Superconducting rails and magnetic friction

Two identical wires with resistance R R and mass m m rest on two smooth parallel superconducting (zero resistance) rails. Initially, they are separated by a distance D = 70 cm D=70~\mbox{cm} . Suddenly, a uniform magnetic field B B , perpendicular to the plane of the rails is switched on and the wires start rolling. What will be the final distance in centimeters between the wires? Assume that the wires are thin and that the process of switching on the magnetic field happens very fast.


The answer is 35.

This section requires Javascript.
You are seeing this because something didn't load right. We suggest you, (a) try refreshing the page, (b) enabling javascript if it is disabled on your browser and, finally, (c) loading the non-javascript version of this page . We're sorry about the hassle.

3 solutions

Nam Nguyễn Hồ
May 20, 2014

Assume l l is the distance between two rails. The appearance of the magnetic field give each wire an initial momentum towards each other as follows: P i = F d t = B l i d t = B l × D l 2 R × d B d t d t = D l 2 2 R B d B = B 2 l 2 D 4 R P_{i}=\int F \mathrm{d}t = \int Bli \mathrm{d}t = \int Bl\times \frac{Dl}{2R}\times \frac {dB}{dt}\mathrm{d}t=\frac{Dl^2}{2R}\int B\mathrm{d}B=\frac{B^2l^2D}{4R}

Lorentz forces applied on the wires slow them down: m d v d t = B l i = B l × B l 2 R × d D d t = B 2 l 2 2 R × d D d t ( 1 ) m\frac{dv}{dt}=Bli=Bl\times \frac {Bl}{2R}\times \frac{dD}{dt}=\frac {B^2l^2}{2R} \times \frac{dD}{dt} (1)

Intergrate both side of equation ( 1 ) (1) from ( m v i = P i = B 2 l 2 D 4 R ; D i = D ) (mv_{i}=P_{i}=\frac{B^2l^2D}{4R};D_{i}=D) to ( m v f = 0 ; D f ) (mv_{f}=0;D_{f}) : D 2 = D f D -\frac{D}{2}=D_{f}-D

Finally D f = D 2 = 35 ( c m ) D_{f}=\frac{D}{2}=35(cm)

Ngô Long
May 20, 2014

Cause the process of switching on the magnetic field happens very fast, we can ssume that the wires does not move during this process, we have: I = ϵ 2 R = D 0 l d B d t 2 R I = \frac {\epsilon}{2R} = - \frac {D_0 l \frac {dB}{dt}} {2R}

m d v d t = B I l = D 0 l 2 2 B d B d t \Rightarrow m \frac {dv}{dt} = BIl = - \frac {D_0 l^2}{2} \frac {B dB}{dt}

So the velocity v 0 v_0 of the wires right after the macnetic field reaches value of B is: v 0 = D 0 l 2 B 2 4 m R v_0 = - \frac {D_0 l^2 B^2}{4mR}

Next, the wires move under the effect of macnetic field:

m d v d t = B ϵ 2 R l = B B v l 2 R l m \frac{dv}{dt} = B \frac{\epsilon}{2R} l = - B \frac{Bvl}{2R} l (1)

We also have 2 v = d D d t 2v = - \frac {dD}{dt}
(2) From (1) and (2): Δ D = D 0 2 \Delta D = \frac{D_0}{2}

Finally we have the distance between the wires is D 0 2 = 35 c m \frac{D_0}{2} = 35cm

Adam Silvernail
May 20, 2014

The inward force on the wires of a conducting loop relate to the change in external magnetic flux.

Initially, the magnetic field is considered 0. Therefore, the flux within the area of the perfectly conducting loop is B A = 0 B*A=0 .

When a magnetic field B is suddenly switched on, the new flux is equal B A B*A . In order to balance this change in flux, the wires must move to generate an opposite flux until reaching a final flux of 0. Because the wires and rails are frictionless, superconducting, and rigid, we can assume that there are no other forces in the system to consider aside from the lateral force on the wires.

First, let the length of each wire be given by L, and assume the system remains rectangular due to the uniform force exerted on each wire. Since B is considered uniform and constant, the change in flux due to the wires moving inward may be given by: B A B A = B ( A ( A A ) ) B*A' - B*A''=B*(A'-(A-A')) , where A = L 70 A=L*70 cm is the original area formed by the wires and rails, A = L D A'=L*D is the final area formed by the wires and rails, and A'' is the change in area: A = A A A''=A - A' .

Therefore,

B L ( D ( 70 c m D ) ) = 0 B*L*( D - (70 cm -D) )=0

Solving this equation for D, B L ( 2 D 70 c m ) = 0 B*L*(2D - 70 cm) = 0 . Assuming that B and L are nonzero constants, ( 2 D 70 c m ) = 0 (2D - 70 cm)=0 . Therefore D=35 cm.

Conceptually, the wires generate an opposing flux by creating a decreasing flux inside the loop and an equal and opposite increasing flux outside the loop. This is why the wires only need to move halfway towards each other to balance the total flux.

0 pending reports

×

Problem Loading...

Note Loading...

Set Loading...