Sine function

Geometry Level 5

a a and b b are nonnegative real numbers such that sin ( a x + b ) = sin ( 2015 x ) \sin(ax + b) = \sin(2015x) for all integers x x .

Find the smallest possible value of a a .


The answer is 1.902.

This section requires Javascript.
You are seeing this because something didn't load right. We suggest you, (a) try refreshing the page, (b) enabling javascript if it is disabled on your browser and, finally, (c) loading the non-javascript version of this page . We're sorry about the hassle.

2 solutions

Hitesh Yadav
Aug 3, 2020

So one way of solving is the one which Khang Nguyen Thanh has pointed out which is quite marvelous. And if you are wondering for a non generalized version then you might be tempted to do this -> s i n ( a + b ) = s i n ( 2015 x ) sin(a+b)=sin(2015x) for all x , then take three integer values of x 1 , 2 , 3 1,2,3 then Add what you get(You must have got a + b , a + 2 b , a + 3 b a+b,a+2b,a+3b as arguments for sine on LHS And similarly you must have got 2015 , 4030 , 6045 2015,4030,6045 on the RHS as arguments of sine . You add them using the formula for addition of sines. You'll see some cancellations . Subsequently you would convert triple angle formula to single angle and again we'll see some cancellations.In the end convert the answer to the general solution for sine. And you must have got a 2 \frac{a}{2} as some integral multiple of pi plus or minus 2015 2 \frac{2015}{2} Then it is done choose such value of integral multiple such that it does not make your value of a negative . After getting the answer try to generalize .

First, since sin ( b ) = sin ( 0 ) = 0 \sin(b) = \sin(0) = 0 , we have b = n π b = n\pi for some integer n n .

Since sin \sin function has period 2 π 2\pi , we need only consider the cases when b = 0 b = 0 and b = π b = \pi .

Now let b { 0 , π } b \in \{0, \pi\} and a a be any real number.

If for all integers x x , sin ( a x + b ) = sin ( 2015 x ) \sin(ax + b) = \sin(2015x) , then for any integer n n , sin ( ( a + 2 π n ) x + b ) = sin ( a x + b + 2 π n x ) = sin ( a x + b ) = sin ( 2015 x ) \sin((a + 2\pi n)x + b) = \sin(ax + b + 2\pi nx) = \sin(ax + b) = \sin(2015x) for all integers x x as well.

Conversely, assume for some a a and c c that for all integers x x , sin ( a x + b ) = sin ( c x + b ) = sin ( 2015 x ) \sin(ax+b) = \sin(cx + b) = \sin(2015x) .

Then, for all integers x x ,

sin ( a x ) = sin ( a x ) cos ( b ) + cos ( a x ) sin ( b ) cos ( b ) = sin ( a x + b ) cos ( b ) \sin(ax) = \dfrac{\sin(ax) \cos(b) + \cos(ax) \sin(b)}{\cos(b)} = \dfrac{\sin(ax + b)}{\cos(b)}

= sin ( c x + b ) cos ( b ) = sin ( c x ) cos ( b ) + cos ( c x ) sin ( b ) cos ( b ) = sin ( c x ) \qquad\quad\;\;= \dfrac{\sin(cx + b)}{\cos(b)} =\dfrac{\sin(cx)\cos(b) + \cos(cx) \sin(b)}{\cos(b)} = \sin(cx) ,

since sin ( 0 ) = sin ( π ) = 0 \sin(0) = \sin(\pi) = 0 and cos ( 0 ) , cos ( π ) 0 \cos(0),\cos(\pi) \ne 0 .

But then, sin ( a ) = sin ( c ) \sin(a) = \sin(c) and 2 sin ( a ) cos ( a ) = sin ( 2 a ) = sin ( 2 c ) = 2 sin ( c ) cos ( c ) 2\sin(a)\cos(a) = \sin(2a) = \sin(2c) = 2\sin(c)\cos(c) implies cos ( a ) = cos ( c ) \cos(a) = \cos(c) since sin ( a ) = sin ( c ) = sin ( 2015 ) cos ( b ) 0 \sin(a) = \sin(c) = \dfrac{\sin(2015)}{\cos(b)}\ne 0 .

Hence, a a and c c are the same angle, modulo integer multiples of 2 π 2\pi . Now, we consider the two cases concretely.

If b = 0 b = 0 , one valid assignment of a a is a = 2015 a =2015 , so all possible ones are a = 2015 + 2 π n a = 2015 + 2\pi n for integers n n .

The smallest positive number we can make this is 2015 640 π 2015 - 640\pi .

Meanwhile, if b = π b = \pi , one valid assignment of a a is a = 2015 a = -2015 , since sin ( 2015 x + π ) = sin ( 2015 x ) cos ( π ) + cos ( 2015 x ) sin ( π ) = sin ( 2015 x ) = sin ( 2015 x ) \sin(-2015x+\pi) = \sin(-2015x) \cos(\pi) + \cos(-2015x) \sin(\pi) = - \sin(-2015x) = \sin(2015x) . So, all possible ones are a = 2015 + 2 π n a = -2015 + 2\pi n for integers n n .

The smallest positive number we can make this is 642 π 2015 642\pi - 2015 .

Because 642 π 2015 < 2015 640 π 642\pi-2015<2015-640\pi so the answer is 642 π 2015 1.902 642\pi-2015\approx \boxed{1.902} .

0 pending reports

×

Problem Loading...

Note Loading...

Set Loading...