Right in Order

How many possible integer values of x are there, such that x is a square number, (x + 1) is a cube number, and (x + 2) is a quartic number?


The answer is 0.

This section requires Javascript.
You are seeing this because something didn't load right. We suggest you, (a) try refreshing the page, (b) enabling javascript if it is disabled on your browser and, finally, (c) loading the non-javascript version of this page . We're sorry about the hassle.

8 solutions

Henry U
Jan 19, 2019

By Catalan's conjecture (which is actually a theorem), the only perfect powers that have a difference of 1 are 8 = 2 3 8=2^3 and 9 = 3 2 9=3^2 , but they are in the wrong order and neither of 7 and 10 are perferct powers.


More elementary:

Any square number leaves a remainder of 0 or 1 when divided by 4 (see here ).

A fourth power is also a square, the square of a square number, so it also leaves a remainder of 0 or 1 when divided by 4.

But now, it's impossible to have two numbers x x and x + 2 x+2 such that both of them leave a remainder of 0 or 1 when divided by 4.

Pedro Cardoso
Jan 23, 2019

Every quartic number is a square number, so the only possibilities for x x are numbers such that x + 2 x+2 is also a square, none exists.

Brilliant! Even though I correctly answered this problem, I never saw it this way. Brilliant!

Francis Dave Cabanting - 1 year, 8 months ago

Suppose such an x x exists. Then there exist (positive) integers m m and n n such that x = m 2 x = m^2 and x + 2 = n 4 x + 2 = n^4 , so m 2 = x = n 4 2 m^2 = x = n^4 - 2 , implying 2 = n 4 m 2 = ( n 2 m ) ( n 2 + m ) 2 = n^4 - m^2 = (n^2 - m)(n^2 + m) . These factors must therefore be 1 1 and 2 2 , but their difference is 2 m 2m , an even number, so this is impossible. Therefore no such x x exists.

BTW there is also an option of - 1, - 2, but we can easily rule it out. Very good approach 👍

Andrew Courtney
Jan 29, 2019

Let a 2 = b 3 1 = c 4 2 a^{2} = b^{3} - 1 = c^{4} - 2 . Since a 2 0 , 1 m o d 4 , c 4 a^{2} \equiv 0, 1 \mod 4, c^{4} must be congruent to 2 , 3 m o d 4. 2, 3 \mod 4. But this is clearly impossible as c 4 0 , 1 m o d 4 c^{4}\equiv 0, 1\mod 4 only. Therefore there are no such x x .

Ahmed X Pro
Jul 26, 2020

We only will see a soulution for x is square and x+1 is a cube X^3-1=(X-1)(X^2+X+1) and because it is a square number amd no number is equal 1 So they should share a prime factor and for this happining only with the number 3 And number 3 dont aplly the rules soo it is impossibpe to find another solution

רזיאל קרן
Aug 28, 2019

let's assume such X exists. It can't be even because if you raise an even to an even power you get a multiple of 4

so x have a reminder of 0 after division by 4 , so x+2 must have a reminder of 2 but x+2 is a fourth power so it also multiple of 4 and we have a contradiction.

X can't be odd as well. because any odd number to an even power have a reminder of 1 after division by 4. (the reminder is 1^2=1 or 3^2=9 that olso leave a reminder of 1)

so if x is odd it must leave a reminder of 1 after division by 4 so x+2 must leave a reminder of 3 but x+2 is a fourth power so it must leave a reminder of 1 as well.

again a contradiction.

so x can't being neither even or odd so no such integer exists.

MegaMoh .
May 19, 2019

The difference between any 2 square numbers is an odd number and any quartic number is a square number so x+2 is a square number. x is said to be a square number too but the difference between them is 2 which isn't odd so none

Edwin Gray
Jan 26, 2019

Let x + r^2, x + 2 = t^4 = s^2. Then s^2 - r^2 = 2. s _ r =1, s + r =2, adding, 2s = 3, no solution in integers. Ed Gray

Typos:

instead of x + r^2, it should be x = r^2

instead of s _ r =1, it should be s - r =1

Laszlo Kocsis - 2 years, 4 months ago

Log in to reply

Laszio, thank you

Edwin Gray - 2 years, 3 months ago

0 pending reports

×

Problem Loading...

Note Loading...

Set Loading...