SAT Numbers

Let x x and y y be integers. If x + y x + y is odd, which of the following is true about ( x + y ) 2 + x y ? (x+y)^{2}+xy?

It is even It is odd It is even if x x is even It is even if y y is even It is even if x y xy is negative

This section requires Javascript.
You are seeing this because something didn't load right. We suggest you, (a) try refreshing the page, (b) enabling javascript if it is disabled on your browser and, finally, (c) loading the non-javascript version of this page . We're sorry about the hassle.

6 solutions

Discussions for this problem are now closed

Tatiana Georgieva Staff
Feb 3, 2015

Correct Answer: B

Solution 1:

Tip: Replace variables with numbers.
(A) If x = 1 x=1 and y = 2 y=2 , x + y = 3 = odd x+y = 3 =\text{odd} , and ( x + y ) 2 + x y = ( 1 + 2 ) 2 + 1 2 = 3 2 + 2 = 9 + 2 = 11 (x+y)^{2}+xy =(1+2)^{2}+1\cdot 2 = 3^{2} + 2 = 9+2=11 , which is odd. Eliminate (A).

(C) If x = 2 x=2 and y = 1 y=1 , x + y = 3 = odd x+y = 3=\text{odd} ,and ( x + y ) 2 + x y = ( 2 + 1 ) 2 + 2 1 = 3 2 + 2 = 9 + 2 = 11 (x+y)^{2}+xy =(2+1)^{2}+2\cdot 1 = 3^{2} + 2 = 9+2=11 , which is odd. Eliminate (C).

(D) If x = 1 x=1 and y = 2 y=2 , x + y = 3 = odd x+y =3= \text{odd} , and ( x + y ) 2 + x y = ( 1 + 2 ) 2 + 1 2 = 3 2 + 2 = 9 + 2 = 11 (x+y)^{2}+xy =(1+2)^{2}+1\cdot 2 = 3^{2} + 2 = 9+2=11 , which is odd. Eliminate (D).

(E) If x = 2 x=-2 and y = 1 , x y = 2. y=1, xy = -2. Then, x + y = 2 + 1 = 1 = odd , x+y = -2 + 1 = -1 = \text{odd}, and ( x + y ) 2 + x y = ( 1 ) 2 + ( 2 ) = 1 2 = 1 , (x+y)^{2} + xy = (-1)^{2} + (-2) = 1-2=-1, which is odd. Eliminate choice E.

We eliminated all choices except (B), which is the correct answer.

Solution 2:

Tip: Know the properties of even and odd numbers.
If x + y x+y is odd, then ( x + y ) 2 = ( x + y ) odd × ( x + y ) odd = odd × odd = odd (x+y)^{2} = \underbrace{(x+y)}_{\text{odd}} \times \underbrace{(x+y)}_{\text{odd}} = \text{odd} \times \text{odd} = \text{odd} .

x + y x+y is odd only if: x x is even and y y is odd, or if x x is odd and y y is even. In either case, x y xy will be even, because even × \times odd = = even.

So, ( x + y ) 2 odd + x y even = \underbrace{(x+y)^{2}}_{\text{odd}}+\underbrace{xy}_{\text{even}}= odd + + even = = odd.

Therefore, answer choice (B) is correct.



Incorrect Choices:

(A) , (C) , (D) , and (E)
See Solution 1 for how we can eliminate these choices by replacing the variable with a number.

Solution 2 is better

PS Prateek - 6 years, 4 months ago

Choice (E) used to read "It is even if xy is odd," and most of the comments submitted here refer to this old version. There was a problem with (E), however, and we have since changed it to read "It is even if xy is negative."

The problem: technically, in classical logic contradictory premises imply any conclusion. In the old version, choice (E) established contradictory premises:

A. x+y is odd
B. xy is odd

A and B cannot be true at the same time. Therefore anything follows, and answer (E) was true. (Look up the paradox of entailment for more.)

Good work to everyone!

Tatiana Georgieva Staff - 6 years, 3 months ago

But (E) is also correct. If (x+y) is odd then, its square is also odd. It is given in the option that xy is odd. Thus, (x+y)^2 + xy is even since the sum of two odd numbers is even.

Siddharth VP - 6 years, 4 months ago

If x+y is odd then xy can not be odd. x+y can only be odd if either x or y is odd and second number is even, so then xy will be even not odd. Therefore, option E can not be correct.

Ghazala Qaiser - 6 years, 4 months ago

Choice (E) is technically correct, though not for the reason that Siddharth Vp gives. He attempts to evaluate the expression as even using: 1) The given information that x+y is odd 2) The additional information suggested by "if xy is odd." The error here is that these two statements are in direct contradiction. We cannot make a conclusion about the expression from two conflicting statements. In reality, the given information "x+y is odd" renders the second statement false. Therefore, we cannot follow the usual method of proving conditional statements ("assume the premise to be correct and reach the conclusion) because the premise is absolutely false.

Here is how to properly show that (E) is correct: The problem says "which of the following is true..." Choice (E) is a conditional statement. It claims "If xy is odd then our expression is even." A conditional statement can be true even if its conclusion (the "then" portion) is false. The fact that xy is NOT odd (something that will always be true with the given information), means that any conditional statement predicated on "if xy is odd" will automatically be true. It is equivalent to me claiming that I will donate everything I own if 1+1=3. My promise is true and I never have to back up my claim because 1+1 will never equal 3.

All that being said, choice (E) seems to read "It is even if xy is NEGATIVE." That is undoubtedly false. This discussion here is about a choice (E) that reads "It It is even if xy is ODD." Such a choice does not seem to exist anymore... It seems like either the problem has been edited, or everyone here is misreading it.

Gavi Hochsztein - 6 years, 3 months ago

No. (x+y) is odd then either one of them is even and the other one is odd. Therefore, their product is an even number (because their product will always be divisible by 2, a factor of the even number).

Nguyen Tra - 6 years, 3 months ago

"It is given in the option that xy is odd"...... is it? And why would it given, as it is said that x+y is odd. One of them is must be even & as a result xy must have to be even. So, the result is: odd {(x+y)^2}+even(xy) = odd.

Shivly Mahmood - 6 years, 2 months ago

Given x + y is odd, which directly implies one is odd and one is even then how x*y be odd?

Arun Karthik - 6 years, 4 months ago

X*y is not odd

prashant singh - 6 years, 4 months ago
Paulo Carlos
Feb 3, 2015

Let E E be a even number and O O be a odd number. We know that:

E + E = E E + E = E

O + O = E O + O = E

E + O = O E + O = O

O + E = O O + E = O

Then:

( x + y ) 2 = O (x + y)^{2} = O

And:

x y = E xy = E

Finally we have that:

O + E = O O + E = O

The answer is B B

x+y is only odd if and only if x or y is odd (not both). Square of an odd number is odd while product of even and odd number is even. Furthermore, sum of an odd and even number is odd. So, the answer must be an odd number.

Jeremy Bansil
Feb 4, 2015

If x + y x + y is an odd number, then it means one of them is odd and one of them is even. Now let's see the equation ( x + y ) 2 + x y (x+y)^{2} + xy ... ( x + y ) 2 (x+y)^2 means that an odd number is multiplied by itself, which means an odd number is multiplied by odd. An odd number multiplied by another odd number gives a product of an odd number. x y xy would say that an odd number is multiplied by an even number, which would give a product of an even number.

Overall, if you add an odd number with an even number, you would get an odd number, so the answer is B \boxed{B} .

Rishi Sharma
Feb 4, 2015

since the sum of the numbers is odd that means both of them must have different parities. Since they have different parities their product must be even. The final number formed is the sum of an odd(square of an odd number is odd) and an even number therefore it must be an odd number hence B

Mike Higdon
Apr 8, 2015

Assume x and y are integers and x+y is odd. Then by definition: (x+y) = 2n+1 for some n where n is an integer. Then (x+y)^2 = (2n+1)(2n+1)=4n^2+4n+1

Now with a quick little move we get: 2(2n^2+2n)+1 which is odd, since it is a number of the form 2m+1, (m = 2n^2+2n where m is an integer). Now, I don't even have to worry about xy being even or odd, because for (x+y)^2 + xy to be even, then it must be divisible by 2.

In other words: (x+y)^2+xy = 2c where c is an integer, which implies (x+y)^2 and xy must both be divisible by 2.

But we have already shown that (x+y)^2 is odd, therefore not divisible by 2.

QED

Note: xy has to be even, and in fact, one of x or y has to be odd. Just run through the three options:

1) x and y could both be even. (Contradicts x+y is odd.) 2) x and y could both be odd. (Contradicts x+y is odd.) 3) One of x or y is odd. Let's say x is even, y is odd. Doesn't contradict x+y odd. And since x =2n where n is an integer, then xy = 2ny which is a number of the form 2m where m is an integer. (Here: m=ny).

0 pending reports

×

Problem Loading...

Note Loading...

Set Loading...