The power of triples #2

Calculus Level 1

22 2 555 , 33 3 444 , 44 4 333 , 55 5 222 \large 222^{555}, 333^{444}, 444^{333}, 555^{222}

Which of these four numbers has the largest value?

22 2 555 222^{555} 33 3 444 333^{444} 55 5 222 555^{222} 44 4 333 444^{333}

This section requires Javascript.
You are seeing this because something didn't load right. We suggest you, (a) try refreshing the page, (b) enabling javascript if it is disabled on your browser and, finally, (c) loading the non-javascript version of this page . We're sorry about the hassle.

5 solutions

Akiva Weinberger
May 3, 2015

Let's start with the immediately obvious inequality: 2 5 111 > 3 4 2^5\cdot111>3^4 . (Note that the left-hand-side is clearly more than 100 100 , while the right-hand-side is only 81 81 .)

Multiplying by 11 1 4 111^4 , we get 2 5 11 1 5 > 3 4 11 1 4 2^5\cdot111^5>3^4\cdot111^4 , or 22 2 5 > 33 3 4 222^5>333^4 . Raising to the 111 st 111\text{st} power, we get: 22 2 555 > 33 3 444 222^{555}>333^{444} We prove that 33 3 444 > 44 4 333 333^{444}>444^{333} in a similar way; this time, start off by noticing that 3 4 111 > 4 3 3^4\cdot111>4^3 , and follow the same argument. Again, 44 4 333 > 55 5 222 444^{333}>555^{222} can be proven using the same argument if you start with 4 3 111 > 5 2 4^3\cdot111>5^2 .

Moderator note:

Yes. This is the correct approach. Using calculus, can you show that the first number is larger than the fourth number? This applies for the second number is larger than the third number. Hint: let f ( x ) = ln x x f(x) = \frac{ \ln x }{x} .

Excellent solution, very convincing and a very clean argument. Have you tried Part III , it's similar to this puzzle but slightly more difficult.

Stewart Feasby - 6 years, 1 month ago
Otto Bretscher
May 6, 2015

Since the second to fourth numbers are all less than 66 6 444 666^{444} , it suffices to show that 66 6 444 < 22 2 555 666^{444}<222^{555} , or , after taking 111th roots, show that 66 6 4 < 22 2 5 666^4<222^5 . But 66 6 4 = 3 4 22 2 4 < 22 2 5 666^4=3^4222^4<222^5 since 3 4 = 81 < 222. 3^4=81<222.

Moderator note:

Great bounding of values!

@Otto Bretscher How did you come up with the idea of comparing with 66 6 444 666^{444} ?

Ankit Kumar Jain - 4 years, 3 months ago
James Moors
May 4, 2015

My first thought, when I saw the question, was to take the logarithm of everything. So... l o g a ( 22 2 555 ) = 555 l o g a ( 222 ) = 555 ( l o g a ( 111 ) + l o g a ( 2 ) ) l o g a ( 33 3 444 ) = 444 l o g a ( 333 ) = 444 ( l o g a ( 111 ) + l o g a ( 3 ) ) l o g a ( 44 4 333 ) = 333 l o g a ( 444 ) = 333 ( l o g a ( 111 ) + l o g a ( 4 ) ) l o g a ( 55 5 222 ) = 222 l o g a ( 555 ) = 222 ( l o g a ( 111 ) + l o g a ( 5 ) ) log_a(222^{555}) = 555\:log_a(222) = 555(log_a(111)+log_a(2))\\ log_a(333^{444}) = 444\:log_a(333) = 444(log_a(111)+log_a(3))\\ log_a(444^{333}) = 333\:log_a(444) = 333(log_a(111)+log_a(4))\\ log_a(555^{222}) = 222\:log_a(555) = 222(log_a(111)+log_a(5)) It's entirely up to me to which base to take logs, so let a = 2 a=2 .

First, we want to compare 555 ( l o g 2 ( 111 ) + l o g 2 ( 2 ) ) 555(log_2(111)+log_2(2)) and 444 ( l o g 2 ( 111 ) + l o g 2 ( 3 ) ) 444(log_2(111)+log_2(3)) . This is equivalent to comparing l o g 2 ( 111 ) + 5 l o g 2 ( 2 ) log_2(111) + 5\:log_2(2) and 4 l o g 2 ( 3 ) 4\:log_2(3) . Now, 6 < l o g 2 ( 111 ) < 7 6<log_2(111)<7 , making the former equal to at least 11 11 . Moreover, l o g 2 ( 3 ) < 2 log_2(3)<2 , so the latter is at most 8 8 , whence 22 2 555 > 33 3 444 222^{555} > 333^{444} .

The same argument holds for 22 2 555 222^{555} and 44 4 333 444^{333} ; now you have 2 l o g 2 ( 111 ) 2\:log_2(111) which dominates the inequality, and the former is larger again.

Similarly for 55 5 222 555^{222} .

22 2 555 444 = 856 > 555 S o 22 2 555 l a r g e s t . Root of the biggest power and still bigger than the biggest number-base. \Large 222^{\frac{555}{444}}=856>555 ~~So~~222^{555} ~ largest.\\ \text {Root of the biggest power and still bigger than the biggest number-base.}

Moderator note:

Can you solve this without a calculator? Note that this question can be done simply by using properties of indices.

Joshua Benabou
May 9, 2015

Another cute way which generalizes the problem: prove that ( 111 a ) 7 a > ( 111 ( a + 1 ) ) 6 a (111a)^{7-a}>(111(a+1))^{6-a} . It's equivalent to 111 ( a + 1 ) > ( 1 + 1 a ) 7 a 111(a+1)>(1+\frac{1}{a})^{7-a} . Note that 1 + 1 a < 2 1+\frac{1}{a}<2 , so if the opposite of our inequality was true, then 111 ( a + 1 ) < 2 7 a 111(a+1)<2^{7-a} which is clearly false for a 1 a \ge 1 . Thus the function ( 111 a ) 7 a (111a)^{7-a} is strictly decreasing for a 1 a \ge 1 .

0 pending reports

×

Problem Loading...

Note Loading...

Set Loading...