SAT1000 - P527

Algebra Level 4

Given that a , b R , a + b = 2 , b > 0 a,b \in \mathbb R, a+b=2, b>0 , then find the minimum value of 1 2 a + a b \dfrac{1}{2|a|}+\dfrac{|a|}{b} .

Let M M be the minimum value. Submit 1000 M \lfloor 1000M \rfloor .


Have a look at my problem set: SAT 1000 problems


The answer is 750.

This section requires Javascript.
You are seeing this because something didn't load right. We suggest you, (a) try refreshing the page, (b) enabling javascript if it is disabled on your browser and, finally, (c) loading the non-javascript version of this page . We're sorry about the hassle.

3 solutions

Chew-Seong Cheong
Jun 10, 2020

1 2 a + a b = 1 2 2 b + 2 b b = { 1 2 ( 2 b ) + 2 b b for 0 < b 2 1 2 ( b 2 ) + b 2 b for b > 2 \dfrac 1{2|a|} + \dfrac {|a|}b = \dfrac 1{2|2-b|} + \dfrac {|2-b|}b = \begin{cases} \dfrac 1{2(2-b)} + \dfrac {2-b}b & \text{for }0 < b \le 2 \\ \dfrac 1{2(b-2)} + \dfrac {b-2}b & \text{for }b > 2 \end{cases}

Case 1: 0 < b 2 0 < b \le 2

f ( b ) = 1 2 ( 2 b ) + 2 b b f ( b ) = 1 2 ( 2 b ) 2 2 b 2 = 3 b 2 16 b + 16 2 ( 2 b ) 2 b 2 = ( 3 b 4 ) ( b 4 ) 2 ( 2 b ) 2 b 2 min ( f ( b ) ) = f ( 4 3 ) = 5 4 \begin{aligned} f(b) & = \frac 1{2(2-b)} + \frac {2-b}b \\ f'(b) & = \frac 1{2(2-b)^2} - \frac 2{b^2} = - \frac {3b^2-16b+16}{2(2-b)^2b^2} = - \frac {(3b-4)(b-4)}{2(2-b)^2b^2} \\ \min (f(b)) & = f \left(\frac 43 \right) = \frac 54 \end{aligned}

Case 2: b > 2 b > 2

f ( b ) = 1 2 ( b 2 ) + b 2 b f ( b ) = 1 2 ( b 2 ) 2 + 2 b 2 = ( 3 b 4 ) ( b 4 ) 2 ( 2 b ) 2 b 2 min ( f ( b ) ) = f ( 4 ) = 3 4 \begin{aligned} f(b) & = \frac 1{2(b-2)} + \frac {b-2}b \\ f'(b) & = - \frac 1{2(b-2)^2} + \frac 2{b^2}= \frac {(3b-4)(b-4)}{2(2-b)^2b^2} \\ \min (f(b)) & = f (4) = \frac 34 \end{aligned}

Therefore the minimum value M = 3 4 = 0.75 M=\frac 34 = 0.75 , 1000 M = 750 \implies \lfloor 1000M \rfloor = \boxed{750} .

Case 2: you copied -1 from case 1.

Pop Wong - 1 year ago

Log in to reply

Thanks. I have deleted it.

Chew-Seong Cheong - 1 year ago

I think we had this conversation before! But, here I go again.

Unwarranted application of AM-GM is almost always bad. f ( x ) g ( x ) f(x) \geq g(x) doesn't mean f ( x ) f(x) achieves a minimum value when f ( x ) = g ( x ) f(x)=g(x) . For example, why didn't you apply AM-GM for the terms 1 2 ( 2 b ) a n d 2 b \frac{1}{2(2-b)} \> and \> \frac{2}{b} ? It's because you wouldn't get to the correct answer applying the same logic as you applied here. Graphing 1 2 ( 2 b ) + 2 b \frac{1}{2(2-b)} + \frac{2}{b} and 2 1 b ( 2 b ) 2 \sqrt{\frac{1}{b(2-b)}} would make the fallacy clear.

AM-GM Fallacy AM-GM Fallacy

As long as you can't justify your reasoning for arranging the terms in a certain way to get the proper result, the solution has no logical basis at all!

I will also point at your usage of = = sign right after \geq saying "equality occurs at some point". This is also wrong. You cannot write this mathematically as the functions of b b are not 'constant' functions. You have to use f ( b = 4 ) f(b=4) to make use of the = = sign.

Atomsky Jahid - 12 months ago

No worry, thanks again.

Chew-Seong Cheong - 12 months ago

This problem can be solved using calculus easily. Firstly, we can turn the expression 1 2 a + a b \frac{1}{2|a|} + \frac{|a|}{b} into a single variable function using the condition a + b = 2 a + b = 2 . Let f ( b ) = 1 2 2 b + 2 b b f(b) = \frac{1}{2|2 - b|} + \frac{|2 - b|}{b}

We now take the derivative of f ( b ) f(b) . This results in the piecewise function f ( b ) = 2 ( 4 2 b ) 2 2 b 2 f'(b) = \frac{2}{\left(4-2b\right)^{2}}-\frac{2}{b^{2}} if b < 2 and 2 ( 2 b 4 ) 2 + 2 b 2 -\frac{2}{\left(2b-4\right)^{2}}+\frac{2}{b^{2}} if b > 2 with a discontinuity at b = 2. Since we are trying to find the minimum of f ( b ) f(b) , we must find the critical points of f ( b ) f(b) . It just so happens that in both halves this occurs when b 2 = ( 4 2 b ) 2 b^{2}=\left(4-2b\right)^{2} . Rearranging terms yields the quadratic equation 3 b 2 16 b + 16 = 0 3b^{2} - 16b + 16 = 0 which has the roots b = 1.333 , 4 b = 1.333, 4 .

Since we are given that there exists a global minimum, one of these critical points must be the global minimum (under different circumstances I would have to show that one of these is a global minimum, most likely via a second-derivative test). Plugging both roots into f ( b ) f(b) yields the local minimums (1.333, 1.25) and (4, 0.75). It is clear that M = 0.75 meaning that 1000 M = 750 \lfloor 1000M \rfloor = 750

Let the given sum be S S . Then

l i m a S = 1 , l i m a 0 S = \displaystyle lim_{a \to -\infty } S=1,\displaystyle lim_{a \to 0^{-}} S=\infty

In the range ( , 0 ) (-\infty, 0) , it has one minimum at a = 2 , b = 4 a=-2,b=4 , the minimum value being 0.75 0.75 .

Also, l i m a 0 + S = l i m a 2 S = \displaystyle lim_{a \to 0^{+}} S=\displaystyle lim_{a \to 2^{-}} S=\infty .

Since b > 0 , a < 2 b>0, a<2

In the range [ 0 , ) , s [0,\infty), s has one minimum at a = 2 3 , b = 4 3 a=\frac{2}{3}, b=\frac{4}{3} , the minimum value being 1.25 > 0.75 1.25>0.75 .

Hence the given sum can never be less than 0.75 \boxed {0.75} .

Shouldn’t the limit of given sum when a is approaching to positive or negative infinity be 1?

wing yan yau - 1 year ago

Log in to reply

Yes. You are right. Editing.

0 pending reports

×

Problem Loading...

Note Loading...

Set Loading...