Squares over, now are cubes!

3 9 + 3 12 + 3 15 + 3 n \large 3^{9} + 3^{12} + 3^{15} + 3^{n}

Find the minimum possible value of positive integer n n such that the expression above is a perfect cube.

Try out Cubes over, now are squares!


The answer is 14.

This section requires Javascript.
You are seeing this because something didn't load right. We suggest you, (a) try refreshing the page, (b) enabling javascript if it is disabled on your browser and, finally, (c) loading the non-javascript version of this page . We're sorry about the hassle.

5 solutions

Discussions for this problem are now closed

Otto Bretscher
Mar 31, 2015

Case 1: n < 9 n<9

First we show that 3 9 + 3 12 + 3 15 + 3 n 3^9+3^{12}+3^{15}+3^n fails to be a perfect cube if n < 9 n<9 . Using the binomial expansion, we see that ( 3 5 + 3 ) 3 < 3 9 + 3 12 + 3 15 + 3 n (3^5+3)^3<3^9+3^{12}+3^{15}+3^n < ( 3 5 + 4 ) 3 <(3^5+4)^3 for all n < 9 n<9 . Thus 3 9 + 3 12 + 3 15 + 3 n 3^9+3^{12}+3^{15}+3^n is "trapped" between two consecutive perfect cubes, 24 6 3 246^3 and 24 7 3 247^3 .

Case 2: n 9 n \geq9

We observe that 3 9 + 3 12 + 3 15 + 3 n = 3 9 ( 1 + 3 3 + 3 6 + 3 n 9 ) 3^9+3^{12}+3^{15}+3^n=3^9(1+3^3+3^6+3^{n-9}) = 2 7 3 ( 757 + 3 n 9 ) . =27^3(757+3^{n-9}). We want 757 + 3 n 9 757+3^{n-9} to be a perfect cube. Now the smallest perfect cube exceeding 757 757 is 1000 1000 , and it so happens that 1000 757 1000-757 = 243 = 3 5 . =243=3^5. Thus 3 9 ( 1 + 3 3 + 3 6 + 3 5 ) 3^9(1+3^3+3^6+3^5) = 3 9 + 3 12 + 3 15 + 3 14 = 27 0 3 =3^9+3^{12}+3^{15}+3^{14}=270^3 .

The answer is n = 14 n=14 .

Alex Zhong
Mar 30, 2015

3 9 + 3 12 + 3 15 = 3 9 ( 1 + 27 + 729 ) = 3 9 757. 3^9+3^{12}+3^{15} = 3^9(1+27+729) = 3^9\cdot 757. The closest cubes are 9 3 = 729 , 9^3=729, and 1 0 3 = 1000 10^3=1000 . Since 1000 757 = 243 = 3 5 , n = 9 + 5 = 14 . 1000-757=243=3^5, n=9+5=\boxed{14}.

Moderator note:

Otto Bretscher is right, you need to prove that n < 9 n<9 has no solution.

I only understood after a while. I think you could rephrase it and explain better.

Daniel Luis Costa - 6 years, 2 months ago

You seem to assume that n 9 n\geq9 .

Otto Bretscher - 6 years, 2 months ago

I used the similar process to solve 2 more questions like this, n i think it is simplest approach.;

Mayank Vimal - 6 years, 2 months ago

This solution is based on the flawed assumption that the four terms of 3 9 + 3 12 + 3 15 + 3 n 3^9+3^{12}+3^{15}+3^n must match the four terms of the binomial expansion of ( a + b ) 3 (a+b)^3 . Considering these six cases does not prove that 3 9 + 3 12 + 3 15 + 3 n 3^9+3^{12}+3^{15}+3^n fails to be a perfect cube for n < 14 n<14 .

Otto Bretscher - 6 years, 2 months ago
  • We can rearrange this expression as 3 9 ( 1 + 3 3 + 3 6 + 3 n 9 ) = 3 9 ( 757 3 n 9 ) 3^{9}(1 + 3^{3} + 3^{6} + 3^{n - 9}) = 3^{9}(757 * 3^{n - 9}) .
  • Since 3 9 3^{9} is a perfect cube, we don't have to worry about it anymore.
  • We also can see that 757 3 \frac{757}{3} has 3 as remainder, so does 1000 3 \frac{1000}{3} (who is actually the closest perfect cube with 3 as remainder).
  • Giving a shot, we try 757 + 3 n 9 = 1000 = 1 0 3 757 + 3^{n - 9} = 1000 = 10^{3} 3 n 9 = 243 = 3 5 3^{n - 9} = 243 = 3^{5} n 9 = 5 = > n = 14 n - 9 = 5 => n = 14 .
  • So, we conclude that the minumum possible value of positiver integer n such that the expression in question is a perfect cube is 14 .
Josh Banister
Apr 2, 2015

The first thing I noticed was that 3 n 3^n will be odd for any positive integer n so the sum of 4 of these must be even. As the number is a cube, it must be the product of cube primes. As 2 divides this number, 8 must divide it too. Also, it is the sum of multiples of 3 so the final number must be divisible by 3 cubed or 27. As the terms are multiples of 27, 3 n 3^n must be too so n 3 n \geq 3

In order for the number to be a multiple of 8, consideration is needed for the terms mod 8. 3 9 3 m o d 8 3 12 1 m o d 8 3 15 3 m o d 8 3 n 1 m o d 8 3^9 \equiv 3 \mod 8 \\ 3^{12} \equiv 1 \mod 8 \\ 3^{15} \equiv 3 \mod 8 \\ \implies 3^n \equiv 1 \mod 8 Which shows that n has to be even.

At this point. I started getting lazy so I made a program in VB.net that generates these numbers and I put in that n has to be even as to save time. Luckily, I was able to find n = 14 \boxed{n=14} . Sorry about the anticlimactic ending :(.

0 pending reports

×

Problem Loading...

Note Loading...

Set Loading...