There are 13 doors: 3 Cars + 10 Goats. (1 behind each, your task is to pick a door that has a car behind it).
You choose a door.
Monty reveals 1 Car + 3 Goats behind 4 other doors. (Now there are 9 doors: 2 Cars + 7 Goats).
You have a choice to stick or to swap doors.
After the choice Monty Shuffles the other objects behind the remaining doors, and then reveals 1 Car and 5 Goats. (Now there are 3 doors: 1 Car + 2 Goats).
You have a final choice to stick or to swap doors.
With optimal play, the odds to win a Car can be written as a fraction in simplest form: .
What is ?
Bonus : What if Monty didn't shuffle before revealing the 1 Car and 5 Goats?
This section requires Javascript.
You are seeing this because something didn't load right. We suggest you, (a) try
refreshing the page, (b) enabling javascript if it is disabled on your browser and,
finally, (c)
loading the
non-javascript version of this page
. We're sorry about the hassle.
There are four different ways to play the game: you could stick both times, stick then swap, swap then stick, or swap both times.
If you stick both times, you have a 1 3 3 chance of winning the car, regardless of the revealing and swapping of Monty, because there are 3 cars out of 1 3 doors at the time when you pick in the first round. These odds are equivalent to a 1 3 3 = 2 0 8 4 8 chance
If you swap then stick, there are two paths to winning the car: picking a door with a goat in the first round then swapping to a door with a car in the second round (goat-car), or picking a door with a car in the first round then swapping to a door with a car in the second round (car-car). For the goat-car path, there is a 1 3 1 0 chance of picking the door with the goat in the first round (because there are 1 0 goats out of 1 3 doors) and then a 8 2 chance of swapping to a door with a car (because there are 2 cars out of the 8 doors available to swap to), for a 1 3 1 0 ⋅ 8 2 = 1 0 4 2 0 chance. For the car-car path, there is a 1 3 3 chance of picking the door with the car in the first round (because there are 3 cars out of 1 3 doors) and then a 8 1 chance of swapping to a door with a car (because there is only 2 − 1 = 1 car left out of the 8 doors available to swap to since you are currently on a door with a car), for a 1 3 3 ⋅ 8 1 = 1 0 4 3 chance. These two paths add up to a 1 0 4 2 0 + 1 0 4 3 = 1 0 4 2 3 = 2 0 8 4 6 chance.
If you stick then swap, there are two paths to winning the car: picking a door with a goat in the first round then swapping to a door with a car in the third round (goat-car), or picking a door with a car in the first round then swapping to a door with a car in the third round (car-car). For the goat-car path, there is a 1 3 1 0 chance of picking the door with the goat in the first round (because there are 1 0 goats out of 1 3 doors) and then a 2 1 chance of swapping to a door with a car (because there is 1 car out of the 2 doors available to swap to), for a 1 3 1 0 ⋅ 2 1 = 1 3 5 chance. For the car-car path, there is a 1 3 3 chance of picking the door with the car in the first round (because there are 3 cars out of 1 3 doors) and then a 2 0 chance of swapping to a door with a car (because there no cars available out of the 2 doors left to swap to since you are currently on a door with a car), for a 0 chance. These two paths add up to a 1 3 5 + 0 = 1 3 5 = 2 0 8 8 0 chance.
If you swap both times, there are four paths to winning the car: picking a door with a goat in the first round then swapping to a door with a goat in the second round then swapping to a door with a car in the third round (goat-goat-car), picking a door with a goat in the first round then swapping to a door with a car in the second round then swapping to a door with a car in the third round (goat-car-car), picking a door with a car in the first round then swapping to a door with a goat in the second round then swapping to a door with a car in the third round (car-goat-car), or picking a door with a car in the first round then swapping to a door with a car in the second round then swapping to a door with a car in the third round (car-car-car). For the goat-goat-car path, there is a 1 3 1 0 chance of picking the door with a goat in the first round (because there are 1 0 goats out of 1 3 doors) and then a 8 6 chance of swapping to a door with another goat (because there are 7 − 1 = 6 goats left out of the 8 doors available to swap to since you are currently on a door with a goat) and then a 2 1 chance of swapping to a door with a car (because there is 1 car out of the 2 doors available to swap to), for a 1 3 1 0 ⋅ 8 6 ⋅ 2 1 = 2 0 8 6 0 chance. For the goat-car-car path, there is a 1 3 1 0 chance of picking the door with a goat in the first round (because there are 1 0 goats out of 1 3 doors) and then a 8 2 chance of swapping to a door with a car (because there are 2 cars out of the 8 doors available to swap to) and then a 2 0 chance of swapping to a door with a car (because there no cars available out of the 2 doors left to swap to since you are currently on a door with a car), for a 0 chance. For the car-goat-car path, there is a 1 3 3 chance of picking the door with a car in the first round (because there are 3 cars out of 1 3 doors) and then a 8 7 chance of swapping to a door with another goat (because there are 7 goats out of the 8 doors available to swap to) and then a 2 1 chance of swapping to a door with a car (because there is 1 car out of the 2 doors available to swap to), for a 1 3 3 ⋅ 8 7 ⋅ 2 1 = 2 0 8 2 1 chance. For the car-car-car path, there is a 1 3 3 chance of picking the door with a car in the first round (because there are 3 cars out of 1 3 doors) and then a 8 1 chance of swapping to a door with a car (because there are 2 − 1 = 1 cars left out of the 8 doors available to swap to since you are currently on a door with a car) and then a 2 0 chance of swapping to a door with a car (because there no cars available out of the 2 doors left to swap to since you are currently on a door with a car), for a 0 chance. These four paths add up to a 2 0 8 6 0 + 0 + 2 0 8 2 1 + 0 = 2 0 8 8 1 chance.
Therefore, the optimal play would be to swap both times for a 2 0 8 8 1 chance of winning. This means that a = 8 1 and b = 2 0 8 , and a + b = 2 8 9 .