Rita Skeeter goes boom

One of the characters in the Harry Potter stories has the ability to turn herself into a beetle. So, let's pretend that all the other laws of physics hold, in particular conservation of momentum, and ask what would happen during such a transformation.

Consider a 70 kg 70~\mbox{kg} woman walking to the right at a speed of 1 m/s 1~\mbox{m/s} who all of a sudden transforms into a 10 g 10~\mbox{g} beetle. How many times faster than the speed of sound is she going after her transformation?

Details and assumptions

  • The speed of sound is approximately 340 m/s 340~\mbox{m/s} at sea level.


The answer is 20.59.

This section requires Javascript.
You are seeing this because something didn't load right. We suggest you, (a) try refreshing the page, (b) enabling javascript if it is disabled on your browser and, finally, (c) loading the non-javascript version of this page . We're sorry about the hassle.

7 solutions

Christian Lee
Aug 26, 2013

The Law of Conservation of Momentum states:

m × v m \times v = constant , where m is mass, and v is velocity.

The mass of the woman is 70 kg , and the velocity is 1 m/s . The woman is transformed to a beetle that is 10 g . 10 g = 0.01 kg . You then need to find the velocity after the transformation.

( 70 k g ) × ( 1 m / s ) (70 kg) \times (1 m/s) = ( 0.01 k g ) × ( v ) (0.01 kg) \times (v) Solve for v

v = 70 0.01 \frac{70}{0.01} v = 7,000 m/s

The question asks for how many times faster than the speed of sound is this. The speed of sound is given as 340 m/s . So take 7000 340 \frac{7000}{340} which gives 20.5882

Also, does anyone know how to format subscripts?

Christian Lee - 7 years, 9 months ago

Log in to reply

v_{f} = v f v_{f}

Add an underscore and then brackets around the thing being subscript-ed.

Kevin Fei - 7 years, 9 months ago
Noel Quirol
Aug 28, 2013

By Law of Conservation of Momentum we have, momentum before transformation = momentum after transformation (70 kg)(1m/s) = (0.01kg) Velocity after transformation Velocity = (70kgm/s)/ 0.01kg Velocity = 7000m/s

(7000m/s)/ (340m/s) = 20.588

That is 20.588 times faster than the speed of sound.

Kshitij Varshney
Aug 27, 2013

The momentum of the body before and after the collision is equal due to the principle of linear momentum. mass of the woman=70 kg (m 1) velocity of it=1m/s(u 1) mass of the beetle=10g or 0.01kg(m 2) velocity=?(u 2) => m 1*u 1=m 2*u 2 70/.01=u 2 7000m/s=u 2 therefore the speed of the beetle is 7000m/s speed of sound is 340m/s => 340x=7000 x=7000/340 x=20.5882 (approx.)

Jerby Cristo
Aug 28, 2013

As the woman reduces her mass into a mass of a beetle, her momentum is still conserved. If m1 is the mass of the woman =70 kg, v1 the speed of the woman = 1 m/s, m2 the mass of the beetle = 10 g = 0.01kg and v2 the speed of the beetle which is UNKNOWN; then; m1v1 = m2v2 (70kg)(1m/s) = (0.01kg)(v2) then; v2 = 7,000 m/s

Divide v2 by the speed of sound: 7,000 m/s / 340 m/s = 20.59

Ajitesh Mishra
Aug 26, 2013

We know that according to the law of conservation of momentum (the product of mass and velocity); the initial momentum of a system is equal to the final momentum provided net external force on the system remains zero.

Hence, Let initial mass of the body be m, velocity be v, and final mass and velocity to be M and V, then m v = M V Solving we get V = 7000 m/s

So , no. of times faster than sound = 7000/340 = 20.6

20.588

Ahmed Abdallah - 7 years, 9 months ago

The momentum of the woman is given by p = m v p=mv . This tells us that the woman's momentum is 70 k g m / s 70kg\cdot m/s . Since the momentum is conserved when she becomes a beetle, we know that 70 k g m / s = 10 g v 70kg\cdot m/s=10g\cdot v , which tells us that the beetle's velocity is 7000 m / s 7000m/s . ( 7000 m / s ) / ( 340 m / s ) = 20.59 (7000m/s)/(340m/s)=20.59 . Thus, she is 20.59 times faster than the speed of sound.

Ben Sockol
Aug 25, 2013

Momentum = mass x velocity. Thus the momentum of the woman = 70000 g x 1 m/s = 70000 mg/s. When she changes into a beetle her velocity = momentum/mass = 70000mg/s/10g = 7000 m/s. this is approximately 20.59 times faster than the speed of sound.

0 pending reports

×

Problem Loading...

Note Loading...

Set Loading...