Strange Function

For every n n let d ( n ) d(n) denote the number of positive divisors of n n .

Let f : N N f:N→N be a function such that

i. d ( f ( x ) ) = x d(f(x))=x for all natural numbers x x

ii . f ( x y ) .f(xy) divides ( x 1 ) y x y 1 f ( x ) (x-1)y^{xy-1}f(x)

Find sum of all possible values of f ( 11 ) + f ( 315 ) f(11)+f(315)


The answer is 508371855226.

This section requires Javascript.
You are seeing this because something didn't load right. We suggest you, (a) try refreshing the page, (b) enabling javascript if it is disabled on your browser and, finally, (c) loading the non-javascript version of this page . We're sorry about the hassle.

1 solution

Souryajit Roy
Oct 16, 2014

The result d ( p 1 a 1 . . . . p k a k ) = ( a 1 + 1 ) ( a 2 + 1 ) . . . . . ( a k + 1 ) d(p_{1}^{a_{1}}....p_{k}^{a_{k}})=(a_{1}+1)(a_{2}+1).....(a_{k}+1) will be used throughout

Putting x = 1 x=1 in (i), d ( f ( 1 ) ) = 1 d(f(1))=1 . Hence, f ( 1 ) = 1 f(1)=1 .

Note that f f is one-one

Now, d ( f ( p ) ) = p d(f(p))=p for prime p. Hence, f ( p ) = q p 1 f(p)=q^{p-1} for some prime q. Hence, f ( 2 ) = q 2 1 = q f(2)=q^{2-1}=q , a prime.

Suppose, p > 2 p>2 be a prime.

Putting x = 2 x=2 and y = p y=p in (ii) we get

f ( 2 p ) p 2 p 1 f ( 2 ) f(2p)|p^{2p-1}f(2)

Putting x = p x=p and y = 2 y=2 in (ii) we get

f ( 2 p ) ( p 1 ) 2 2 p 1 f ( p ) = ( p 1 ) 2 2 p 1 q p 1 f(2p)|(p-1)2^{2p-1}f(p)=(p-1)2^{2p-1}q^{p-1}

Suppose p q p≠q .Hence p p does not divide ( p 1 ) 2 2 p 1 q p 1 (p-1)2^{2p-1}q^{p-1} .Hence the greatest common factor of p 2 p 1 f ( 2 ) p^{2p-1}f(2) and ( p 1 ) 2 2 p 1 q p 1 (p-1)2^{2p-1}q^{p-1} is a divisor of f ( 2 ) f(2) .Since f ( 2 p ) f(2p) is a common divisor of them, f ( 2 p ) f(2p) divides f ( 2 ) f(2) . But f ( 2 ) f(2) is a prime and f ( 2 p ) > 1 f(2p)>1 . So, f ( 2 p ) = f ( 2 ) f(2p)=f(2) . contradiction!

So, p = q p=q .Therefore, f ( p ) = p p 1 f(p)=p^{p-1}

Suppose p=2. Putting x = 2 x=2 and y = 3 y=3 in (ii) and again, x = 3 x=3 and y = 2 y=2 in i(i), we get f ( 6 ) 3 5 f ( 2 ) f(6)|3^{5}f(2) and f ( 6 ) 2 6 f ( 3 ) f(6)|2^{6}f(3) .Suppose f ( 2 ) f(2) is odd. Then, f ( 6 ) f ( 3 ) = 9 f(6)|f(3)=9 .Therefore, f ( 6 ) = 1 , 3 , 9 f(6)={1,3,9} .Then, 6 = d ( f ( 6 ) ) = d ( 1 ) , d ( 3 ) , d ( 9 ) = 1 , 2 , 3 6=d(f(6))={d(1),d(3),d(9)}={1,2,3} , which is false. So, f ( 2 ) = 2 f(2)=2

Next, for each n > 1 n>1 , the prime divisors of f ( n ) f(n) are among the ones of n n .Indeed, let p p be the least prime divisor of n n .Putting x = p x=p and y = n p y=\frac{n}{p} in (ii), we get f ( n ) ( p 1 ) y n p p 1 f(n)|(p-1)y^{n-}p^{p-1} .Write f ( n ) = l P f(n)=lP where g c d ( l , n ) = 1 gcd(l,n)=1 and P P is a product of primes dividing n n .Since, l l divides ( p 1 ) y n p p 1 (p-1)y^{n-}p^{p-1} and is co-prime to y n 1 p p 1 y^{n-1}p^{p-1} , l l divides p 1 p-1 .So, d ( l ) l < p d(l)≤l<p . Now, n = d ( f ( n ) ) = d ( l P ) = d ( l ) d ( P ) n=d(f(n))=d(lP)=d(l)d(P) .Hence, d ( l ) n d(l)|n .But d ( l ) < p d(l)<p ,the least prime divisor of n n .So, l = 1 l=1 , proving the claim.

If p p is a prime and a 1 a≥1 ,by the above, the only prime factor of f ( p a ) f(p^{a}) is p p .So, f ( p a ) = p b f(p^{a})=p^{b} .Hence, p a = d ( f ( p a ) = d ( p b ) = b + 1 p^{a}=d(f(p^{a})=d(p^{b})=b+1 .Therefore, f ( p a ) = p b = p p a 1 f(p^{a})=p^{b}=p^{p^{a}-1} .

Finally, show that if n = p 1 a 1 . . . . p k a k n=p_{1}^{a_{1}}....p_{k}^{a_{k}} , f ( n ) = p 1 p 1 a 1 1 . . . . p k p k a k 1 f(n)=p_{1}^{p_{1}^{a_{1}}-1}....p_{k}^{p_{k}^{a_{k}}-1} .

Now, calculate the given sum.

@Souryajit roy are u an inmo awardee?hats off to your brilliance man.

Tejas Suresh - 6 years, 5 months ago

0 pending reports

×

Problem Loading...

Note Loading...

Set Loading...