Solving a Diophantine Fraction

For what positive integer value N < 1000 N < 1000 is N 2 75 5 N + 56 \dfrac {N^2-75}{5N+56} also an integer?


The answer is 241.

This section requires Javascript.
You are seeing this because something didn't load right. We suggest you, (a) try refreshing the page, (b) enabling javascript if it is disabled on your browser and, finally, (c) loading the non-javascript version of this page . We're sorry about the hassle.

33 solutions

Quang Minh Bùi
Jul 23, 2013

Use long division, we can analyse the fraction:

N 2 75 5 N + 56 = ( 5 N + 56 ) ( 5 N 56 ) + 1261 25 ( 5 N + 56 ) = 5 N 56 + 1261 ( 5 N + 56 ) 25 \frac {N^2-75}{5N+56} = \frac {(5N+56)(5N-56)+1261}{25(5N+56)} = \frac {5N-56+\frac {1261}{(5N+56)}}{25}

Thus, 5 N + 56 5N+56 must be a divisor of 1261 1261 , so it's an element of { 1261 , 97 , 13 , 1 , 1 , 13 , 97 , 1261 } \{-1261, -97, -13, -1, 1, 13, 97, 1261\} . So the value of N N must be 241 241 (other cases cause N N negative or not natural), and with N = 241 N = 241 , the fraction is an integer.

Therefore, the solution of the problem is 241 241 .

Moderator note:

This is the best way to solve this problem, several people used some variation of it. Other solutions exist as well, but they are more complicated.

This is really neat! I like it

Matt McNabb - 7 years, 10 months ago

Log in to reply

Thanks...

Quang Minh Bùi - 7 years, 10 months ago

I just bought some popcorn while reading the solutions. So far, your solution is the best. :)

Vincent Miller Moral - 5 years, 11 months ago

Note that N 2 75 5 N + 56 = 1 25 25 N 2 1875 5 N + 56 = 1 25 [ 5 N 56 + 1261 5 N + 56 ] \dfrac{N^2-75}{5N+56}=\dfrac{1}{25}\cdot\dfrac{25N^2-1875}{5N+56}=\dfrac{1}{25}\left[5N-56+\dfrac{1261}{5N+56}\right] . It follows that 1261 5 N + 56 \dfrac{1261}{5N+56} is an integer, so 5 N + 56 5N+56 is a factor of 1261 1261 . Since the positive factors of 1261 = 13 97 1261=13\cdot 97 are 1 , 13 , 97 , 1261 1, 13, 97, 1261 , N > 0 N>0 and 5 N + 56 1 ( m o d 5 ) 5N+56\equiv 1\pmod{5} , we get that 5 N + 56 = 1261 5N+56=1261 or N = 241 N=241 .

This problem had a lot of wrong solutions submitted, where students made numerous unsubstantiated assumptions. For example, 1 solution stated that 1261 was prime, while another stated that the value of N 2 75 5 N + 56 \frac {N^2-75}{5N+56} must be even.

Calvin Lin Staff - 7 years ago

Log in to reply

The statement that N 2 75 5 N + 56 \frac{N^2-75}{5N+56} is not difficult to substantiate. (I am not sure how it helps, though.)

If N N is even, the numerator N 2 75 N^2-75 is odd but the denominator 5 N + 56 5N+56 is even. This will not result in an integer quotient. Therefore N N is odd.

Writing N = 2 n + 1 N = 2n+1 , the fraction becomes 4 n 2 + 4 n 74 10 n + 61 ; \frac{4n^2+4n-74}{10n+61}; since the numerator is even and the denominator is odd, the quotient must be even, QED.

Arjen Vreugdenhil - 5 years, 8 months ago
Ryandk St
May 20, 2014

we assume the expression to be k k , then we have N = 5 k ± 300 + 224 k + 25 k 2 2 N=\frac{5k\pm \sqrt{300+224k+25k^2}}{2}

since N must integer so 300 + 224 k + 25 k 2 300+224k+25k^2 must be perfect square. so 300 + 224 k + 25 k 2 = L 2 ( 25 k + 112 ) 2 ( 5 L ) 2 = 5044 300+224k+25k^2=L^2\Rightarrow (25k+112)^2-(5L)^2=5044

note that when N 8 N≤8 there is no such N N is suitable . so k k must be 0 >0 .

now we divide the 5044 = a × b 5044=a\times b and assume a > b a>b ,then we have a + b = 2 ( 25 k + 112 ) > 0 , a b = 2 ( 5 L ) > 0 a+b=2*(25k+112)>0,a-b=2*(5L)>0 . a b a-b must be multiple of 10 10 . so a = 2 × 13 × 97 , b = 2 , k = 46 , L = 252 a=2\times 13\times 97,b=2,k=46,L=252 .

finally, N = 5 k ± L 2 = 241 , o r , 11 N=\frac{5k\pm L}{2}=241,or,-11 and the answer is 241 241

Sai Krishna
May 20, 2014

given (5N+56)|(N^2-75) , then (5N+56)| (N(5N+56)-5(N^2-75)). this gives that (5N+56)| (56N+375) then 5N+56| (56(5N+56)-5(56N+375)) this gives that 5N+56|1261. but 1261=13*97. integer value of N is possible only if 5N+56=1261 this gives us n=241

Tomas Bayer
Jul 25, 2013

The N N satisfies N 2 75 ( m o d 5 N + 56 ) N^2\equiv 75 \pmod{5N+56} Multiplying by 5 2 5^2 yields ( 5 N ) 2 25 75 ( m o d 5 N + 56 ) (5N)^2\equiv 25\cdot 75 \pmod{5N+56} which is the same as ( 56 ) 2 25 75 ( m o d 5 N + 56 ) (-56)^2\equiv 25\cdot 75 \pmod{5N+56} Hence, 5 N + 56 ( 56 ) 2 25 75 = 1261 5N+56 \mid (-56)^2-25\cdot 75=1261 The divisors of 1261 1261 are { 1 , 13 , 97 , 1261 } \{1,13,97,1261\} and only 1261 1261 is of the form 5 N + 56 5N+56 for some positive integer N N , namely 241 241 .

I really like this solution. It effectively bypasses the long division method which is a little too involved.

Aram Tangboonduangjit - 7 years, 10 months ago

by long division, N 2 75 5 N + 76 = 1 25 ( 5 N 56 + 1261 5 N + 56 ) \frac{N^2-75}{5N+76}=\frac{1} {25}(5N-56+\frac{1261} {5N+56} ) . Note that 1261 = 13 97 1261=13⋅97 .Then the only factor in the form of 5 N + 56 5N+56 is 1261 1261 , so N = 241 N=241 .Indeed, as it gives N 2 75 5 N + 76 = 46 \frac{N^2-75}{5N+76}=46 .So the only answer is 241 241 .

Tan Likai
May 20, 2014

N 2 75 5 N + 56 \frac{N ^ 2 - 75}{5N + 56} is an integer if and only if 5 N + 56 N 2 75 5N + 56 \mid N ^ 2 - 75 . This is equivalent to 5 N + 56 5 N 2 375 5N + 56 \mid 5N ^ 2 - 375 . Combined with the fact that 5 N + 56 5 N 2 + 56 N 5N + 56 \mid 5N ^ 2 + 56N , we have 5 N + 56 56 N + 375 5 N + 45 280 N + 1875 5N + 56 \mid 56N + 375 \Rightarrow 5N + 45 \mid 280N + 1875 . Also 5 N + 56 280 N + 3136 5N + 56 \mid 280N + 3136 , so 5 N + 56 1261 5N + 56 \mid 1261 . Since 1261 is prime, N = 1261 56 5 = 241 N = \frac{1261 - 56}{5} = 241 .

If the given fraction were to be an integer, so is any of its integral multiples. In particular if N^2 – 75 is multiplied by 25, it facilitates division by 5N + 56 as follows: First observe that (5N + 56) (5N – 56) = 25N^2 – 3136. So we write 25(N^2 – 75) = 25N^2 – 1875 = (25N^2 – 3136) + 1261. 25(N^2 – 75) / (5N + 56) = (5N – 56) + [1261 / (5N + 56)]. So it suffices to find N such that 1261 / (5N + 56) = 1. It is easy to see that N = 241 serves the purpose. By actual verification, with N = 241, we find the value of the given fraction = 58006/1261 = 46.

Noel Lo
May 20, 2014

By long division, N^2 -75 = (5N+ 56)(N/5 - 56/25) + 1261/25. Multiplying throughout gives us 25(N^2 -75) = (5N+ 56)(5N-56) + 1261.

Either (5N +56) or (5N-56) is a factor of 1261. For N to be a positive integer < 1000, the only possibility is 5N + 56 = 1261 which gives us 5N = 1205 and hence N = 241. This yields (241^2-75) / (5 x 241+ 56) = 46.

Since 25 ( N 2 75 ) = ( 5 N 56 ) ( 5 N + 56 ) + 1261 25(N^2-75) = (5N-56)(5N+56)+1261 , it follows that 5 N + 56 5N+56 divides N 2 75 N^2-75 if and only if 5 N + 56 5N+56 divides 1261. 1261. Since 1261 = 13 97 1261=13\cdot 97 , the only possibilities are 5 N + 56 5N+56 is 1 , 13 , 97 , 1, 13, 97, or 1261 1261 . Since N N is required to be a positive integer no greater than 1000 1000 it follows that 5 N + 56 = 1261 N = 241 5N+56 = 1261 \implies N=241 .

Tim Vermeulen
Jul 22, 2013

We have to find an N N < 1000 N \in \mathbb{N}_{<1000} such that N 2 75 5 N + 56 Z . \frac{N^2-75}{5N+56} \in \mathbb{Z}. So, 5 N + 56 N 2 75. 5N + 56 \mid N^2 - 75. It follows that 5 N + 56 N ( 5 N + 56 ) 5 ( N 2 75 ) = 56 N + 375. 5N + 56 \mid N \cdot (5N + 56) - 5 \cdot (N^2 - 75) = 56N + 375. Similarly, 5 N + 56 ( 56 N + 375 ) 11 ( 5 N + 56 ) = N 241. 5N + 56 \mid (56N + 375) - 11 \cdot (5N + 56) = N - 241. But we know that for all a Z a \in \mathbb{Z} , a 0 a \mid 0 , so we just let N 241 = 0 N = 241 N-241 = 0 \implies N = 241 . Let's try it out:

N 2 75 5 N + 56 = 24 1 2 75 5 241 + 56 = 58006 1261 = 46 Z . \frac{N^2 - 75}{5N+56} = \frac{241^2-75}{5 \cdot 241 + 56} = \frac{58006}{1261} = 46 \in \mathbb{Z}. Hence, N = 241 N = \boxed{241} .

Zi Song Yeoh
Jul 22, 2013

N 2 75 5 N + 56 = 1 25 ( 5 N 56 + 1261 5 N + 56 ) \frac{N^{2} - 75}{5N + 56} = \frac{1}{25}(5N - 56 + \frac{1261}{5N + 56}) . In order for the fraction to be an integer, ( 5 N + 56 ) 1261 (5N + 56) \mid 1261 . Since 1261 = 13 × 97 1261 = 13 \times 97 , and N N is a positive integer, the only possible value for N N is 241 241 .  It turns out that N = 241 N = 241 is indeed a solution. So, N = 241 N = 241 .

Douglas Zare
Jul 21, 2013

( 5 N + 56 ) ( 5 N 56 ) = 25 N 2 3136. (5N+56)(5N-56) = 25N^2-3136.

If N 2 75 5 N + 56 \frac{N^2-75}{5N+56} is an integer, then so is 25 ( N 2 75 ) 5 N + 56 = 25 N 2 1875 5 N + 56 = 25 N 2 3136 + 1261 5 N + 56 = 5 N 56 + 1261 5 N + 56 \frac{25(N^2-75)}{5N+56} = \frac{25N^2 - 1875}{5N+56} = \frac{25N^2-3136 + 1261}{5N+56} = 5N-56 + \frac{1261}{5N+56} . For the latter to be an integer, ( 5 N + 56 ) 1261 = 13 × 97 (5N+56) | 1261 = 13 \times 97 . The only divisors of 1261 1261 which are congruent to 56 m o d 5 56 \mod 5 are 1 1 and 1261 1261 . If 5 N + 56 = 1 5N+56=1 then N = 11 < 0 N=-11<0 . So, 5 N + 56 = 1261 5N+56 = 1261 is the only possibility, and N = 241 , N 2 75 5 N + 56 = 46 N=241, \frac{N^2-75}{5N+56}=46 .

Aman Tiwari
Jul 27, 2013

Let N 2 75 5 N + 56 = k \frac{N^{2}-75}{5N+56}=k for some integer k. N 2 75 = 5 N k + 56 k N^{2}-75=5Nk +56k . N 2 5 N k 75 56 k = 0 N^{2}-5Nk-75-56k=0 . N = 5 k ± 25 k 2 + 224 k + 300 2 N=\frac{ 5k\pm\sqrt{25k^{2}+224k+300}}{2} . Now because N is a positive integer 25 k 2 + 224 k + 300 25k^{2}+224k+300 must be a perfect square. It is easy to see that ( 5 k + 17 ) 2 < 25 k 2 + 224 k + 300 < ( 5 k + 23 ) 2 (5k+17)^{2}<25k^{2}+224k+300<(5k+23)^{2} .

Now if 25 k 2 + 224 k + 300 = ( 5 k + 18 ) 2 25k^{2}+224k+300=(5k+18)^{2} . k = 6 11 k=\frac{6}{11} which is not an integer. Similarly for 25 k 2 + 224 k + 300 = ( 5 k + 19 ) 2 o r ( 5 k + 20 ) 2 o r ( 5 k + 21 ) 2 25k^{2}+224k+300=(5k+19)^{2} or (5k+20)^{2} or (5k+21)^{2} we don"t get an integer value of k. But for 25 k 2 + 224 k + 300 = ( 5 k + 22 ) 2 25k^{2}+224k+300=(5k+22)^{2} we get k=46 and therefore N = 230 ± ( 5 46 + 22 ) 2 N=\frac{230\pm (5*46 +22)}{2} . N = 11 o r N = 241 N= -11 or N=241 . but given that N is a positive integer therefore N = 241 N=241 .

I don't know if I was supposed to solve in this way, but I could easily calculate the solution using java:

public static void main(String[] args) {

    int i;

    double a;

    for (i = 0; i <= 1000; i++){

        a = (Math.pow(i, 2) - 75)/(5*i + 56);

        if (a == (int)a){

            System.out.println(i);

        }

    }

}

The output of the program was: 241.

suppose N 2 75 5 n + 56 = y \frac{N^{2}-75}{5n+56}=y

N 2 75 = 5 y N + 56 y N^{2}-75=5yN+56y N 2 5 y N 56 y 75 = 0 N^{2}-5yN-56y-75=0

N 1 , 2 = 5 y ± 25 y 2 + 224 y + 300 2 N_{1,2}=\frac{5y\pm \sqrt{25y^{2}+224y+300}}{2}

suppose y = 2 a y=2a N 1 , 2 = 5 a ± 25 a 2 + 112 a + 75 N_{1,2}=5a\pm \sqrt{25a^{2}+112a+75}

suppose again 25 a 2 + 112 a + 75 = k \sqrt{25a^{2}+112a+75}=k 25 a 2 + 112 a + 75 = k 2 25a^{2}+112a+75=k^{2} ( k 5 a ) ( k + 5 a ) = 112 a + 75 (k-5a)(k+5a)=112a+75 from here we can get

a = 23 a=23 and k = ± 126 k=\pm 126

subtitution to N N 1 , 2 = 5 a ± 25 a 2 + 112 a + 75 N_{1,2}=5a\pm \sqrt{25a^{2}+112a+75} N 1 , 2 = 5.23 ± 126 N_{1,2}=5.23\pm 126 N 1 = 241 N_{1}=241 N 2 = 11 N_{2}=-11 ( Not possible because N is integer )

so the answer is 241 241

suppose N 2 75 5 n + 56 = y \frac{N^{2}-75}{5n+56}=y

N 2 75 = 5 y N + 56 y N^{2}-75=5yN+56y N 2 5 y N 56 y 75 = 0 N^{2}-5yN-56y-75=0

N 1 , 2 = 5 y ± 25 y 2 + 224 y + 300 2 N_{1,2}=\frac{5y\pm \sqrt{25y^{2}+224y+300}}{2}

suppose y = 2 a y=2a N 1 , 2 = 5 a ± 25 a 2 + 112 a + 75 N_{1,2}=5a\pm \sqrt{25a^{2}+112a+75}

suppose again 25 a 2 + 112 a + 75 = k \sqrt{25a^{2}+112a+75}=k 25 a 2 + 112 a + 75 = k 2 25a^{2}+112a+75=k^{2} ( k 5 a ) ( k + 5 a ) = 112 a + 75 (k-5a)(k+5a)=112a+75 from here we can get

a = 23 a=23 and k = ± 126 k=\pm 126

subtitution to N N 1 , 2 = 5 a ± 25 a 2 + 112 a + 75 N_{1,2}=5a\pm \sqrt{25a^{2}+112a+75} N 1 , 2 = 5.23 ± 126 N_{1,2}=5.23\pm 126 N 1 = 241 N_{1}=241 N 2 = 11 N_{2}=-11 ( Not possible because N is integer )

so the answer is 241 241

(N^2-75)=0.4{(5N+56)(5N-56)+1261} Take, 5N+56=1261 which gives N=241 and it is less than 1000, positive integer. Taking test: (241 241-75)/(5 241+56)=46 So, value of N=241

N 2 75 5 N + 56 \frac{N^{2}-75}{5N+56}

= 1 25 ( 5 N + 56 ) ( 5 N 56 ) + 1261 5 N + 56 \frac{1}{25}\frac{(5N+56)(5N-56)+1261}{5N+56}

from this fraction we know that (5N+56)(5N-56) divisible by 5N+56 and 1261 also divisible by 5N+56

1261= 13 × 97 13 \times 97 = 1 × 1261 1 \times 1261

5N+56 must be equal to positive factor of 1261 because we find N<1000 and N is positive integer.

  1. 5N+56=1, N=-11 (negative integer)
  2. 5N+56=1261, N=241 (positive integer)
  3. 5N+56=13, N= 43 5 \frac{-43}{5} (not integer)
  4. 5N+56=97, N= 41 5 \frac{41}{5} (not integer)

so possible value of N is 241

Bob Bobson
Jul 27, 2013

Suppose N 2 75 5 N + 56 = k Z \frac{N^2-75}{5N+56} = k \in \mathbb Z . Rearranging this we get N 2 5 k N 56 k = 75 N^2 - 5kN - 56k = 75 , and it is easily verified that ( N + 56 / 5 ) ( N 5 k 56 / 5 ) = 75 ( 56 / 5 ) 2 (N+56/5)(N-5k-56/5) = 75-(56/5)^2 . Multiplying both sides by 25 25 we have ( 5 N + 56 ) ( 5 N 25 k 56 ) = 1261 = 13 × 73 (5N+56)(5N-25k-56) = -1261 = -13 \times 73 . So we see that if N N is a solution, then if d = 5 N + 56 d = 5N+56 then d 13 × 97 d \mid 13\times 97 , and then 5 ( d 56 ) 5 \mid (d-56) so d = 1 mod 5 d = 1 \text{ mod 5} . Clearly only divisors of 13 × 97 13 \times 97 with this property are d = 1 d = 1 or d = 1261 d=1261 . The first gives us N = 11 N = -11 which is negative, and the second gives us N = 241 N = 241 . Plugging this back into the equation above gives us k = 46 k = 46 . So 24 1 2 75 241 5 + 56 = 46 Z \frac{241^2-75}{241*5+56} = 46 \in \mathbb Z . Thus the only solution is N = 241 \boxed{N = 241} .

Sanjay Meena
Jul 26, 2013

By partial fraction,

N^2−75/5N+76

if u didn`t solve by partial fraction i will explain.....now m using shortcut

=1/25(5N−56+1261/(5N+56)).

we check that 1261=13⋅97(both primes)

now 5N+56/1261 must be integer so put 5N+56= 1261,

=> N=241 .

Indeed, now further we check put n=241 gives answer 46.....

Therefore 241 is the correct answer

Technique is basically Partial Fraction

Matt McNabb
Jul 23, 2013

Let k k be the quotient. Rearranging into quadratic form:

N 2 ( 5 k ) N + ( 75 56 k ) = 0 N^2 - (5k)N + (75 - 56k) = 0

Using the method of completing the square , i.e. transforming x 2 + p x + q x^2 + px + q into ( x + p 2 ) 2 p 2 4 + q (x + \frac{p}{2})^2 - \frac{p^2}{4} + q , we get:

( N 5 2 k ) 2 25 4 k 2 75 + 56 k = 0 (N - \frac{5}{2}k)^2 - \frac{25}{4}k^2 - 75 + 56k = 0

Multiply by 2 2 2^2 to remove the fractions:

( 2 N 5 k ) 2 = 25 k 2 + 224 k + 300 (2N - 5k)^2 = 25k^2 + 224k + 300

Now we can complete the square on the right-hand side:

( 2 n 5 k ) 2 = ( 5 k + 22.4 ) 2 ( 22.4 ) 2 + 300 (2n - 5k)^2 = (5k + 22.4)^2 - (22.4)^2 + 300

and again multiply through by 5 2 5^2 to remove fractions:

( 10 N 25 k ) 2 = ( 25 k + 112 ) 2 11 2 2 + 7500 (10N - 25k)^2 = (25k + 112)^2 - 112^2 + 7500

Rearranging:

( 25 k + 112 ) 2 ( 10 N 25 k ) 2 = 5044 (25k + 112)^2 - (10N - 25k)^2 = 5044

Using the identity a 2 b 2 = ( a + b ) ( a b ) a^2 - b^2 = (a+b)(a-b) and factorising 5044 5044 :

( 112 + 10 N ) ( 112 10 N + 50 k ) = 2 2 13 97 (112 + 10N)(112 - 10N + 50k) = 2*2*13*97

Note that these two factors differ by 50 k 20 N 50k - 20N , a multiple of 10.

The only factorization of 2 2 13 97 2*2*13*97 in which the two factors differ by a multiple of 10 is 2 2522 2 * 2522 .

This gives us 112 + 10 N = 2522 112 + 10N = 2522 , i.e. N = 241 N = 241 .

Final note: This proves that there are no solutions except for potentially N = 241 N = 241 . To complete the proof we do need to actually verify that N = 241 N = 241 solves the problem.

This is easily done and we find 46 = 24 1 2 75 5 241 + 56 46 = \frac{241^2 - 75}{5*241 + 56}

Nishant Sharma
Jul 23, 2013

Let the given fraction equal some k k\: \in\: Z \mathbb{Z} . Then N 2 75 = N^{2} -75 =\: 5 N k + 56 k , 5Nk + 56k \:, or

N 2 5 N k 75 56 k = N^{2} - 5Nk -75 -56k =\: 0 0 --- ( i ) (i) which has integer root(s) for N N so it's discriminant is a perfect square i.e.

25 k 2 + 224 k + 300 = 25k^{2} + 224k + 300 =\: p 2 p^{2} --- ( i i ) (ii) for some p p\: \in\: Z + \mathbb{Z^{+}} which again has integer root(s) for k k so it's discriminant is a perfect square i.e.

22 4 2 30000 + 100 p 2 = 224^{2} - 30000 + 100p^{2} =\: n 2 n^{2} for some n n\: \in\: Z + \mathbb{Z^{+}}

\implies\: ( n 10 p ) (n - 10p) ( n + 10 p ) = (n + 10p) =\: 20176 20176 --- ( i i i ) (iii)

Now from -- ( i i ) (ii) we have k = k =\: 224 ± n 50 \frac{-224 \pm n}{50} --- ( i v ) (iv)

Since k k is an integer last two digits of k k should be one of 24 , 74 , 26 , 76 24\:,74\:,26\:,76 . Using this and manually trying out the different possible factorizations of -- ( i i i ) (iii) ( \big( There are only three possible factorizations to try out ) \big) we find ( n 10 p , n + 10 p ) = (n - 10p,n + 10p) =\: ( 4 , 5044 ) (4,5044) \implies\: ( n , p ) = (n,p) =\: ( 2524 , 252 ) (2524,252) .

From ( i v ) , (iv),\: we get k = k =\: 46 46 ( \big( Rejecting the non-integral root ) \big) . From -- ( i ) (i) we obtain N = N =\: 241 \boxed{241} as our answer.

Joe Tomkinson
Jul 23, 2013

Using the notation a b a|b for a a divides b b , we need to find N N where ( 5 N + 56 ) N 2 75 (5N+56)|N^2-75 . We use a b a k b a|b \Rightarrow a|kb and a b a b + k a a|b \Leftrightarrow a|b+ka to make this more approachable. by removing all coefficients of N N from the right side.

( 5 N + 56 ) N 2 75 ( 5 N + 56 ) 5 ( N 2 75 ) = 5 N 2 375 ( 5 N + 56 ) ( 5 N 2 375 ) N ( 5 N + 56 ) = 56 N 375 ( 5 N + 56 ) 5 ( 56 N 375 ) = 280 N 1875 ( 5 N + 56 ) ( 280 N 1875 ) + 56 ( 5 N + 56 ) = 56 56 1875 = 1261 s o ( 5 N + 56 ) 1261 (5N+56)|N^2-75 \quad \Rightarrow\\ (5N+56)|5(N^2-75)=5N^2-375 \Leftrightarrow\\ (5N+56)|(5N^2-375) - N(5N+56) = -56N-375 \Rightarrow\\ (5N+56)|5(-56N-375) = -280N - 1875 \Leftrightarrow\\ (5N+56)|(-280N-1875) + 56(5N+56) = 56\cdot56 - 1875 = 1261 \\\quad so \\ (5N+56)|1261

At the stages where the right hand side has been multiplied up by 5 5 , the implication only works in one direction. The direction means that every solution of the original is captured in the derived equation, but that not every solution to the derived one is also a solution to the original.

Now we have that 5 N + 56 5N+56 is a factor of 1261 = 13 × 97 1261 = 13 \times 97 . The only possible (positive) factors are then 1 , 13 , 97 , 1261 1,13,97,1261 , and only 1261 1261 gives a positive integer value of N N - 241 241 . This has to be checked with the original, and indeed 24 1 2 75 5 241 + 56 = 46 \frac{241^2-75}{5\cdot241+56} = 46 .

One note here is that this implies the restriction N < 1000 N < 1000 is irrelevant, as this is the only solution possible.

Harsa Mitra
Jul 23, 2013

By partial fraction ,N^2−75/5N+76 if u didt solve by partial fraction i will explain.....now m using shortcut =1/25(5N−56+1261/(5N+56)). we check that 1261=13⋅97(both primes) now 5N+56/1261 must be integer so put 5N+56= 1261,=> N=241 .Indeed, now further we check put n=241 gives answer 46.....technique is basically partial fraction

Derek Khu
Jul 23, 2013

Let M = N 2 75 5 N + 56 M = \frac{N^2-75}{5N+56} be an integer. Then C = N 5 M C = N - 5M is also an integer, and we can write N 2 75 5 N + 56 = N C 5 \frac{N^2-75}{5N+56} = \frac{N-C}{5} . Cross-multiplying, we get 5 N 2 375 = 5 N 2 + ( 56 5 C ) N 56 C 5N^2-375=5N^2+(56-5C)N-56C , so ( 56 5 C ) N = 56 C 375 (56-5C)N=56C-375 . Since C C is an integer, then 56 5 C 56-5C is non-zero so we obtain N = 56 C 375 56 5 C N = \frac{56C-375}{56-5C} . We know that N N is positive, so the numerator and denominator must either be both positive or both negative. Since C C is an integer, we have 56 C 375 < 0 C 6 56C-375<0 \Leftrightarrow C \leq 6 and 56 5 C < 0 C 12 56-5C<0 \Leftrightarrow C \geq 12 . Thus, we cannot have both being negative simultaneously and hence both must be positive. So 7 C 11 7 \leq C \leq 11 . Also, since N N is an integer, we have ( 56 5 C ) ( 56 C 375 ) (56-5C) | (56C-375) and thus ( 56 5 C ) [ ( 56 C 375 ) + 11 ( 56 5 C ) ] (56 - 5C) | [(56C-375)+11(56-5C)] , or ( 56 5 C ) ( C + 241 ) (56 - 5C) | (C + 241) . We shall now do casework on C = 7 , 8 , 9 , 10 , 11 C=7,8,9,10,11 to see which works. If C C is even, then 56 5 C 56-5C is even but C + 241 C+241 is odd; so C C is odd. If C = 7 C=7 , then 3 3 divides 56 5 C = 21 56-5C=21 but does not divide C + 241 = 248 C+241=248 . If C = 9 C=9 , then 56 5 C = 11 56-5C=11 does not divide C + 241 = 250 C+241=250 . The only C C left is 11 11 , and indeed, 56 5 C = 1 56-5C=1 divides 11 + 241 = 252 11+241=252 . So N = 56 ( 11 ) 375 56 5 ( 11 ) = 241 N=\frac{56(11)-375}{56-5(11)}=\boxed{241} .

Nguyễn Anh
Jul 22, 2013

(N^2-75)/(5N+76) is an integer so we can consider (N^2 - 75)/(5N + 56)=a (a is a positive integer)

We have the following equation: N^2 - 75 = a(5N + 56) <=> N^2 - 5aN - 75 - 56a = 0 (1)

This equation has integer roots; therefore Delta must equal b^2 (b is a positive integer)

=> (5a)^2 + 4.56a + 4.75 = b^2 <=> (25a)^2 + 100.56a + 100.75 = (5b)^2 <=> (25a+112)^2 - (5b)^2 = 5044 (2)

By solving (2) we have a=46, b=252 (after eliminating unsatisfied roots)

=> (1) <=> N^2 - 230N - 2651 = 0 <=> N = 241

(N^2-75)/(5N+56)=k, we first multiple by 5 so (5N^2-375)/(5N+56)=5k euclid, 5N^2-375=(5N+56)(N-12)+4N+297 look that 5N+56 not multiplication of 5 so 5N+56=4N+297 then \Box {N=241}

Bao Nguyen Le
Jul 22, 2013

n 2 75 5 n + 56 is an integer ( n 2 75 ) ( 5 n + 56 ) 25 ( n 2 75 ) ( 5 n + 56 ) ( 5 n + 56 ) 2 2 56 ( 5 n + 56 ) + 1261 ( 5 n + 56 ) 1261 ( 5 n + 56 ) and 1261 = 13 97 5 n + 56 = 13 or 5 n + 56 = 97 or 5 n + 56 = 1261 n = 241 \frac {n^2-75}{5n+56} \text{ is an integer}\\ \Rightarrow (n^2-75) \vdots (5n+56)\\ \Rightarrow 25(n^2-75) \vdots (5n+56)\\ \Rightarrow (5n+56)^2 - 2 \cdot 56(5n+56) + 1261 \vdots (5n+56)\\ \Rightarrow 1261 \vdots (5n+56)\\\\ \\ \text{ and }1261 = 13 \cdot 97\\ \Rightarrow 5n+56 = 13\\ \text{ or } 5n+56 = 97\\ \text{ or } 5n+56 = 1261\\ \Rightarrow n = 241

Jan J.
Jul 22, 2013

We need 5 N + 56 N 2 75 5N + 56 \mid N^2 - 75 , i.e. there exists a a such that a ( 5 N + 56 ) = N 2 75 a(5N + 56) = N^2 - 75 . Write it as quadratic in N N to get $$N^2 - 5aN - 56a - 75 = 0$$ This has solution $$N = \frac{\pm \sqrt{25a^2 + 224a + 300} + 5a}{2}$$ So it is necessary to have $$25a^2 + 224a + 300 = x^2$$ for some x x . Now note that $$(5a + 23)^2 > 25a^2 + 224a + 300 > (5a + 17)^2$$ i.e. x x is equal to one of 5 a + 18 5a + 18 , 5 a + 19 5a + 19 , \dots , 5 a + 22 5a + 22 . It is easily found that only x = 5 a + 22 x = 5a + 22 yields integral solution $$a = 46$$ Plugging a = 46 a = 46 into $$N = \frac{\pm \sqrt{25a^2 + 224a + 300} + 5a}{2}$$ yields N = 11 N = -11 or N = 241 N = 241 , so $$N = \boxed{241}$$

Francis Naldo
Jul 22, 2013

first. equate it to x, where x is a positive integer..

N 2 N^{2} - 75 = 5xN + 56x to equate it to zero, transpose..

N 2 N^{2} - 5xN - (75+56x) = 0 using the quadratic formula, [ \frac{[5x +- \sqrt{ \( 25x^{2} + 224x + 300] }{2} ]

we'll now find the values of x that give the discriminant positive.. and from that domain, we'll be able to find that the equation is a perfect square (so that means one solution only) which is 241

Adrian Iriciuc
Jul 22, 2013

5n + 56 | n 2 n^{2} - 75

5n + 56 | 5( n 2 n^{2} - 75)

5n + 56 | 5 n 2 n^{2} + 56n - 56n - 5*75

5n + 56 | n(5n + 56) - 56n - 5 * 75

5n + 56 | -56n - 5 * 75 => 5n + 56 | 56n + 5 * 75

5n + 56 | 5(56n + 5 * 75)

5n + 56 | 5*56n + 56 * 56 - 56 * 56 + 5 * 5 * 75

5n + 56 | 56(5n + 56) + 5 5 75 - 56*56 => 5n + 56 | -1261 => 5n + 56 | 1261

1261 = 13 * 97 => 5n + 56 = 97 or 5n + 56 = 1261

  1. 5n + 56 = 97 => 5n = 41 => n is not integer
  2. 5n + 56 = 1261=> n = 241
Daniel Chiu
Jul 21, 2013

Do long division. You get that N 2 75 5 N + 56 = 1 25 ( 5 N 56 + 1261 5 N + 56 ) \dfrac{N^2-75}{5N+56}=\dfrac{1}{25}\left(5N-56+\dfrac{1261}{5N+56}\right) Now, 1261 = 13 97 1261=13\cdot 97 , and so the only factor of 1261 that can be expressed as 5 N + 56 5N+56 is 1261, so N = 241 N=241 . This works, so the answer is 241 \boxed{241} .

0 pending reports

×

Problem Loading...

Note Loading...

Set Loading...