Roly-Poly toy

Why does this toy always bounce back no matter how hard it's punched?

Most of the toy's mass is distributed at the top The toy's mass is distributed evenly Most of the toy's mass is distributed at the bottom

This section requires Javascript.
You are seeing this because something didn't load right. We suggest you, (a) try refreshing the page, (b) enabling javascript if it is disabled on your browser and, finally, (c) loading the non-javascript version of this page . We're sorry about the hassle.

13 solutions

Ram Mohith
Aug 19, 2018

Center of mass for this bodies lies exactly at the body. In what ever direction it is pushed centre of mass position is not changed. Which means centre of mass displacement is 0. This implies all the bodies will come to their initial position.


x c m = m 1 x 1 + m 2 x 2 + . . . m 1 + m 2 + . . . x_{cm} = \dfrac{m_1x_1 + m_2x_2 + ...}{m_1 + m_2 + ...} Where x c m x_{cm} is the change in position of centre of mass which is 0. m 1 x 1 + m 2 x 2 + . . . = 0 \implies m_1x_1 + m_2x_2 + ... = 0 This says that the sum of product of masses and change in position of corresponding bodies is equal to 0 0 . This implies that all the bodies' have reached their initial positions.

correctmundo

Arian Royz - 2 years, 9 months ago

This is complete nonsense. First of all, the center of mass does move. Secondly, the formula doesn't yield a displacement but a position. Furthermore, sum zero doesn't imply terms zero.

Manuel Ruiz - 2 years, 9 months ago

Can you please explain more (elementarily i guess)

Mohammad Farhat - 2 years, 9 months ago
Mohammad Farhat
Aug 20, 2018

WARNING: THIS IS ONLY BY USING COMMON SENSE.

The mass can't be distributed evenly because it would be impossible for it to rebound. If most of the mass is at the top then it would stay wobbling down and cannot rebound (or bounce back) and thus the answer is it is at the bottom because then it [the top] could just move while the bottom is trying to keep the toy still and the bottom is the reason why it [the toy] stops after a while.

2 points (from Chris Cheek) : - if the mass were all at the top then it would also flip upside down and remain there (point 1) and the reason that it finally comes to rest is due to friction and the resulting loss of momentum that was imparted by the punch (point 2)

Good deduction by process of elimination. Two points, if the mass were all at the top then it would also flip upside down and remain there and the reason that it finally cones to rest is due to friction and the resulting loss of momentum that was imparted by the punch .

Chris Cheek - 2 years, 9 months ago

Log in to reply

Hmm. Interesting.

Mohammad Farhat - 2 years, 9 months ago

Mohhamed Farhan do you know why people are not discussing to such an interesting question. Can a question with more than 35K solvers have just 56 people discussing ??

Ram Mohith - 2 years, 9 months ago

Log in to reply

The answer is human behavior. We do what we like

Mohammad Farhat - 2 years, 9 months ago

It can be shown that the center of mass is the point such that the resulting external force and torque applied to it produces the same effect as the application of all those external forces to the body.

This allows us to consider the force of gravity as a vector pointing towards the ground applied to the center of mass. Let's conduct our analysis choosing the point of contact with the ground as the origin (this allows us to avoid considering the normal force).

In case of point A (in the situation showed), this means that the body will experience a torque that makes it rotate counterclockwise , thus making the situation worse. Point C is the only one that is exerting a finite torque that restores the body to its initial position: point B might do the same job as point A with only a slight fluctuation.

Because of the form of the toy's base, point C (or a point that is a little lower) will always exert a restoring torque.

Note: directions of rotation are given by the right hand rule .

Jeff Phillips
Aug 20, 2018

It’s evil; it rises up each time by the strength of its purely malevolent hatred of all humanity.

It bounces back because in its mind it says, "Comin' for" … person punches "yo.." punch punch punch "u"

Mohammad Farhat - 2 years, 9 months ago
Utsav Playz
Sep 8, 2018

It's simply some common sense. If all the mass will be distributed at the bottom because of gravity or the greatest force of attraction will only the towards the earth (9.8m/s). Now, if you punch the object, the mass will be at rest at the moment but while it goes down, there are some disturbance to the matter pulling it upwards but gravity uncle will pull the matter back down again no matter what ! If you didn't understood then listen, First, the mass is distributed at the bottom keeping it in stationery motion. Now, if you punch it backwards you are actually trying to distribute the mass at the top while there is more mass at the bottom. So the mass pulled upwards is pulled downwards again which leads the object to get back in straight position.

Trevor Greenlee
Sep 5, 2018

This is a basic problem. Thank about it. If you have EVER lift one of these things up, which side is heavier? The bottom. You don’t need super math skills to solve this, just basic knowledge.

Perera Chandi
Aug 28, 2018

The centre of mass is at the bottom of the toy this makes the toy more stable. The centre of mass is at the bottom because the lower surface of the toy has a larger surface area than the top, sort of like a cone.

Manuel Ruiz
Aug 25, 2018

The object is stable (returns to equilibrium), as long as moving away equals center of mass having to rise (beside from moving sideways). This happens when the center of mass lies below the center of the smallest curvature in the contact point. So actually a combination of a low center of mass and a blunt underside are needed. This phenomenon also happens with a classical guitar.

Jenne De Gendt
Aug 22, 2018

An object is in balance as long as its centre of gravity lies in or above the area of the zone where it touches the ground. This can only happen when (most of) the mass is in the bodom, whereas the centre of gravity is as low as possible.

Kesavan V
Aug 22, 2018

Think about torque about the contact point with the ground. If the mass is distributed only at the top or evenly distributed, a considerable torque exists due to gravity (because a "considerably" large lever arm exists) that prevents the rebound of the object. Only plausible choice is C.

Kaisei Tanaka
Aug 21, 2018

This sounds so much like a meme X D \frac{X}{D}

Radoslav Habarda
Aug 21, 2018

For your amusement : https://youtu.be/JEKLN2V5_gI

Stewart Gordon
Aug 20, 2018

The toy's centre of mass would have to be in the base, lower down than its widest part. In any position, the toy's weight will effectively act downwards at the centre of mass. When the toy is in contact with the ground, a couple forms consisting of the toy's weight and the normal reaction from the ground. When the centre of mass is suitably placed, this couple will always be oriented in such a direction as to rotate the toy back to the upright position.

0 pending reports

×

Problem Loading...

Note Loading...

Set Loading...