That was a close call!

A heavy body of mass m m (shown in grey) approaching Earth with initial velocity v 0 v_0 in the absence of interaction has an aiming parameter a a . At the instant of closest approach to Earth, its distance from the surface of Earth is given by

b = G M e ( v 0 ) y [ x + ( a ( v 0 ) y z G M e ) 2 1 ] R e , b = \dfrac{GM_e}{{(v_0)}^{y}} \left[ \sqrt{x + {\left( \dfrac{a \ {(v_0)}^{y}}{z \ GM_e} \right)}^2} -1 \right] - R_e,

where x , y , x , y, and z \ z are positive constants.

Find x + y + z x + y + z .

Details and Assumptions:

  • Assume there are no other external bodies other than Earth and the heavy body. The only mutual force of gravitation that exists is between them.
  • Neglect the size of the heavy body, i.e. treat it as a particle of mass m m .
  • G G denotes the universal gravitational constant, i.e. G = 6.67 × 1 0 11 N m 2 kg 2 G = 6.67 \times 10^{-11} \text{ N m}^2 \text{ kg}^{-2} .
  • M e M_e denotes the mass of Earth, i.e. M e = 5.972 × 1 0 24 kg M_e = 5.972 \times 10^{24} \text{ kg} .
  • R e R_e denotes the radius of Earth, i.e. R e = 6371 km R_e = 6371 \text{ km} .
  • Assume that rotation and revolutions of Earth are absent for this problem.


The answer is 4.

This section requires Javascript.
You are seeing this because something didn't load right. We suggest you, (a) try refreshing the page, (b) enabling javascript if it is disabled on your browser and, finally, (c) loading the non-javascript version of this page . We're sorry about the hassle.

2 solutions

Tapas Mazumdar
Jan 28, 2017

At the instant of closest approach the particle velocity is perpendicular to the radius vector joining the center of the Earth to the particle. Thus applying law of conservation of angular momentum, we get

m v 0 a = m v ( R e + b ) . mv_0a = mv(R_e+b).

where v v is the speed of the particle at the instant of closest approach.

For the sake of calculations we'll denote R e + b R_e + b as r r .

So, from the above equation

v = a v 0 r . . . ( 1 ) v = \dfrac{a v_0}{r} \qquad ...(1)

Also applying conservation of mechanical energy, we get

1 2 m v 0 2 = 1 2 m v 2 + E . . . ( 2 ) \dfrac 12 m {v_0}^2 = \dfrac 12 m v^2 + E \qquad ...(2)

where E E denotes the field intensity of Earth at distance r r from the center.

Now,

E = G M e m r . . . ( 3 ) E = - \dfrac{GM_e m}{r} \qquad ...(3)

Substituting the value for v v and E E from equations ( 1 ) (1) and ( 3 ) (3) in equation ( 2 ) (2) , we get

1 2 m v 0 2 = 1 2 m a 2 v 0 2 r 2 G M e m r 1 2 ( a 2 v 0 2 r 2 v 0 2 ) = G M e r v 0 2 2 ( a 2 r 2 r 2 ) = G M e r v 0 2 a 2 v 0 2 r 2 = 2 G M e r v 0 2 r 2 + 2 G M e r v 0 2 a 2 = 0. \begin{aligned} \dfrac 12 m {v_0}^2 &= \dfrac 12 m \dfrac{a^2 \ {v_0}^2}{r^2} - \dfrac{GM_e m}{r} \\ \implies \dfrac 12 \left( \dfrac{a^2 \ {v_0}^2}{r^2} - {v_0}^2 \right) &= \dfrac{GM_e}{r} \\ \implies \dfrac{{v_0}^2}{2} \left( \dfrac{a^2 - r^2}{r^2} \right) &= \dfrac{GM_e}{r} \\ \implies {v_0}^2 a^2 - {v_0}^2 r^2 &= 2GM_e r \\ \implies {v_0}^2 r^2 + 2GM_e r - {v_0}^2 a^2 &= 0. \end{aligned}

Which is a quadratic in r r . Solving for r r , we get

r = 2 G M e + 4 G 2 M e 2 + 4 v 0 4 a 2 2 v 0 2 Neglecting negative value = G M e v 0 2 + G M e v 0 2 1 + v 0 4 a 2 G 2 M e 2 = G M e ( v 0 ) 2 [ 1 + ( a v 0 2 G M e ) 2 1 ] . \begin{aligned} r &= \dfrac{-2GM_e + \sqrt{4G^2{M_e}^2 + 4 {v_0}^4 a^2}}{2{v_0}^2} \qquad \qquad \small \color{#3D99F6}{\text{Neglecting negative value}} \\ &= -\dfrac{GM_e}{{v_0}^2} + \dfrac{GM_e}{{v_0}^2} \sqrt{ 1 + \dfrac{{v_0}^4 a^2}{G^2 {M_e}^2}} \\ &= \dfrac{GM_e}{{(v_0)}^2} \left[ \sqrt{1 + {\left( \dfrac{a \ {v_0}^{2}}{\ GM_e} \right)}^2} -1 \right]. \end{aligned}

As r = b + R e r = b + R_e , therefore

b = G M e ( v 0 ) 2 [ 1 + ( a ( v 0 ) 2 G M e ) 2 1 ] R e . b = \dfrac{GM_e}{{(v_0)}^2} \left[ \sqrt{1 + {\left( \dfrac{a \ {(v_0)}^{2}}{\ GM_e} \right)}^2} -1 \right] - R_e.

which gives

x = 1 y = 2 z = 1 x + y + z = 4 . x=1 \\ y=2 \\ z=1 \\ \implies x+y+z = \boxed{4}.

Nice problem, but one slight error (I was a bit puzzled but managed to get the correct answer): the denominator of the quadratic solution should be 2 v 0 2 2v_0^2 not 2 2 .

Shaun Leong - 4 years, 4 months ago

Log in to reply

This means that my further calculations are wrong. Now wonder why many people got the answer wrong. Very thankful to you for pointing this mistake out.

Tapas Mazumdar - 4 years, 4 months ago

I have made necessary corrections to the problem.

Tapas Mazumdar - 4 years, 4 months ago

Shouldn't we include field intensity at a distance a a as well? In the equation after ( 3 ) (3) , equation will be LaTeX: 1 2 m v 0 2 G M e m a = 1 2 m a 2 v 0 2 r 2 G M e m r \begin{aligned} \dfrac 12 m {v_0}^2 - \dfrac{GM_e m}{a} &= \dfrac 12 m \dfrac{a^2 \ {v_0}^2}{r^2} - \dfrac{GM_e m}{r} \ \end{aligned}

Ajinkya Shivashankar - 4 years, 4 months ago

Log in to reply

You missed an important part of the problem statement:

A heavy body of mass m m (shown in grey) approaching Earth with initial velocity v 0 v_0 in the absence of interaction has an aiming parameter a a .

Which indirectly tells us that the grav. field intensity at the initial case was 0.

Tapas Mazumdar - 4 years, 4 months ago

The figure is a bit wrong.The mass will not go in a straight line path as shown in the figure .It will follow a curved path as it approaches earth.

Aaron Jerry Ninan - 4 years, 4 months ago

Log in to reply

Yes. I know that. But the tool I used to make this figure wasn't fit for drawing curves of that sort.

Tapas Mazumdar - 4 years, 4 months ago

What software do you use.

Aaron Jerry Ninan - 4 years, 4 months ago

A really nice problem, that I decided to post my handwritten solution to it, even though it shares a similar approach discussed in past solutions here. Enjoy.

0 pending reports

×

Problem Loading...

Note Loading...

Set Loading...