Surviving elimination

In every round of a certain game show, v v votes are cast by the public to decide which contestants out of c c contestants continue to the next round. The contestant with the lowest amount of votes in every round is eliminated. The next round proceeds with c 1 c - 1 contestants, and so on. What is the minimum number of votes needed to guarantee that a contestant will proceed to the next round, assuming that he/she does not forfeit?

  • c c is updated at the start of every round to represent the number of remaining contestants.

  • v v may vary with each round.

  • Every round, one contestant must be eliminated by voting, forfeit, or tiebreaker.

  • c 2. c \geq 2.

v 2 \frac{v}{2} v c \frac{v}{c} v 2 + 1 \frac{v}{2} + 1 v c + 1 \frac{v}{c} + 1

This section requires Javascript.
You are seeing this because something didn't load right. We suggest you, (a) try refreshing the page, (b) enabling javascript if it is disabled on your browser and, finally, (c) loading the non-javascript version of this page . We're sorry about the hassle.

1 solution

Tan Li Xuan
Oct 5, 2014

First, we conjecture that v c \frac{v}{c} is the answer.

We must show that:

1) v c 1 \frac{v}{c} - 1 will not work.

and

2) v c \frac{v}{c} votes can guarantee that a contestant will pass to the next round.

First, we prove 1).

This can be proved easily by taking v c 1 \frac{v}{c} - 1 votes for contestant 1, v c \frac{v}{c} for contestants 2 to c 1 c - 1 and v c + 1 \frac{v}{c} + 1 for contestant c c .

Then, we prove 2).

Suppose that a contestant loses with a total of v c \frac{v}{c} votes. Then, the other contestants must all have at least v c + 1 \frac{v}{c} + 1 votes. The total sum is v + ( c 1 ) v + ( c - 1 ) , which is obviously larger than v v . So we have a contradiction.

Now, it would seem that the answer is v c \frac{v}{c} . However, one question arises : What if all the contestants are tied in a c c -way tie? As unlikely as it is, it is still a possibility, and the tiebreaker will result in one contestant losing, thus contradicting our assumption that v c \frac{v}{c} is sufficient to guarantee that a contestant will proceed to the next round.

So, we take the next smallest value, v c + 1 \frac{v}{c} + 1 as our answer. A quick check confirms that this value satisfies the conditions, and we are done. \blacksquare

0 pending reports

×

Problem Loading...

Note Loading...

Set Loading...