An apple is in the shape of a ball of radius 31 mm. A worm gets into the apple and digs a tunnel of total length 61 mm, and then leaves the apple. The tunnel need not be a straight line. Can one cut the apple with a straight slice through the center so that one of the two halves is not rotten?
This section requires Javascript.
You are seeing this because something didn't load right. We suggest you, (a) try
refreshing the page, (b) enabling javascript if it is disabled on your browser and,
finally, (c)
loading the
non-javascript version of this page
. We're sorry about the hassle.
Consider first a 2 d version of the problem. Let Γ be the circle delimiting the disc Δ on which the worm moves, A ∈ Γ and B ∈ Γ be respectively the starting and the end point of the trajectory of the worm and [ C D ] be a diameter of Γ . Suppose that the trajectory A B ~ intersects [ C D ] in two points E and F such that O the center of Γ lies in [ E F ] , then the length of A B ~ is at least equal to the diameter of Γ . To prove this, assume WLG that E and F lie respectively in [ O C ] and [ O D ] , and denote by X Y ˉ the length of the portion X Y ~ of A B ~ , we use the fact that for a point M on Δ , the nearest point on Γ to M is the intersection of Γ and [ O M ) , and the fact that the shortest path between two points is the straight line connecting the two points, to derive the inequalities A E ˉ ≥ C E , E F ˉ ≥ E F and F B ˉ ≥ F D , thus A B ˉ = A E ˉ + E F ˉ + F B ˉ ≥ C E + E F + F D = C D . It follows that either [ O C ] or [ O D ] does not intersect the trajectory. Assume WLG that [ O C ] does not intersect the trajectory. Let V be a variable point on Γ whose starting position is C . Imagine that we move V (for ex. clockwise), let P be the position of V when [ O V ] touches A B ~ for the first time. Obviously A B ~ is completely outside the region delimited by [ O C ] , [ O P ] and the arc C P ~ (that corresponds to the clockwise sense starting from C ). Let Q be the 2nd intersection between [ P O ) and Γ , according to the first result the trajectory does not intersect [ O Q ] , thus [ P Q ] is a cut that satisfies the conditions of the 2 d version. For the 3 d version, we keep the same notations as before. Let Δ be the intersection of the ball and a plane containing A , B and O the center of the ball. Consider the orthogonal projection of A B ~ on Δ , and let [ P Q ] be a cut on Δ that satisfies the conditions of the 2 d version. Consider the plane containing [ P Q ] and perpendicular to Δ , this plane defines a cut that satisfies the condition of the 3 d version.