The Broad Street cholera outbreak of 1854 helped demonstrate that cholera was spread by contaminated water. By talking with residents and studying the spread of cholera cases, Dr John Snow was able to pinpoint the water pump that was the source of the outbreak. He disabled the pump by removing its handle, which is popularly reported as ending the outbreak.
The above image was created by Dr Snow. It shows the clusters of cholera cases, which are represented by the black rectangles on each street. Which of the water pumps is the pump that was identified by Dr John Snow?
This section requires Javascript.
You are seeing this because something didn't load right. We suggest you, (a) try
refreshing the page, (b) enabling javascript if it is disabled on your browser and,
finally, (c)
loading the
non-javascript version of this page
. We're sorry about the hassle.
It's even simpler than that. Why would people living around Broad Street go to pumps as far and remote as A, C and D to fetch water? Everyone walks the town's main street, so everyone fetches water at pump B. I apologise for my English...
Yep u are right.. there is a tv show called as 'Mankind The Story Of All Of Us' .. in that also they had shown the same thing!
Log in to reply
Yeah, that's the documentary that I have watched! :)
pump B.
it is pump B
the map is showing that the water has a downward flow.....
i think pump c
it was challenging
its pump A
Log in to reply
why?
explain how
its pump b exactly
ya you can wath this on ted videos
its pump B bcz maximum rectangle marked by Dr. in that area only
i thought it was going to be really trickly
pump B
I agree with Jaydee's reasoning. It is Pump B
certainly B Baka
It is Pump B. If you will analyze the map, it is the area of most residence having cholera. Base of the counts of the black rectangles which are the pumps that caused this disease.
good question
goooood
B
I agree with Jaydee. It is obvious even to the common man.
b
pump B
pump B is answer
is really the image clear to all ??? what did u understand from that image exactly ? can anyone explain it please ????
I actually didn't knew about this case. But by seeing the map, it is observed that most of the cases of cholera are clustered around B and and at other places the cases of cholera is less. It is always seen that the place responsible for the disease has most of the cases around it and less on the other places. So,the correct answer is pump B....
its c
I think I first heard the story of a documentary . It brought cholera to the vicinity of the Broad Street pump water was coming from . And it is obvious map . Most cases of cholera cholera victims or their respective relatives said pump water ( or water to drink ) got very far from the station B. This means that other cases are clustered around .And another way I say the lying in the center of streets and passages, because it is the pump B, the term "outbreak" is to be used. So when the water pump broke b emitted from the the neighborhood.
when i observed the map clearly there is almost equal spread of disease on both the sides of pump B but this situation was not observed with other pumps so i thought it might be PUMP-B
after observation the map the water coming from pump B
Log in to reply
u mean water coming from pump-B only not from others. if that is the case where is the puzzle dear.
I think because there are alot of black rectangles around Pump B which means cholera spreads from pump B so Dr Snow identified and disabled it
The question itself gives us the answer. One can notify the line which says" Dr John Snow was able to pinpoint the water pump that was the source of the outbreak. " Here, the source itself describes the area where cholera cases were more as compared to the other places where it spread to. Cholera spread there as a result of the contamination of water which is more likely from that of the pump B present at that respective street. Hence the water pump identified by Dr.Snow was pump B.
Most cases of the cholera are reported at pump B, and at other pumps the cluster of cholera patients decreases with respect of their distance from pump B.
its pump B, because it lying in the center of street and in the Passage the word "outbreak" is used. so when pump b out broke the water just flowed to the surroundings. Its all common sense.
ellaam oru guess la adichu vidradhu dhaaa ... ha ha ha ...... :D
wht is dat?tamil?
naa guess pannala, logical answer daan click pannen. Ans yes Ephraim Raj this is tamil
The reason is simple because a disease spreads in region which are close to each other and pump b) was located in a crowd full area
if you see closely pump b near of it there is writing broad st.
its pump b as more clusters of cholera rwere found at the place by which water was supplied throughtt this pump
One could easily figure it out that it is pump B , bcoz the black triangles indicating cholera stats are constellated near pump B . And that is the clue
there are more cases near pump b
This is a pretty cool tracking problem, but as usual, the image credit is a huge spoiler alert. If one goes onto the Wikipedia page, they can see that there is an article about the incident, and read "The pump is located at the intersection of Broad Street and Cambridge Street." and I quote exactly. But anyways, to legitimately solve the problem, I would suggest finding where the highest density is located. This is obviously Pump B.
This is obviously Pump B.
You don't have to go to the image credit link :)
Problem Loading...
Note Loading...
Set Loading...
I remembered this when I first heard the story in a documentary. It was the water coming from the pump of Broad Street that brought cholera to the vicinity. And it is obvious in the map. Most of the cases of cholera are clustered near pump B. Other cases far from it means that victims of cholera or their respective relatives got water (or used to get water) from the said pump. What an amazing investigation he had done! :)