Root Difference Inequality

Algebra Level 4

How many integers satisfy ( n 23 × 24 ) 2 < 1 \left(\sqrt{n} - \sqrt{23\times 24}\right)^2 < 1 ?


The answer is 93.

This section requires Javascript.
You are seeing this because something didn't load right. We suggest you, (a) try refreshing the page, (b) enabling javascript if it is disabled on your browser and, finally, (c) loading the non-javascript version of this page . We're sorry about the hassle.

5 solutions

( n 23 × 24 ) 2 < 1 \left(\sqrt{n} - \sqrt{23\times 24}\right)^2<1

Getting the square root of both sides, n 23 × 24 < 1 |\sqrt{n} - \sqrt{23\times 24}|<1
1 < n 23 × 24 < 1 -1< \sqrt{n} - \sqrt{23\times 24}<1
23 × 24 1 < n < 23 × 24 + 1 \sqrt{23\times 24}-1<\sqrt{n}<\sqrt{23\times 24}+1

Squaring, 23 × 24 2 23 × 24 + 1 < n < 23 × 24 + 2 23 × 24 + 1 23\times 24-2\sqrt{23\times 24}+1<n<23\times 24+2\sqrt{23\times 24}+1 Counting the number of integers n which satisfy the inequality above is similar to knowing how many integers satisfy: 2 23 × 24 < n 23 × 24 < 2 23 × 24 -2\sqrt{23\times 24}<n-23 \times 24 <2\sqrt{23\times 24}

Since, 23 < 23 × 24 < 23.5 23 < \sqrt{23\times 24}<23.5 , thus 47 < n 23 × 24 < 47 -47<n- 23 \times 24 <47 .

Since n n is an integer, so 46 n 46 -46 \le n \le 46 This gives us 46 ( 46 ) + 1 = 93 46 - (-46) + 1 = 93 integers.

Comments and replies:

Calvin:

This is correct, and exactly my solution. I did not find the exact value for n n , but found the range of n 23 × 24 n - 23 \times 24 . That greatly reduces the chance for calculation errors.

Calvin Lin Staff - 7 years ago
Yogita Gaikwad
May 20, 2014

mod(root(n)- root (23 24))&lt;=1 1-root (23 24)&lt;root(n)&lt; 1+root (23*24) 22.49468025&lt;root (n)&lt; 24.49468025 506.0106395&lt; n &lt; 599.9893606 total no of integers=599.9893606-506.0106395=93 Now, I agree with n=93!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!

Comments and replies:

Calvin:

Note that the intention of this question is NOT to have you calculate 23 × 24 \sqrt{23 \times 24} to an extreme degree of precision. Please refer to Raoul's comment to see how to count the number of solutions evaluating 23 × 24 \sqrt{23\times24} . This question can be generalized to an arbitrary A × B \sqrt{A \times B} .

Calvin Lin Staff - 7 years ago

Since n is an integer, the value (sqrt(n)-sqrt(23*24))^2 must be positive. Now, this value is less than 1 implies that its minimum value is 0.

Consider the case that the value of the given number is zero.

Then, n=23*24=552

Now consider the following equation (although it is not possible).

(sqrt(n)-sqrt(23*24))^2= 1

Note that 23 24 lies between 23^2 and 24^2. So, sqrt(23 24) lies between 23 and 24.

A small calculation reveals that the approximate value of sqrt(23*24) is 23.5.

So, ((sqrt(n) - 23.5))^2= 1 Or, sqrt(n) - 23.5= 1 [the negative case is dealt with later] Or, sqrt(n)= 24.5 Or, n= 600.25

But the given number is less than 1. This implies than n must be less than 600.25. Or, the maximum value of n is 600. So n can lie between 552 and 600.

Now consider the negative case [i.e sqrt(n) - 23.5 = -1)

sqrt(n)- 23.5 = -1 Or, sqrt(n) = 22.5 Or, sqrt(n)= 506.25

This implies that n can lie between 506 and 552.

Combining these two facts, we get that n must lie between 506 and 600 [both inclusive]. So the number of such integers is 600-506+1= 95

Comments and replies:

Calvin:

This is essentially correct, though it obscures the quick way of calculating.

You mentioned that 23 × 24 \sqrt{23 \times 24} is approximately 23.5. Do you know if it is larger than, equal to, or smaller than 23.5?

There is a neater way of presenting it, so that you don't need to distinguish between the 'negative case' and the 'positive case'? If you treat this as a standard inequality, how would you normally proceed?


Calvin:

The error that you made, was to not accurately use the value of 23 × 24 \sqrt{23 \times 24} . It only appears close to 23.5, but when we are doing further calculations, that error can multiply.

It is not true that the solutions are equal to 1 n 23.5 1 -1 \leq \sqrt{n}-23.5 \leq 1 . If you check, it turns out that \sqrt{600} - \sqrt{23 \times 24} &gt;1 , even though \sqrt{600} - 23.5 &lt; 1 .

Calvin Lin Staff - 7 years ago
Calvin Lin Staff
May 13, 2014

The inequality is equivalent to ( n 23 × 24 + 1 ) ( n 23 × 24 1 ) < 0 \left( \sqrt{n} - \sqrt{23\times 24} +1\right) \left(\sqrt{n} - \sqrt{23\times 24} -1\right) < 0 , or 23 × 24 1 < n < 23 × 24 + 1 \sqrt{23\times 24} -1 < \sqrt{n} < \sqrt{ 23\times 24} + 1 . All the terms are greater than 0 so squaring everything, we get 23 × 24 2 23 × 24 + 1 < n < 23 × 24 + 2 23 × 24 + 1 23\times 24 - 2 \sqrt{23\times 24} +1 < n < 23\times 24 + 2 \sqrt{23\times 24} +1 2 23 × 24 < n 23 × 24 1 < 2 23 × 24 \Rightarrow -2 \sqrt{23\times 24} < n - 23\times 24 - 1 < 2 \sqrt{23\times 24} . Since 2 3 2 < 23 × 24 < 23. 5 2 23^2 < 23\times 24 < 23.5^2 , we have 46 n 23 × 24 1 46 -46 \leq n - 23\times 24 - 1\leq 46 , so there are 93 possible integer solutions.

Saloni Gupta
May 20, 2014

According to me , there are two such integers - 23^2 (=529) and 24^2 (=576) as I have calculated as follows-

The quantity ( 23 24)^1/2 is approximately 23.49468 i.e 23.5 . Now, using modulus { n^1/2 - (23 24)^1/2 } &lt; 1, considering a straight line with points (23 24)^1/2 -1 and (23 24)^1/2 +1 , n^1/2 must strictly lie between these two numbers , i.e. n^1/2 must strictly lie between 23.5 - 1 and 23.5 + 1 i.e. n^1/2 must strictly lie between 22.5 and 24.5 i.e. n can attain values between (22.5) ^2 and (24.5)^2

                  Since n is demanded to be an integer , it can be either (23)^2  that is 529 
                                                                                or (24)^2 that is 576.

0 pending reports

×

Problem Loading...

Note Loading...

Set Loading...