Strange Kinematic Optimization

A drone is launched from ground level with speed v v and at an angle θ \theta with respect to the ground. It then moves in a parabolic arc under the influence of gravity.

When the drone reaches its highest point, it shoots a projectile whose velocity relative to the drone has a magnitude of v v and an angle of 2 3 θ \frac{2}{3} \theta with respect to the horizontal. The projectile continues on a separate parabolic trajectory before eventually landing on the ground.

Suppose θ \theta' is the value of θ \theta (in degrees) which maximizes the final landing distance of the projectile relative to the initial launch point of the drone. Give your answer as 100 θ \lfloor 100 \, \theta' \rfloor , where \lfloor \cdot \rfloor denotes the floor function.


The answer is 5149.

This section requires Javascript.
You are seeing this because something didn't load right. We suggest you, (a) try refreshing the page, (b) enabling javascript if it is disabled on your browser and, finally, (c) loading the non-javascript version of this page . We're sorry about the hassle.

1 solution

Chris Lewis
Dec 13, 2018

Anticipating dealing with lots of occurrences of 2 3 θ \frac{2}{3}\theta later on, put θ = 3 ψ \theta=3\psi .

The trajectory of the drone is given by

x = v t cos 3 ψ y = v t sin 3 ψ g t 2 2 \begin{aligned} x&=vt\cos{3\psi} \\ y&=vt\sin{3\psi}-\frac{gt^2}{2} \end{aligned}

There are various standard ways to find the highest point, which we'll say has coordinates ( p , q ) (p,q) . We can consider the horizontal and vertical components of the drone's velocity, which are given by

x ˙ = v cos 3 ψ y ˙ = v sin 3 ψ g t \begin{aligned} \dot x&=v\cos{3\psi} \\ \dot y&=v\sin{3\psi}-gt \end{aligned}

At the highest point, y ˙ = 0 \dot y=0 ; which happens when t = v sin 3 ψ g t=\frac{v\sin{3\psi}}{g} , so that

p = v 2 2 g sin 6 ψ q = v 2 g sin 2 3 ψ v 2 2 g sin 2 3 ψ = v 2 2 g sin 2 3 ψ \begin{aligned} p&=\frac{v^2}{2g} \sin{6\psi} \\ q&=\frac{v^2}{g}\sin^2{3\psi}-\frac{v^2}{2g}\sin^2{3\psi}=\frac{v^2}{2g}\sin^2{3\psi} \end{aligned}

Let's tidy this up a bit more. We can choose v v , so let's put v 2 = 2 g v^2=2g ; then we get

p = sin 6 ψ q = sin 2 3 ψ \begin{aligned} p&=\sin{6\psi} \\ q&=\sin^2{3\psi} \end{aligned}

Now, we need to consider the projectile shot by the drone. Let's use τ \tau to measure time from this point (so that the projectile is fired at τ = 0 ) \tau=0) . We are told the projectile is fired at a speed v v and angle 2 3 θ = 2 ψ \frac{2}{3}\theta=2\psi relative to the drone.

At its highest point, the vertical component of the drone's velocity is zero; the horizontal component is v cos 3 ψ v\cos{3\psi} . Hence the initial velocity of the projectile is ( v cos 3 ψ + v cos 2 ψ , v sin 2 ψ ) (v\cos{3\psi}+v\cos{2\psi},v\sin{2\psi})

The trajectory of the projectile is

x = p + v ( cos 3 ψ + cos 2 ψ ) τ y = q + v τ sin 2 ψ g τ 2 2 \begin{aligned} x&=p+v(\cos{3\psi}+\cos{2\psi})\tau \\ y&=q+v\tau\sin{2\psi}-\frac{g\tau^2}{2} \end{aligned}

To find the overall range, R R of the projectile, we need to find x x when y = 0 y=0 . Say this happens when τ = T \tau=T .

0 = q + v T sin 2 ψ g T 2 2 T = v sin 2 ψ ± v 2 sin 2 2 ψ + 2 g q g \begin{aligned} 0&=q+vT\sin{2\psi}-\frac{gT^2}{2} \\ T&=\frac{v\sin{2\psi} \pm \sqrt{v^2\sin^2{2\psi}+2gq}}{g} \end{aligned}

We want the positive root. Substituting in,

R = p + v ( cos 3 ψ + cos 2 ψ ) v sin 2 ψ + v 2 sin 2 2 ψ + 2 g q g = p + 2 ( cos 3 ψ + cos 2 ψ ) ( sin 2 ψ + sin 2 2 ψ + q ) \begin{aligned} R&=p+v(\cos{3\psi}+\cos{2\psi})\frac{v\sin{2\psi} + \sqrt{v^2\sin^2{2\psi}+2gq}}{g} \\ &=p+2(\cos{3\psi}+\cos{2\psi})(\sin{2\psi} + \sqrt{\sin^2{2\psi}+q}) \end{aligned}

where again we've made use of our choice v 2 = 2 g v^2=2g . Plugging in p p and q q ,

R = sin 6 ψ + 2 ( cos 3 ψ + cos 2 ψ ) ( sin 2 ψ + sin 2 2 ψ + sin 2 3 ψ ) \begin{aligned} R&=\sin{6\psi}+2(\cos{3\psi}+\cos{2\psi})(\sin{2\psi} + \sqrt{\sin^2{2\psi}+\sin^2{3\psi}}) \end{aligned}

This can be maximised either numerically (directly) or by setting the derivative equal to zero and solving that numerically. Either way gives ψ 17.163 8 \psi\approx17.1638^\circ , θ 51.491 4 \theta\approx51.4914^\circ and the answer 100 θ = 5149 \lfloor 100\theta' \rfloor=\boxed{5149}

@Steven Chase Desmos says that maximum holds at θ = 0.899 \theta = 0.899 radians , so that gives the answer as 5150.

Ankit Kumar Jain - 2 years, 2 months ago

Log in to reply

Lol I put in 5150 as my last try and still got it wrong :(

Krishna Karthik - 1 year, 1 month ago

You need to go to more decimal places. By asking for the answer in the given form, we need a tolerance of 0.0 1 0.01^{\circ} ; but 0.001 0.001 radians is 0.05 7 0.057^{\circ} .

Chris Lewis - 2 years, 2 months ago

0 pending reports

×

Problem Loading...

Note Loading...

Set Loading...