Fraser and Georgina are brother and sister and are playing outside in the snow. They come across a sheet of ice and want to slide on it to collide with each other, at which point they will cling together and let themselves go in whichever direction they go. Fraser's mass is and Georgina's mass is Fraser travels at whereas Georgina travels at
Fraser:
"For us to not move after the collision, it must be true that
"
Georgina:
"If
, I will move backwards after the collision."
Just then, their neighbors Owen and Paddy appear to weigh in on the debate.
Owen:
"It doesn't matter what
is. Fraser will move forward as he is heavier."
Paddy:
"Fraser will move forwards if
"
Who is correct?
Details and Assumptions:
This problem is part of the Snowy Shenanigans set.
This section requires Javascript.
You are seeing this because something didn't load right. We suggest you, (a) try
refreshing the page, (b) enabling javascript if it is disabled on your browser and,
finally, (c)
loading the
non-javascript version of this page
. We're sorry about the hassle.
Considering Fraser's direction as +ve and Georgina's direction as -ve.
Net Momentum before collision = Net Momentum after collision (no non conservative forces, law of conservation of momentum, velocity of center of mass constant)
Net Momentum = Pfraser +Pgeorgia = 60 * 2 + 40 * (-x) = Pnet
Pnet > 0 => x < 3
=> if x < 3 they both will toward Fraser's direction i.e +ve