Semicircles On A Line

Geometry Level 1

The above shows 3 semicircles on a line.

Which has a larger perimeter?

Green semicircle Blue semicircles Equal length

This section requires Javascript.
You are seeing this because something didn't load right. We suggest you, (a) try refreshing the page, (b) enabling javascript if it is disabled on your browser and, finally, (c) loading the non-javascript version of this page . We're sorry about the hassle.

3 solutions

Zee Ell
Sep 29, 2016

Relevant wiki: Circles - Circumference

Let the radius of the green semicircle be R R and the radius of the smaller (or if they are equal, then one of them) blue be r r

Then:

• the radius of the bigger blue semicircle is R r R - r

• the length of the green line (the perimeter of the green semicircle) is: R π R\pi

• the perimeter of the smaller blue semicircle is: r π r\pi .

• the perimeter of the bigger blue semicircle is: ( R r ) π (R - r)\pi .

• the length of the blue line: r π + ( R r ) π = r π + R π π r π = R π r\pi + (R - r)\pi = r\pi + Rπ\pi- r\pi = R\pi .

Hence, our answer is:

Equal Length \boxed { \text {Equal Length } } .

It doesn't matter how many semicircles we use, or what their individual radius is, the perimeter is going to be the same.

I first did it for equilateral triangles, where the image gave the answer away immediately. I think this is much nicer :)

Chung Kevin - 4 years, 8 months ago

Log in to reply

Yes, this is due to the fact that the sum of the diameters/radii of your many blue semicircles is equal to the diameter/radius of the green semicircle.

Zee Ell - 4 years, 8 months ago
Elliott J
Oct 1, 2016

Let D be the diameter of the big green semicircle, d be the diameter of the left blue semicircle, and δ be the diameter of the right blue semicircle.

IMPORTANT FACT 1: Notice that d + δ = D, since d and δ partition the line segment with length D.

Now the length of the blue line is the sum of the length of the blue semicircles:

π·d/2 + π·δ/2

= π·(d + δ)/2 (By the distriputive law)

= π·D/2 (By important fact 1)

But π·D/2 is the length of the green semicircle!

Thus the blue line and the green line have the same length.

Haytham Connor
Oct 2, 2016

Let a be the diameter of the larger blue semicircle and b be the diameter of the smaller blue semicircle. Taking the total perimeter of the blue semicircles, it would be (a pi)/2 + (b pi)/2. Analyzing the diameter of the green semicircle, we see it's a + b. Taking the diameter of the green semicircle, we see it's (a + b)*pi/2. Comparing our expressions, we see that they are the same. Therefore, the green and blue semicircle perimeters are equal to each other.

No one answered the question -- Which semicircle has the larger perimeter? The perimeter of a semicircle is the diameter plus the length of its arc. The proposed solution needs to include the diameter of each semicircle in its perimeter. Everyone solved for the sum of the blue arcs and found it equal to the green arc and including the diameter in the perimeter of each semicircle would not have changed your answers, but, that did not answer the question. We were asked "which" semicircle has the larger perimeter. We were not asked if the green line was longer than the sum of the blue lines.

It is easy to see by inspection that the green semicircle has the largest perimeter, the larger blue semicircle has the next largest perimeter, and the small blue semicircle has the smallest perimeter. Now, I agree that the question is obviously poorly worded, and the only way for this problem to be a challenge would be to interpret the question as you all did although no one's solution determined the length of the perimeters.

David Toelkes - 4 years, 8 months ago

Log in to reply

Great point, actually.

Haytham Connor - 4 years, 8 months ago

0 pending reports

×

Problem Loading...

Note Loading...

Set Loading...