the bullet.

By the way, I would appreciate if someone writes a solution in the conventional way.

Muhammad Arifur Rahman - 3 years, 11 months ago
Uros Stojkovic
Jul 4, 2017

Using formula υ 2 = υ 0 2 2 a s \upsilon^{2}=\upsilon_{0}^{2}-2as where:

a a is (negative) acceleration of the bullet caused by thickness of book,

s s is distance traveled (in this case thickness of one book),

υ 0 \upsilon_{0} is starting speed of the bullet and

υ s \upsilon_{s} is speed of the bullet after distance traveled s s ,

we get a = υ 0 2 υ s 2 2 s a=\dfrac{\upsilon_{0}^{2}-\upsilon_{s}^{2}}{2s} .

If n s ns is thickness of n n books, then n s = υ 0 2 υ n s 2 2 a ns=\dfrac{\upsilon_{0}^{2}-\upsilon_{ns}^{2}}{2a} .

Substituting υ n s \upsilon_{ns} with 0 0 and a a with υ 0 2 υ s 2 2 s \dfrac{\upsilon_{0}^{2}-\upsilon_{s}^{2}}{2s} :

n s = υ 0 2 2 υ 0 2 υ s 2 2 s ns=\dfrac{\upsilon_{0}^{2}}{2\frac{\upsilon_{0}^{2}-\upsilon_{s}^{2}}{2s}}

n = υ 0 2 υ 0 2 υ s 2 = 4.27914... \Rightarrow n=\dfrac{\upsilon_{0}^{2}}{\upsilon_{0}^{2}-\upsilon_{s}^{2}}=4.27914...

In order to be sure that bullet will stop before reaching him, he should stack up at least 5 \boxed{5} books.

Nice. This shows that we actually don't need the thickness at all. 😁

Muhammad Arifur Rahman - 3 years, 11 months ago

Log in to reply

Exactly! It was intuitive to me when I read the question, but I had to prove myself correct using bit of math.

Uros Stojkovic - 3 years, 11 months ago

0 pending reports

×

Problem Loading...

Note Loading...

Set Loading...