RMO 2006 Problem

Find the least possible value of a + b a+b where a , b a,b are positive integers such that 11 11 divides a + 13 b a+13b and 13 13 divides a + 11 b a+11b .


The answer is 28.

This section requires Javascript.
You are seeing this because something didn't load right. We suggest you, (a) try refreshing the page, (b) enabling javascript if it is disabled on your browser and, finally, (c) loading the non-javascript version of this page . We're sorry about the hassle.

5 solutions

Ryan Lee
Dec 17, 2014

Given that 11 divides a + 13 b a + 13b and 13 divides a + 11 b a + 11b , we know that

a + 13 b 0 ( m o d 11 ) a + 13b \equiv 0 \pmod{11}

and

a + 11 b 0 ( m o d 13 ) a + 11b \equiv 0 \pmod{13} .

These are equivalent to

a + 2 b 0 ( m o d 11 ) a + 2b \equiv 0 \pmod{11}

and

a 2 b 0 ( m o d 13 ) a - 2b \equiv 0 \pmod{13} .

Now, let a + 2 b = 11 j a + 2b = 11j and a 2 b = 13 k a - 2b = 13k , where j , k j, k are non-negative integers. Because b b is positive, 11 j 11j must be bigger than 13 k 13k as there is a difference of 4 b 4b between the two equations. This means that j > k j > k .

If we add the two equations, we get

2 a = 11 j + 13 k 2a = 11j + 13k .

Ideally we want a a as small as possible, which means we are looking for the smallest values of j j and k k that work. As j j and k k are integers, 11 j 11j and 13 k 13k must add to give an even number ( 2 a 2a ).

The smallest values of j j and k k that fit these criteria are 2 and 0 (respectively). This leads to a a being 11. Looking back to our equation a 2 b = 13 k a -2b = 13k , the only non-negative value of 13 k 13k that is smaller than 11 is 0. This leads to b b being 5.5, however we know that b b is an integer, so this cannot be the case.

The next smallest values of j j and k k are 3 and 1. This leads to a a being 23.

Using these values we can try to find b b by subtracting the two equations instead, giving

4 b = 11 j 13 k 4b = 11j - 13k .

If we substitute our values in, we get

4 b = 11 3 13 1 = 20 4b = 11 \cdot 3 - 13 \cdot 1 = 20

b = 5 b = 5

b b is an integer! It works!

Therefore

a + b = 23 + 5 = 28 a + b = 23 + 5 = 28

This is my first time using latex (and writing a solution!), so sorry if my write-up is a bit wonky.

Vishal Antony
Dec 17, 2014

(a+13b) = 0 (mod 11) and (a+11b) = 0(mod 13)

now 13 times a multiple of 11 and

11 times a multiple of 13 is divisible by 11*13 = 143.

therefore 13*(a+13b) = 0 (mod143)

and 11*(a+11b) = 0 (mod 143)

hence

13 a + 169b = 0 (mod 143)

and 11a + 121b = 0 (mod 143)

adding both gives: 24a + 290b = 0 (mod 143)

2(12a + 145b) = 0 (mod 143)

that implies

12a + 145b = 0(mod 143)

(12a + 2b) + 143b = 0 (mod 143)

that implies

12a + 2b = 0 (mod 143)

2(6a+b) = 0 (mod 143)

hence a = 143/6 = 23

and b = 143 - 23*6 = 5.

a+b = 28.

Souryajit Roy
Dec 17, 2014

a + 13 b a + 2 b 0 a+13b≡a+2b≡0 ( m o d 11 ) (mod 11) .

Multiplying by 6 6 , 6 a + 12 b 0 6a+12b≡0 ( m o d 11 ) (mod 11) which further implies 6 a + b 0 6a+b≡0 ( m o d 11 ) (mod 11) .

Again, a + 11 b a 2 b 0 a+11b≡a-2b≡0 ( m o d 13 ) (mod 13)

Multiplying by 6 6 , 6 a 12 b 0 6a-12b≡0 ( m o d 13 ) (mod 13) which implies 6 a + b 0 6a+b≡0 ( m o d 13 ) (mod 13) .

Since g c d ( 11 , 13 ) = 1 gcd(11,13)=1 ,therefore 143 143 divides 6 a + b 6a+b .

So we can write, 6 a + b = 143 k 6a+b=143k , or 6 a + 6 b = 143 k + 5 b = 114 k + 6 b ( k + b ) 6a+6b=143k+5b=114k+6b-(k+b)

Hence, 6 6 divides k + b k+b and so, k + b 6 k+b≥6

Now, 6 ( a + b ) = 143 k + 5 b = 138 + 5 ( k + b ) 138 + 30 = 168 6(a+b)=143k+5b=138+5(k+b)≥138+30=168

Hence, a + b 28 a+b≥28

Taking, a = 23 a=23 and b = 5 b=5 , one can see the conditions of the pronlem are satisfied.

So,the minimum value of a + b a+b is 28 28

Rick B
Dec 24, 2014

11 a + 13 b 11 ( a + 13 b ) + 11 b 11 a + 24 b 11 \mid a+13b \implies 11 \mid (a+13b)+11b \implies \color{#D61F06}{11 \mid a+24b}

13 a + 11 b 13 ( a + 11 b ) + 13 b 13 a + 24 b 13 \mid a+11b \implies 13 \mid (a+11b)+13b \implies \color{#D61F06}{13 \mid a+24b}

Since a + 24 b a+24b is a multiple of 11 11 and 13 13 and these numbers are coprime, it follows that a + 24 b a+24b is a multiple of 11 × 13 = 143 11 \times 13 = 143

Since we want the least possible value of a + b a+b , we need to set a + 24 b = 143 a+24b = 143 and maximize b b

Under these conditions, a = 23 a = 23 and b = 5 b = 5 , so a + b = 28 a+b = \boxed{28}

Abdullah Shahriar
Dec 21, 2014

a + 13 b 0 ( m o d 11 ) a + 2 b 0 ( m o d 11 ) a+13b \equiv 0 \pmod{11} \Rightarrow a+2b \equiv 0 \pmod{11}

a + 11 b 0 ( m o d 13 ) a 2 b 0 ( m o d 13 ) a+11b \equiv 0 \pmod{13} \Rightarrow a-2b \equiv 0 \pmod{13}

a 2 b = 13 x a-2b=13x

Let x = 1 x=1 (For the smallest value of a+b)

17 4 = 13 17 + 4 = 21 1 ( m o d 11 ) 17-4=13 \Rightarrow 17+4=21 \equiv -1 \pmod{11}

19 6 = 13 19 + 6 = 25 3 ( m o d 11 ) 19-6=13 \Rightarrow 19+6=25 \equiv 3 \pmod{11}

21 8 = 13 21 + 8 = 29 7 ( m o d 11 ) 21-8=13 \Rightarrow 21+8=29 \equiv 7 \pmod{11}

23 10 = 13 23 + 10 = 33 0 ( m o d 11 ) 23-10=13 \Rightarrow 23+10=33 \equiv 0 \pmod{11}

s o , b = 10 / 2 = 5 so, b=10/2=5

H e n c e ( a , b ) = ( 23 , 5 ) a + b = 28 Hence (a,b)=(23,5) \Rightarrow a+b= \boxed{28}

0 pending reports

×

Problem Loading...

Note Loading...

Set Loading...