Take the Centre of Mass, I Dare You!

Consider a homogenous rod of length L L and mass M M , and a point-sized object of mass m m , kept at a distance L L from one end of the rod, as shown in the figure.

Let the magnitude of force of gravitational attraction be F F

If F = ( a b ) ( G M m L 2 ) F=(\frac{a}{b})(\frac{GMm}{L^2}) , where a , b a,b are coprime, natural numbers, find a + b a+b


The answer is 3.

This section requires Javascript.
You are seeing this because something didn't load right. We suggest you, (a) try refreshing the page, (b) enabling javascript if it is disabled on your browser and, finally, (c) loading the non-javascript version of this page . We're sorry about the hassle.

2 solutions

In this problem, taking centre of mass of the rod and finding its attraction with the point is wrong. This method will yield

F = 4 G M m 9 L 2 F=\frac{4GMm}{9L^2} , thus a + b = 13 a+b=13 .

This method is incorrect as the force distribution for each point on the rod is different, and non-contradictory.

Thus, let us use calculus to solve this problem.

Consider a small part of the rod of length d x dx , with mass d M dM , and let this small part's distance from the point-mass be x x

Thus, d F = G ( d M ) m x 2 dF=\frac{G(dM)m}{x^2} . However, we cannot integrate this, as the variables do not match. Thus, we must find d M dM in terms of d x dx , or x x in terms of M M .

Let us do the former option, as it would eliminate the variable.

Now, consider linear density λ \lambda . Since the rod is homogenous, and the small part of the rod has the same linear density, we get

λ = d M d x = M L \lambda=\frac{dM}{dx}=\frac{M}{L} , which means that d M = M L d x dM=\frac{M}{L}dx

Plugging into the force equation, we get d F = ( G M m L ) 1 x 2 d x dF=(\frac{GMm}{L})\frac{1}{x^2}dx

Now, the limits of this integration must be from L L to 2 L 2L , as the minimum distance of any point on the rod from the point mass is L L , and the maximum distance is 2 L 2L

Thus, integrating, we get F = L 2 L ( G M m L ) ( 1 x 2 ) d x = G M m L [ 1 x 2 ] L 2 L = G M m L [ 1 2 L 1 L ] = G M m 2 L 2 F=\int_L^{2L}(\frac{GMm}{L})(\frac{1}{x^2})dx=\frac{GMm}{L}[\frac{-1}{x^2}]_L^{2L}=\frac{-GMm}{L}[\frac{1}{2L}-\frac{1}{L}]=\boxed{\frac{GMm}{2L^2}}

Thus, a = 1 , b = 2 a=1,b=2 and a + b = 3 a+b=3

Mvs Saketh
Oct 17, 2014

No thanks , i would use integration instead

LoL......!! even I also prefer calculus.

Deepanshu Gupta - 6 years, 7 months ago

0 pending reports

×

Problem Loading...

Note Loading...

Set Loading...